Series · Part 4, article 10 of 23Revelation and physical fulfillment · What did Jesus say to John the Baptist in prison? Matthew 11:2–6 and Luke 7

Part 4 · article 31 of 70

What did Jesus say to John the Baptist in prison? Matthew 11:2–6 and Luke 7

Part 2 of 2 on this passageBack: John the Baptist

9 min readHow we check sources

Short answer

This is the second part of the study of John the Baptist. The first part sets out how Shincheonji uses John’s story and what the Bible says about doubt, Luke 1 and Elijah; this part covers John’s question from prison, his disciples and the New Covenant, and Jesus’ own defense of John.

Notice carefully: John did not abandon his mission or renounce Jesus.

When John sent his disciples to ask if Jesus was the One, Christ did not rebuke John.

Bible quotations are from the NET Bible.

On this page (7 sections)
  1. Short answer
  2. 1. John’s question from prison and Jesus’ answer
  3. 2. John’s disciples and the New Covenant
  4. 3. Jesus’ own defense of John
  5. Where to go next
  6. Frequently asked questions
  7. Sources

1. John’s question from prison and Jesus’ answer

When John the Baptist, confined in prison, sent his disciples to ask Jesus, “Are you the one who is to come, or should we look for another?” (Matthew 11:2–3, NET), this was not an act of betrayal. It was a moment of human struggle, a man isolated, facing imminent death, and wrestling with how the Messiah’s ministry was unfolding differently than expected. Far from turning away from Christ, John turned toward him.

Notice carefully: John did not abandon his mission or renounce Jesus. Instead, he sent his disciples directly to Christ for confirmation. This shows that even in his doubt, he anchored his hope in Jesus. He sought reassurance not from men, but from the Messiah himself. And Jesus did not rebuke John — instead, he responded with evidence of fulfilled prophecy: “The blind see, the lame walk, lepers are cleansed, the deaf hear, the dead are raised, and the poor have good news proclaimed to them” (Matthew 11:5, NET). Then, in front of the crowds, Jesus declared John to be the greatest born of women (Matthew 11:11).

“Jesus answered them, “Go tell John what you hear and see: The blind see, the lame walk, lepers are cleansed, the deaf hear, the dead are raised, and the poor have good news proclaimed to them —and blessed is anyone who takes no offense at me!””

— Matthew 11:4–6 (NET)

When John sent his disciples to ask if Jesus was the One, Christ did not rebuke John. Instead, he immediately turned to the crowds and gave one of the strongest commendations in Scripture (Matthew 11:7–11; Luke 7:24–28).

PhraseMeaning
“A reed shaken by the wind?” (NET)John was not weak or unstable; he stood firm in conviction.
“A man dressed in soft clothing?” (NET)John was no court flatterer like Herod’s yes-men, but lived a life of self-denial in the wilderness.
“A prophet? Yes, I tell you, and more than a prophet” (NET).John was the fulfillment of Malachi 3:1 — the messenger sent to prepare the way for the Lord.
“among those born of women, no one has arisen greater than John the Baptist” (NET).No one before John was more righteous or more central to God’s redemptive plan.

This testimony directly rebukes any attempt to dishonor John or call him a betrayer.

Even if John did waver in prison, his response was not betrayal. Instead of abandoning Christ, he sent his disciples to verify Jesus’ identity. Whether this was for his own reassurance or for his disciples’ benefit, John’s actions pointed them directly to the Messiah. His faith sought confirmation from Jesus himself, showing reliance, not rejection.

The only certainty we have about John’s faith is not speculation about his inner struggle, but Christ’s own words about him. Jesus declared John to be firm, faithful, and the greatest prophet, chosen to prepare the way for the Lord.

Luke 7:29–30 records the divided response to Jesus’ testimony about John. The ordinary people, even tax collectors, acknowledged God’s righteousness because they had received John’s baptism. They recognized John’s ministry as God’s work and therefore affirmed the justice of his plan. In contrast, the Pharisees and experts in the law rejected John’s baptism, and in doing so, Scripture says they “rejected God’s purpose for themselves” (NET). To accept or reject John was ultimately to accept or reject the God who had sent him.

