Series · Part 4, article 21 of 23Revelation and physical fulfillment · Wheat and tares: is the field the church or the world? Matthew 13, Jeremiah 31:27 and Acts 17:30

Part 4 · article 42 of 70

Wheat and tares: is the field the church or the world? Matthew 13, Jeremiah 31:27 and Acts 17:30

Part 2 of 2 on this passageBack: Did the light go out?

17 min readHow we check sources

Short answer

This is the second part of the study of light and darkness. The first part covers the light, the Spirit, the Good Shepherd and the two readings of “light”; this part takes up the parable of the wheat and the tares as one whole section, with Jeremiah 31:27, Acts 17:30 and 1 Corinthians 13:12.

Shincheonji often points to Acts 17:30 and 1 Corinthians 13:12 to argue that Christianity lived in ignorance until the present time of “fulfillment” through SCJ.

Bible quotations are from the NET Bible.

On this page (5 sections)
  1. Short answer
  2. 1. The parable of the wheat and the tares
  3. Where to go next
  4. Frequently asked questions
  5. Sources

1. The parable of the wheat and the tares

This section takes up SCJ’s main appeal to the parable of the wheat and the tares. SCJ’s Genesis commentary says:

In SCJ’s own words

“In this parable the good seed is the word of God, and the man who sowed it is Jesus. The field is Jesus’ church, and the enemy is the devil”

— The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 301

BVC’s lesson page: 1, parable of the weeds and wheat; 15, seed and field, part one.

Is the field the church or the world?

From a Shincheonji (SCJ) perspective, the “field” in the parable of the wheat and the tares (Matthew 13:24–30) is not simply the entire world in a general sense, but more specifically the religious world—what they call the “world of Christianity.” They argue that since Jesus likens the kingdom of heaven to the sowing of seed, the field must represent the sphere where God’s word is planted and expected to grow, namely the church. In their interpretation, the “good seed” are those who receive and understand the revealed word, while the “weeds” are those planted by the devil—false pastors, doctrines, and believers within Christianity who corrupt and oppose the truth. Thus, the field becomes the battleground of God’s word and Satan’s lies, and the parable illustrates how both true and false believers coexist in the same religious world until the time of harvest, when God’s chosen worker (whom SCJ identifies as the Promised Pastor) gathers the good seed into the barn (their church) and burns the weeds. This framing allows SCJ to argue that salvation is only possible through their interpretation of the parable and their leader’s role in the harvest.

In Matthew 13:38, Jesus leaves no room for reinterpretation: “The field is the world and the good seed are the people of the kingdom. The poisonous weeds are the people of the evil one” (NET). The Lord himself defines the terms of his parable, and his words are clear and authoritative. Yet when faced with this plain explanation, Shincheonji often shifts the meaning of the “field” away from “the world” and insists it refers only to the world of Christianity. This is not done because of biblical context, but because their interpretation collapses if taken at face value. By redefining what Jesus has already defined, they place Lee Man-hee’s commentary above Christ’s own interpretation, showing that their authority rests not in Scripture but in a man’s word. When a group must adjust or override the plain meaning of Jesus’ teaching to maintain their theology, it exposes their method: twisting Scripture to fit doctrine, rather than letting doctrine flow from Scripture.

If we take the field in Matthew 13 to mean only the world of Christianity, then Jesus’s teaching in this parable would contradict his own instructions elsewhere and the consistent apostolic witness. In Matthew 13:30, Jesus says: “Let both grow together until the harvest” (NET). Yet later, in Matthew 18:15–18, he commands the church to discipline and even remove an unrepentant brother or sister. If the field is limited to the body of Christ, then Jesus would be saying two opposing things: “Let both grow together until the harvest” (NET) and remove them now.

The apostles reinforce this command. Paul rebukes the Corinthian church for tolerating blatant sin: “Remove the evil person from among you” (1 Cor. 5:13, NET). He distinguishes sharply between judging those inside the church and leaving those outside to God (1 Cor. 5:12), which only makes sense if the “field” is the whole world, not just the church. He also warns believers not to be unequally yoked with unbelievers, emphasizing separation from darkness (2 Cor. 6:14–17). Titus echoes this principle, urging the rejection of divisive people who persist in sin (Titus 3:10–11).

