Part 1 · article 5 of 70
How Shincheonji recruits: Bible studies, “leaves,” and front groups
Short answer
Shincheonji recruits mainly through a months-long Bible course that is often offered without naming the church. Former members describe members who pose as fellow students (“leaves”), recruits screened against unwritten “worthiness criteria,” and outreach through pastor networks and seminaries under other names. Singapore’s government reached similar findings in 2020.
On this page (12 sections)
What SCJ says about its teaching
SCJ’s books describe one true place of Bible teaching:
In SCJ’s own words
“The only theological seminary Jesus promised is the place where the pastor, who eats the scroll opened by Jesus (Rv 10), teaches the words of that scroll without cost according to the Bible (Rv 21:6).”
In SCJ’s own words
“The living water the spirit and the bride give is the word of truth that flows from the throne of God and Jesus. This living water is given without cost (Rv 22:17).”
That place is the Zion Christian Mission Center (ZCMC), which SCJ names as where the promised pastor teaches (CHE, 2014, p. 443). The no-cost offer is real, and for many people it is the draw. What the books don’t describe is how people are brought into the course, or who is in the room with them. That information comes from former members, the press and one government.
How the course is structured
Per former members, and as our glossary records it, the course has an introduction and three levels. See levels and Bible study seminar.
- Bible Basics (BB): the Old and New Testaments as promise and fulfillment; the Bible’s four parts (history, morals, prophecy and fulfillment); and why the Jews missed the Messiah.
- Parables and the secrets of the kingdom of heaven: the figurative “code” (see parables).
- Intermediate: “Bible logic,” Genesis to Jude, built on betrayal, destruction and salvation.
- Advanced: Revelation and its claimed fulfillment in Korea.
Per ex-member testimony, students are also asked to sign a determination letter committing to finish the course. Our Bible study signs page notes a typical pattern: questions about who runs the class get vague answers, and “you learn the name Shincheonji only after months.” Singapore’s Ministry of Home Affairs reached a similar finding in 2020 (quoted below). WORLD describes a Seattle-area recruit whose first online class ended in October 2018 and whose leaders did not name Shincheonji until October 2019 (WORLD, Sept 12, 2024).
The “worthiness criteria”
Per ex-member testimony and recruiting guidelines (not in SCJ’s published books), recruits are screened during Bible Basics. The fullest itemized list we have comes from an anonymous former-member post on r/Shincheonji in August 2022 (Reddit). Items 1–4 describe whom to recruit; items 5–7 describe people members were told not to approach. Named testimony, below, corroborates the health and LGBTQ items:
- Local, or holding a visa valid for at least three years, with a path to permanent residence.
- Christian or Catholic.
- A university student or older.
- Not “spiritually rich.”
- Not people with mental disorders such as depression.
- Not people who are LGBTQ.
- Not people who are too suspicious or skeptical about the group.
Per the same testimony, a student who fails one or more criteria is normally not allowed into the Center Class. A member of seven years replied that the “should not evangelise” list “still holds true.”
The post is anonymous. The Independent reported the same pattern from named former members in the UK. Former member Jess Xentsa told the paper it began with the “worthiness criteria”: “You can’t have any physical or mental health issues, because people in there need to be able to be faithful and work, and work means recruiting.” The paper said it had seen an “evangelism diary” in which members answer questions about recruits such as “Does he/she have depression? Is he/she homosexual?” (The Independent, Aug 9, 2022).
“Leaves” and “fruits”
Per ex-member testimony, many of the “students” in a class are already members. Former members call them leaves, and the new recruits fruit. A leaf befriends a recruit and reports anything that might make the recruit stop, such as doubts, family worries or outside warnings. Leaves keep pace with the recruit’s level, so they too seem surprised by each “new” teaching.
Our Bible study signs page records the same practice (SCJ’s internal term is “leaf”). WORLD reported that when leaders of a Seattle study finally named Shincheonji in October 2019, “half the study members … already secretly belonged to the group” (WORLD, 2024).