Jesus then compared that generation to children who could not be pleased (Luke 7:31–35). The people dismissed John as demon-possessed because of his ascetic lifestyle, while accusing Jesus of being a glutton and friend of sinners because of his fellowship with the outcasts. Yet both John and Jesus were faithfully carrying out the missions entrusted to them by God. The criticisms of “this generation” exposed their spiritual blindness — their refusal to recognize God’s work — rather than any failure in John or Christ.

2. John’s disciples and the New Covenant

Shincheonji often argues that John the Baptist failed in his mission because not all of his disciples immediately followed Jesus. They suggest that John should have ordered his followers to abandon him and go to Christ. But this misunderstands both John’s role and the way discipleship unfolded in the Gospels.

The Gospels show that John’s disciples were divided in their response. Some remained with him even after his public testimony about Jesus (John 3:22–30). These disciples expressed confusion, even envy, when Jesus’ ministry began to grow. In his final testimony, however, John clarified his position: he was not the Bridegroom but the friend of the Bridegroom, declaring, “He must become more important while I become less important” (NET). John’s role was to shine as a lamp until the Bridegroom appeared, and then to fade so that all attention would be on Christ.

Others, such as Andrew and Peter, received John’s witness and followed Jesus (John 1:35–42). Yet their full transition into discipleship only occurred after John was imprisoned, when Jesus began his public ministry (Mark 1:14–20). John’s task was never to command people to leave him, but to prepare them so that when Jesus called, they would recognize and follow him.

As for Mark 2:18–22, where John’s disciples are mentioned alongside the Pharisees in questioning Jesus about fasting, this does not indicate rebellion or betrayal. They were simply practicing the traditions of the law, which Jesus affirmed as valid until all was fulfilled (Matthew 5:18). Their questions reflected misunderstanding, not rejection. Jesus responded by pointing them to a new reality: his presence as the Bridegroom marked a time for joy, not fasting.

It is also important to remember that both John the Baptist and his disciples still lived under the Old Covenant. The New Covenant had not yet been fully enacted until Christ’s death and resurrection (Luke 22:20; Hebrews 9:15–17). John’s role, then, was transitional, bridging the Old Covenant to the New by preparing a people for the Messiah.

Jesus declared, “I tell you the truth, among those born of women, no one has arisen greater than John the Baptist. Yet the one who is least in the kingdom of heaven is greater than he is!” (NET) This verse has sometimes been misunderstood as if Jesus were diminishing John’s righteousness or implying he was unfaithful. But that is not the meaning.

John was the greatest prophet under the Old Covenant — the culmination of all who came before him, preparing the way for the Messiah. His greatness lay in his unique role as the forerunner of Christ. Yet even the least in the kingdom of heaven would be greater, not because of superior character or righteousness, but because of their place within the New Covenant.

After the cross and Pentecost, those who believe in Christ receive what John never experienced in his lifetime: the fullness of the Spirit, the adoption as children of God, and the eternal redemption secured by Jesus’ death and resurrection. The kingdom Jesus inaugurated brings not only external testimony, but internal transformation through grace. This is the greatness of the New Covenant — that by grace and the Spirit’s indwelling, even the least believer shares in a reality that surpasses the greatest figures under the old.

John the Baptist stood as the culmination of the Old Testament prophets. Scripture testifies that he prepared the way for the Messiah (Matthew 3:3; Isaiah 40:3), was filled with the Holy Spirit even from the womb (Luke 1:15), lived a life wholly devoted and separated for God’s purpose, and served as the bridge between the Old Covenant and the New. Jesus himself called him “more than a prophet” (Matthew 11:9, NET). Among those born under the old covenant, John was the pinnacle — the greatest born of women.

Yet Jesus immediately pointed to something greater: “The one who is least in the kingdom of heaven is greater than he” (Matthew 11:11, NET). This was not a rebuke of John’s faithfulness but a declaration that the New Covenant, secured by Christ’s death and resurrection, would bring an even greater reality. From John’s time forward, the kingdom of heaven was advancing in conflict (Matthew 11:12–13), but its fulfillment in Christ would usher in the Spirit, adoption, and redemption. Jesus even identified John as the prophesied Elijah (Matthew 11:14), underscoring his unique role in God’s plan.