If the field meant only the world of believers, then none of these passages would hold together. Jesus and the apostles would be contradicting themselves—commanding the church both to tolerate and not to tolerate unrepentant sinners in its midst. The only way the parable makes consistent sense is if the “field” refers, just as Jesus explicitly said in Matthew 13:38, to the world. In the world, the righteous and the wicked grow side by side until the final judgment. Within the church, however, discipline is commanded to preserve holiness and witness. SCJ’s redefinition of “the field” collapses under the weight of the New Testament’s own testimony.

Here’s a potential response from SCJ.

Shincheonji would reconcile these verses by arguing that they operate on two different levels of separation. They claim the parable of the wheat and tares in Matthew 13 refers to the final, eschatological harvest at the Second Coming, when God’s appointed pastor separates true believers (wheat) from false believers (weeds). By contrast, passages like Matthew 18, 1 Corinthians 5, 2 Corinthians 6, and Titus 3 deal only with local church discipline during the church age, where unrepentant or divisive members are temporarily removed to protect the congregation but not yet finally judged. In their view, this distinction between temporary discipline and final separation allows them to maintain that the “field” is the world of Christianity, since both wheat and weeds coexist until the ultimate harvest, while still affirming that local churches should deal with disruptive members in the meantime.

This potential response is not quoted from an SCJ book or lesson.

Jeremiah 31:27 and the seed of man and seed of beast

SCJ’s Genesis commentary says:

In SCJ’s own words

“The seed of man, which was promised in Jer 31:27, refers to the seed of the Son of Man and represents the word of God that Jesus preached. The seed of beasts represents the words of the devil”

— The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 453

From a Shincheonji perspective, Jeremiah 31:27 foreshadows the parable of the wheat and tares in Matthew 13:24–30. The prophecy says that God will sow both the seed of mankind and the seed of animals within Israel and Judah. They would argue that this dual sowing finds its ultimate fulfillment in Jesus’ parable: the “good seed” planted by the Son of Man represents God’s seed, while the “weeds” sown by the enemy reflect Satan’s seed. To strengthen this, they point to passages where an animal or beast symbolizes a person lacking divine understanding (Ps. 49:20; Prov. 30:2–3; Ps. 73:22), suggesting that the seed of animals means those born of Satan’s deception, who resemble beasts in their ignorance. By contrast, humans were created in God’s image (Gen. 1:26), so the seed of mankind is identified with God’s truth and his children. In SCJ’s interpretation, Jeremiah 31’s imagery prophetically points to two lineages—God’s seed and Satan’s seed—coexisting in the same field, just as Jesus later describes in Matthew 13, and to be separated at the time of harvest through God’s promised pastor.

At first glance, it might seem clever to connect Jeremiah 31:27 with Matthew 13 because both mention two kinds of seed. But a closer reading shows that this connection actually distorts both passages and results in calling God the devil. In Jeremiah 31:27, the Lord himself declares, in the wording SCJ’s books use, that he will sow the house of Israel and the house of Judah with the seed of mankind and the seed of animals. God is the one doing the sowing, both of man and beast. But in Matthew 13:37–39, Jesus clearly explains the parable: “The one who sowed the good seed is the Son of Man. The field is the world and the good seed are the people of the kingdom. The poisonous weeds are the people of the evil one, and the enemy who sows them is the devil” (NET). If you merge the two texts the way SCJ does, you end up with a theological contradiction: the same God who plants Israel’s restoration in Jeremiah is suddenly identified as the devil sowing tares in Matthew.

The error in Shincheonji’s interpretation is that it tears Jeremiah 31 out of its historical and covenantal context and forces it into Matthew 13. Jeremiah 31 is not teaching about two opposing spiritual lineages but about the restoration of Israel and Judah after judgment and exile. The Babylonians had devastated the land, leaving it desolate of people and animals. Against this backdrop, God promises renewal:

NET reads Jeremiah 31:27 this way:

““Indeed, a time is coming,” says the Lord, “when I will cause people and animals to sprout up in the lands of Israel and Judah. In the past I saw to it that they were uprooted and torn down, that they were destroyed and demolished and brought disaster. But now I will see to it that they are built up and firmly planted. I, the Lord, affirm it!”

— Jeremiah 31:27–28 (NET)

The wording seed of man and seed of beast in SCJ’s quotation and in the text below comes from older English translations, not from NET.

This promise echoes other Old Testament restoration prophecies:

Ezekiel 36:9–11: “I will multiply your people … The cities will be populated and the ruins rebuilt … I will increase the number of people and animals on you; they will increase and be fruitful” (NET).