The “wisdom of hiding”
Per ex-member testimony and SCJ lesson material (the phrase is not in SCJ’s published books), members are taught a “wisdom of hiding” with two parts:
- Concealing information. Members point to times Jesus withheld information. In Mark 8:30, “he warned them not to tell anyone about him,” and in Matthew 9:30, “Jesus sternly warned them, ‘See that no one knows about this!’” (NET).
- Redefining a lie. The real sin is adding to or taking away from Revelation (Rev 22:18–19), and SCJ’s book defines that in terms of its own teaching:
In SCJ’s own words
“Ignoring the book of Revelation or partially interpreting it is the same as subtracting from it. Interpreting Revelation according to one’s own thoughts or imagination is the same as adding to it. … This is why believers must learn the entire book of Revelation from the promised pastor (Rv 1:1-3, Rv 10).”
Former members describe a related strategy term, mo-ryak. See also How to leave Shincheonji, which discusses the “wisdom of hiding.” Paul describes the opposite approach: “But we have rejected shameful hidden deeds, not behaving with deceptiveness or distorting the word of God, but by open proclamation of the truth we commend ourselves to everyone’s conscience before God” (2 Cor 4:2, NET). Article 61 tests this teaching: The Wisdom of Hiding: Does the Bible Justify Deception? coming soon.
What a government found
In 2020, Singapore’s Ministry of Home Affairs reported on the local chapter:
“The SCJ in Singapore has been using front entities to target Christian youths and young adults to join their group. A controlling influence is then exerted over these young members, requiring them to comply with strict instructions to conceal the local existence of SCJ and their involvement with it. Members are not allowed to contact one another, verify teachings with other churches, or inform their families of their involvement.”
The same statement names front companies and says MHA objected to registering HWPL because it “believed that HWPL was going to be used as a front for SCJ.”
Front groups and pastor outreach
SCJ also works through names and affiliated groups that do not say “Shincheonji” at first. Our church names page lists the official church name, Zion Christian Mission Center (ZCMC), and affiliated peace groups HWPL, IWPG and IPYG, each with a source. Our FAQ notes that people also meet the group through UK-linked Parachristo activity, often before the name Shincheonji is used. For how these names show up in church outreach, see How Shincheonji enters churches.
Pastors have described what happened in their churches:
- New Zealand: William Chong tells how a man stopped by the welcome desk at LIFE Central church in Auckland in April 2015. By the end of that year, the volunteer he met there and five classmates had joined a group she “then learned was called Shincheonji” (Baptist New Zealand, Dec 19, 2023, reprinted from Christianity Today).
- Austin, Texas: Pastor Rusty’s account of his church being targeted (video).
- Upstate New York: Pastor House’s warning to other pastors (video).
- India: two pastors, Narashima Rao Paul and Rev. Ponnappah, describe ending agreements (MOUs) with Shincheonji (video; video).
Former students tell their own stories:
- Perth: parents opposed SCJ’s bid to run its building as an “education establishment” (PerthNow).
- Video testimonies: Washington, DC (video), Seattle (video), Los Angeles (video) and South Africa (video).
For churches, see How Shincheonji enters churches, When Shincheonji approaches your church and the Pastors Packet.
How to tell
You can ask any Bible study three plain questions:
- Who runs this study?
- Which church is it connected to?
- Who is the final teacher?
An honest study will answer all three on day one. For more warning signs, see How to tell if a Bible study is Shincheonji. If someone you love is already in a study, start with the Family Packet or contact us.
Where to go next
Frequently asked questions
When does a Shincheonji Bible study reveal that it is Shincheonji?
Often only after months of classes.
Our Bible study signs page notes a typical pattern: “you learn the name Shincheonji only after months.” WORLD describes a Seattle-area recruit whose first online class ended in October 2018 and whose leaders did not name Shincheonji until October 2019 (WORLD, Sept 12, 2024).