Luke 7:31–35 shows how John and Jesus were both misunderstood. The crowds accused John of having a demon because of his strict asceticism, and they accused Jesus of being a glutton and drunkard because of his fellowship with sinners. But Jesus concludes: “Wisdom is vindicated by all her children” (NET) — meaning that the works of John and Jesus themselves prove the wisdom of God.

Those who were baptized by John recognized God’s justice (Luke 7:29), while the Pharisees and experts in the law rejected God’s purpose by rejecting him (Luke 7:30). To claim that John was wicked, demon-possessed, or a betrayer is to stand with the blind generation that Jesus rebuked as childish and undiscerning. Scripture and Christ’s own words vindicate John the Baptist as faithful, chosen, and the greatest prophet of the old covenant.

3. Jesus’ own defense of John

Luke 7:33–35 records Jesus’ direct defense of John the Baptist:

“For John the Baptist has come eating no bread and drinking no wine, and you say, ‘He has a demon!’ The Son of Man has come eating and drinking, and you say, ‘Look at him, a glutton and a drunk, a friend of tax collectors and sinners!’ But wisdom is vindicated by all her children.””

— Luke 7:33–35 (NET)

In this statement, Jesus does three things at once. First, he defends John against the slander that his strict lifestyle meant he was demon-possessed. Second, he defends himself, pointing out that his willingness to fellowship with sinners drew the opposite accusation of indulgence. Together, these show that the critics could never be satisfied — their rejection revealed their hardness, not any fault in John or Jesus. Finally, Jesus concludes by saying that true wisdom is vindicated by its results. John’s ministry bore righteous fruit in those who repented and were baptized, just as Jesus’ ministry bore the fruit of salvation.

To agree with John’s accusers is, in effect, to stand against Jesus himself. It is to call God’s wisdom foolishness. But Christ’s words stand as his final verdict: John was no betrayer, no failure, and no demon-possessed man. He was the greatest prophet of the old covenant, and his deeds — and Jesus’ own testimony — vindicate his faithfulness.

Where to go next

  1. 30Did John the Baptist betray Jesus? Matthew 11:2–3previous in this passage
  2. 21Is God’s revelation complete in Christ? Hebrews 1, Colossians 2 and Jude 3
  3. 20Does Jesus warn against someone who comes in his name? Matthew 24 and Galatians 1
  4. 14Promised pastor: is Lee Man-hee “the one who overcomes” and the male child?
  5. 2The history of Shincheonji: from the Tabernacle Temple to 1984
  6. 8How Shincheonji interprets the Bible

Frequently asked questions

Did Jesus rebuke John for the question from prison?

When John sent his disciples to ask if Jesus was the One, Christ did not rebuke John.

Instead, he immediately turned to the crowds and gave one of the strongest commendations in Scripture (Matthew 11:7–11; Luke 7:24–28).

Did John fail because not all of his disciples followed Jesus?

Shincheonji often argues that John the Baptist failed in his mission because not all of his disciples immediately followed Jesus.

They suggest that John should have ordered his followers to abandon him and go to Christ.

What does Jesus’ defense of John in Luke 7:33–35 show?

To agree with John’s accusers is, in effect, to stand against Jesus himself.

It is to call God’s wisdom foolishness.

Sources

BVC lesson pages used.

Lesson 28, Lesson 37, Lesson 44 and Lesson 59.

Closer Look Initiative.

“John the Baptist Did Not Betray,” closerlookinitiative.com/archives/12737. (This article is part 2 of 2.) Sections used: “Did John the Baptist Betray?” through Jesus’ defense in Luke 7:33–35, without the promo box and the page intro. Bible Vaccine Center and Closer Look Initiative are run by the same team.

Scripture.

NET Bible, quoted as (NET).

Scripture quotations are from the NET Bible®, https://netbible.com, copyright ©1996, 2019 by Biblical Studies Press, L.L.C. Used by permission. All rights reserved.