Hosea 2:18–23: God promises to betroth Israel again and restore creation, including animals, as part of his covenant faithfulness.

The “seed of man” and the “seed of beast” are therefore literal — God is promising to repopulate the land with both humans and animals, reversing the devastation of exile. Far from symbolizing two lineages (God’s vs. Satan’s), these verses symbolize the fullness of flourishing life under God’s renewed covenant blessings.

The flow of Jeremiah 31 confirms this:

  • vv. 27–28: Rebuilding and repopulation.
  • vv. 29–30: Personal accountability for sin (no longer suffering for the fathers’ guilt).
  • vv. 31–34: The climactic promise of the New Covenant, fulfilled in Christ (cited directly in Hebrews 8:8–12).

By contrast, Matthew 13 addresses an entirely different issue: the coexistence of good and evil until the final judgment. Jesus explicitly defines the terms: “The one who sowed the good seed is the Son of Man. The field is the world and the good seed are the people of the kingdom. The poisonous weeds are the people of the evil one, and the enemy who sows them is the devil” (Matt. 13:37–39, NET). Here the contrast is not between man and beast but between God’s children and Satan’s children, culminating in final separation at the harvest.

The similarity of “seed” imagery is superficial. Agricultural metaphors recur throughout Scripture, but they must be read in context. To merge Jeremiah 31 and Matthew 13 not only distorts both passages but also produces a theological contradiction: it would make God, who sows in Jeremiah 31, identical with Satan, the enemy sower in Matthew 13. The consistent biblical reading preserves Jeremiah 31 as a covenant-restoration text pointing forward to Christ and the New Covenant, and Matthew 13 as a kingdom parable about judgment.

By contrast, Matthew 13’s parable of the wheat and the tares is not about physical restoration but about the spiritual reality of good and evil coexisting in the world until the final judgment. Jesus himself explains that the good seed are the sons of the kingdom, the weeds are the sons of the evil one, and the enemy is the devil (Matt. 13:37–39). The similarity of “seed” language does not prove the passages are parallel; it simply demonstrates how agricultural imagery recurs in different contexts to teach different truths. Forcing them together not only misinterprets Jeremiah’s historical setting, but also risks identifying God as the one who sows Satan’s seed — a conclusion that contradicts Jesus’s plain words.

PointShincheonji InterpretationBiblical Context
Who sows both seeds?God sows both the seed of man (truth) and the seed of beast (Satan’s lies).Jeremiah 31: God repopulates the land with literal people and animals after exile. Matthew 13: The Son of Man sows the good seed; the devil sows the weeds.
Seed of manGod’s children (truth).Literal people of Israel restored to the land (Ezek. 36:11).
Seed of beastSatan’s children (lies).Literal animals restored to the land (Ezek. 36:11; Hos. 2:18).
Theme of Jeremiah 31Prophecy of two spiritual lineages within Christianity to be separated at harvest.Promise of restoration, rebuilding, and the New Covenant with Israel and Judah.
Theme of Matthew 13The “field” is the world of Christianity; wheat = SCJ, tares = false churches.The “field” is the world; wheat = sons of the kingdom, tares = sons of the evil one; final separation at the end of the age.
Contradiction in SCJ’s viewMakes God the one who plants Satan’s seed (since in Jer. 31 God is the sower).No contradiction: Jeremiah speaks of historical restoration; Matthew speaks of eschatological judgment.

Supporting Scriptures

  • Psalms 49:20; Prov. 30:2–3; Ps. 73:22 (misapplied to force “beast = evil”).
  • Ezekiel 36:9–11; Hosea 2:18–23; Hebrews 8:8–12 confirm Jeremiah 31 is about restoration, not opposing seeds.

Jeremiah 31 is not pointing to two spiritual seeds in the church age but to the restoration of Israel after exile and the promise of something greater — the New Covenant. After promising to repopulate the land with man and beast (Jer. 31:27–28), God moves to the climax in verses 31–34: “Indeed, a time is coming” (NET), says the Lord, “when I will make a new covenant with the people of Israel and Judah” (NET). This is not an abstract prophecy about invisible lineages; it is a covenant promise to a real people in a real land. That is why Jesus, the mediator of the New Covenant (Heb. 8:6–12), had to come to physical Israel. He came as a Jew, born under the Law (Gal. 4:4), to fulfill the promises made to the patriarchs (Rom. 15:8) and to establish the covenant Jeremiah foresaw.