What is a “leaf” in a Shincheonji Bible study?
A leaf is a member who poses as a fellow student in the class.
Former members say leaves befriend a recruit (the fruit) and report doubts, family worries, or outside warnings, while keeping pace with the recruit’s level. WORLD reported that when a Seattle study finally named Shincheonji, “half the study members … already secretly belonged to the group” (WORLD, 2024).
What is Shincheonji’s “wisdom of hiding”?
Per ex-member testimony and SCJ lesson material (the phrase is not in SCJ’s published books), members are taught a “wisdom of hiding” that covers concealing information and redefining a lie.
The real sin, in that teaching, is adding to or taking away from Revelation, which SCJ’s book defines in terms of learning Revelation from the promised pastor (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 563). See How to leave Shincheonji and The Wisdom of Hiding: Does the Bible Justify Deception?
How is Shincheonji’s Bible course structured?
Per former members, and as our glossary records it, the course has an introduction and three levels.
The stages described are Bible Basics, a course on parables, Intermediate, and Advanced, which covers Revelation and its claimed fulfillment in Korea. See levels and Bible study seminar.
Does Shincheonji charge tuition for its Bible course?
SCJ’s books say the teaching is given “without cost.”
The Creation of Heaven and Earth, p. 166, calls the promised seminary “the place where the pastor, who eats the scroll opened by Jesus (Rv 10), teaches the words of that scroll without cost,” and The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, p. 561, says the living water “is given without cost.” That place is the Zion Christian Mission Center (ZCMC).
Sources
SCJ’s own books (primary).
Printed page numbers.
- Lee Man-hee, The Creation of Heaven and Earth, English 2nd ed. (2014), pp. 166, 443.
- Lee Man-hee, The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, English 1st ed. (March 2015), pp. 561, 563.
Bible Vaccine Center.
Levels · Bible study seminar · Determination letter · Leaf · Bible study signs · Church names · FAQ · How Shincheonji enters churches · How to leave.
Government (kept: named official findings).
- Ministry of Home Affairs, Singapore, “Investigations into Shincheonji Church of Jesus the Temple of the Tabernacle of the Testimony in Singapore,” Feb 28, 2020. https://www.mha.gov.sg/media-room/newsroom/investigations-into-shincheonji-church-of-jesus-the-temple-of-the-tabernacle-of-the-testimony-in-singapore/
Named ex-member and press (kept where no primary or BVC page covers the specific fact).
- Holly Bancroft, The Independent, Aug 9, 2022 (Jess Xentsa; evangelism diary). https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/new-heaven-new-earth-lee-man-hee-cult-sect-b2119061.html
- r/Shincheonji, “Are there any updates to SCJ’s ‘worthy’ standard?” (anonymous former member, Aug 2022; source of the seven-item list). https://www.reddit.com/r/Shincheonji/comments/wq5bqr/are_there_any_updates_to_scjs_worthy_standard/
- Elizabeth Russell, “Bait and switch,” WORLD, Sept 12, 2024 (Seattle 2018–19 timeline; “half the study”). https://wng.org/articles/bait-and-switch-1725590378
- William Chong, Baptist New Zealand, Dec 19, 2023 (reprinted from Christianity Today). https://baptist.nz/a-korean-sect-targeted-new-zealand-christians-did-churches-respond-effectively/
- PerthNow, on SCJ’s West Leederville planning application. https://www.perthnow.com.au/wa/perth/central/western-suburbs/shincheonji-church-opponents-of-perth-cult-battle-bid-to-become-educational-establishment-c-15382160
- Video testimonies from named pastors and former students, linked above (YouTube, checked Nov 12, 2026).
Scripture quotations are from the NET Bible®, https://netbible.com, copyright ©1996, 2019 by Biblical Studies Press, L.L.C. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