Jesus’s earthly ministry was rooted in this historical context. He preached first to “the lost sheep of the house of Israel” (Matt. 15:24, NET), because Jeremiah’s prophecy was given to Israel and Judah. The restoration Jeremiah spoke of — repopulation, rebuilding, and covenant renewal — finds its ultimate fulfillment not in the multiplication of physical man and beast alone, but in the arrival of the Messiah who brought forgiveness, renewal, and the Spirit. Jesus’s presence in physical Israel was therefore essential: the promises of Jeremiah and the prophets had to be anchored in the people and land to which they were given, before extending outward to the nations.

Thus, Jeremiah 31 flows directly into Christ. The seed of man and beast looks to the physical restoration of the land, while the New Covenant looks to the spiritual restoration accomplished through Jesus. He had to come to a physical Israel in order to fulfill these covenant promises, and only then could the blessings extend to all nations through the gospel.

How SCJ reads the parable, and what Jesus says

From a Shincheonji perspective, the parable of the wheat and the tares reveals the hidden reality of Christianity over the last 2,000 years: Jesus sowed the good seed (the truth), but Satan also planted tares (false doctrines), producing confusion and multiple interpretations. While the word itself was never corrupted, SCJ argues that the interpretations of that word were mixed with lies, making Christianity like the tree of the knowledge of good and evil — containing both truth and error. They appeal to Acts 17:30 to say that God overlooked this time of ignorance until the present, when he now calls all people to repentance, and to 1 Corinthians 13:12 to argue that Christians only knew in part throughout history but now, at the time of fulfillment, can finally see “face to face.” For Shincheonji, this “face to face” knowledge is provided through Lee Man-hee and their revealed word, which alone can separate wheat from tares at the harvest.

Just to reiterate, in the parable of the wheat and the tares, Jesus is clear that the “good seed” persists until the end of the age, when the sons of the kingdom are harvested into the barn (Matt. 13:38–43). There is no suggestion in the parable that the good seed becomes corrupted, partially true, or mingled with falsehood. In fact, Jesus elsewhere confirms that his word and his people endure uncorrupted: “Heaven and earth will pass away, but my words will never pass away” (Matt. 24:35, NET); and “the gates of Hades will not overpower it” (NET) his church (Matt. 16:18). Peter also emphasizes the permanence of this seed when he says believers have been “born anew, not from perishable but from imperishable seed, through the living and enduring word of God” (1 Pet. 1:23, NET). The imagery of imperishable seed makes it impossible to claim that what Jesus planted 2,000 years ago later became spoiled or mixed with lies.

Acts 17:30 and 1 Corinthians 13:12: ignorance and partial knowledge

Shincheonji often points to Acts 17:30 and 1 Corinthians 13:12 to argue that Christianity lived in ignorance until the present time of “fulfillment” through SCJ. But the context of both passages shows otherwise. In Acts 17, Paul is addressing pagan Athenians, not Christians. The “times of ignorance” he refers to are the centuries in which Gentile nations walked in idolatry, not the 2,000 years of the church. Paul’s point is that now, in light of Christ’s death and resurrection, God commands all people everywhere to repent, because the proof of salvation has already been revealed in Jesus (Acts 17:30–31). Far from teaching an extended period of ignorance after the cross, Paul is proclaiming that the age of ignorance has ended and the time of the gospel has begun. This means the “good seed” was already present and active in Paul’s preaching, creating sons of the kingdom throughout the world.

Similarly, 1 Corinthians 13:12 does not teach that Christians lacked the truth for 2,000 years. Paul is describing the difference between our present knowledge and the perfect clarity we will have when Christ returns: “For now we see in a mirror indirectly, but then we will see face to face” (NET). The “face to face” moment is not the rise of a promised pastor, but the return of Christ himself (cf. 1 John 3:2, where believers will see him as he is when he appears). To claim this verse is about Lee Man-hee is to replace Christ with another man. Even Shincheonji acknowledges that Lee once taught wrongly about the 144,000, later changing his interpretation. By their own standard, that would constitute “adding and subtracting” from the Word (Rev. 22:18–19). If Lee’s errors are excused as partial knowledge until fulfillment, then Christians too can be acknowledged as having partial knowledge while still holding fast to the imperishable seed of the gospel (1 Pet. 1:23). The difference is that Christians await Christ for full knowledge, not a Korean pastor.

Thus, Acts 17 and 1 Corinthians 13 actually affirm the opposite of what Shincheonji claims: ignorance ended with the coming of Christ, and partial knowledge will end when he returns — not with the appearance of a new “promised pastor.”

TopicShincheonji’s InterpretationBiblical Context & Teaching
Acts 17:30 — “times of ignorance”Refers to 2,000 years of Christianity’s confusion and false interpretations. God overlooked this period until Lee Man-hee revealed the true meaning of Scripture.Paul is addressing pagan Athenians, not Christians. The “times of ignorance” = centuries of Gentile idolatry before Christ. With Jesus’s death and resurrection, that time ended; now God commands all people everywhere to repent (Acts 17:30–31).
Acts 17:31 — “day of judgment”The day of judgment = now, through Lee Man-hee and Shincheonji’s revealed word, which separates truth from lies.Judgment is tied to Christ’s resurrection and his future return: God will judge the world “by a man whom he designated, having provided proof to everyone by raising him from the dead” (NET). The judge is Jesus, not a new pastor.
1 Corinthians 13:12 — knowing in partRefers to 2,000 years of partial knowledge in Christianity. Full knowledge comes “face to face” through Lee Man-hee and SCJ’s revelation.Paul contrasts present, imperfect knowledge with the perfect clarity believers will have at Christ’s return: “For now we see in a mirror indirectly, but then we will see face to face” (NET). Fulfillment = seeing Christ himself (1 John 3:2), not following a new man.
Consistency issueChristianity’s errors prove they lacked truth; only SCJ’s revealed word counts as the “good seed.”Even Lee Man-hee has changed interpretations (e.g., on the 144,000). By SCJ’s own definition, this would be “adding and subtracting” (Rev. 22:18–19). If his errors can be excused as “partial knowledge,” then Christians too can be acknowledged as holding partial knowledge while still carrying the imperishable seed of the gospel (1 Pet. 1:23).
Who brings full knowledge?Lee Man-hee, the “promised pastor,” reveals the word at the harvest.Jesus Christ himself. The gospel is imperishable (1 Pet. 1:23), his church will not be overcome (Matt. 16:18), and full knowledge comes when he returns (1 John 3:2), not through another man.
Back to the top of §1

Where to go next

  1. 41Did the light go out for 2,000 years? Light, the Spirit and the Good Shepherdprevious in this passage
  2. 21Is God’s revelation complete in Christ? Hebrews 1, Colossians 2 and Jude 3
  3. 14Promised pastor: is Lee Man-hee “the one who overcomes” and the male child?
  4. 2The history of Shincheonji: from the Tabernacle Temple to 1984
  5. 8How Shincheonji interprets the Bible

Frequently asked questions

Is the field in the parable of the wheat and the tares the church?

In Matthew 13:38, Jesus leaves no room for reinterpretation: “The field is the world” (NET).

The Lord himself explains the parable, so the field cannot be limited to “the world of Christianity.”

What does Jeremiah 31:27 have to do with the wheat and the tares?

Jeremiah 31 is not pointing to two spiritual seeds in the church age but to the restoration of Israel after exile and the promise of something greater, the New Covenant.

It is a covenant promise to a real people in a real land.

Does Acts 17:30 teach that Christianity lived in ignorance?

Thus, Acts 17 and 1 Corinthians 13 actually affirm the opposite of what Shincheonji claims: ignorance ended with the coming of Christ, and partial knowledge will end when he returns — not with the appearance of a new “promised pastor.”

Sources

SCJ’s own books (primary).

Printed page numbers.

  1. Lee Man-hee, The Creation of Heaven and Earth, English 2nd ed. (2014): pp. 301, 453.

BVC lesson pages used.

Lesson 1, Lesson 15, Lesson 26 and Lesson 27.

Closer Look Initiative.

“Light and Darkness: God Preserves, Not Betrayal,” closerlookinitiative.com/archives/12757. (This article is part 2 of 2.) Sections used: the light, the Spirit, the Good Shepherd and the two-readings table; the wheat and tares and Jeremiah 31:27 sections. Not used: the “heaven” table (same as article 40), the repeated Jeremiah 31 flow, the second-chance block and “Additional references.” Bible Vaccine Center and Closer Look Initiative are run by the same team.

Scripture.

NET Bible, quoted as (NET).

Scripture quotations are from the NET Bible®, https://netbible.com, copyright ©1996, 2019 by Biblical Studies Press, L.L.C. Used by permission. All rights reserved.