Series · Part 2, article 3 of 5The gospel and biblical interpretation · The sealed book and the open scroll

Part 2 of 9 · 5 articles, 3 live

  1. 7 What is the gospel? Shincheonji’s gospel vs. the Bible
  2. 8 How Shincheonji interprets the Bible
  3. 9 The sealed book and the open scroll
  4. 10 Why did Jesus speak in parables?
  5. 11 The difference between biblical prophecy and figurative interpretation
Next: Part 3 · Promised pastor Back to Part 2 All 9 parts →

Part 2 · article 9 of 70

Shincheonji and the open scroll: what is the sealed book, and who opens it?

37 min readHow we check sources

Short answer

Shincheonji teaches that the Bible, especially the book of Revelation, was sealed in parables and symbolic language to prevent Satan from interfering with God’s plan. They believe these sealed truths were hidden until the end times, at which point they would be revealed through a divinely appointed figure — the Promised Pastor, Lee Man-hee. Shincheonji asserts that salvation today depends on recognizing and receiving the testimony of this one person.

The Bible’s answer is different. Revelation 5 makes it clear that the sealed scroll is opened only by Christ, and there is no indication that its authority or contents are handed to another figure after Him.

This article sets out what SCJ’s own books say about the sealed book and the open scroll, then tests it against the Bible. For how SCJ reads the Bible as a whole, see Article 8, How Shincheonji interprets the Bible.

Bible quotations are from the NET Bible. The NET renders the Greek verb behind “overcomes” as “conquers.” This article uses “overcomes,” as SCJ’s own books do, and keeps “conquers” inside the NET quotations. SCJ’s books quote the Bible from more than one translation, and those quotations appear here as SCJ prints them.

On this page (8 sections)
  1. Short answer
  2. 1. Shincheonji’s perspective: the sealed book and the open scroll
  3. 2. What the Bible says about the scroll
  4. 3. A scroll that only one man can read
  5. 4. Conclusion: the Lamb opens the scroll
  6. Where to go next
  7. Frequently asked questions
  8. Sources

1. Shincheonji’s perspective: the sealed book and the open scroll

What SCJ means by the sealed book

In Shincheonji theology, the concept of the sealed book is central to understanding the Bible, particularly the book of Revelation. SCJ teaches that the Bible—especially prophetic texts like Revelation—was written in parables and symbolic language, making it spiritually sealed and inaccessible to complete understanding for the past 2,000 years. They believe this sealed nature of the Word was intentional, designed by God to prevent interference from Satan and to reserve the full meaning for a specific appointed time.

SCJ’s books say the same thing in their own words:

“There is a time for the contents of the scroll to be hidden, but there is also a time for them to be revealed. When the appointed time comes, God opens the words of revelation and explains them to us.” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 5)

“This sealed book is the book of Revelation, the meaning of which is hidden in parables until it is fulfilled.” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 111)

“God sealed the words of the Old and New Testaments with figurative language until the time of the end when Revelation is fulfilled.” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 356)

For how SCJ divides Scripture into sealed and opened words, see Article 8, How Shincheonji interprets the Bible.

The 2,000 years of darkness

This perspective also informs SCJ’s view of church history. They teach that after Jesus, the light of the world, ascended to heaven, the world entered a 2,000-year period of spiritual darkness, lacking the full truth. This idea is supported in their teachings by references such as John 9:4-5 and Isaiah 29:9-14, which they interpret as prophecies about the sealed state of God’s word and the spiritual blindness of people during that time. SCJ also uses this theological framework to question traditional Christian doctrines, including the doctrine of the Trinity, which they view as the product of human interpretation developed during the period of spiritual darkness.

“When Jesus, who is light and day, left this world, everything was plunged into a deep, dark night (Jn 9:4-5). Just as night arrives when the sun sets in the west, this world turned to night when Jesus left it. Today, this world has been in constant darkness for the past 2,000 years.” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 535)

“The prophecies of Revelation, however, have been sealed with seven seals for approximately 2,000 years since Apostle John received and recorded his vision. Today, the time that was appointed for Revelation’s fulfillment has finally come.” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 565)

The sealed scroll of Isaiah

You will be shocked and amazed! You are totally blind! They are drunk, but not because of wine; they stagger, but not because of beer. For the Lord has poured out on you a strong urge to sleep deeply. He has shut your eyes (you prophets), and covered your heads (you seers). To you this entire prophetic revelation is like words in a sealed scroll. When they hand it to one who can read and say, “Read this,” he responds, “I can’t, because it is sealed.” Or when they hand the scroll to one who can’t read and say, “Read this,” he says, “I can’t read.” The Lord says, “These people say they are loyal to me; they say wonderful things about me, but they are not really loyal to me. Their worship consists of nothing but man-made ritual. Therefore I will again do an amazing thing for these people—an absolutely extraordinary deed. Wise men will have nothing to say, the sages will have no explanations.” (Isaiah 29:9–14, NET)

Isaiah’s Vision and the Sealed Scroll: Shincheonji draws heavily on Isaiah 29:9-13, which describes a vision given to Isaiah that was hidden from the people, likening it to a sealed book that no one, not even prophets, could understand. This passage serves as a foundation for their belief that God intentionally conceals certain truths until the appropriate time. They interpret the blindness mentioned in this passage as a consequence of relying solely on human understanding and tradition, mirroring their criticisms of traditional churches.

We can see this being reinforced with SCJ’s literature, including:

“Approximately 2,700 years ago the prophet Isaiah saw visions regarding Judah and Jerusalem (Is 1:1). Approximately 2,000 years ago Apostle John, who was in exile on the island of Patmos, received the revelation of Jesus Christ (Rv 1:1-2). The visions and revelations these two men received included information about God’s sealed book (Is 29:9-14; Rv 5, 10). Let us understand the sealed book and the process of revelation more deeply.” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 8)

And

“This same content also appears in Rv 6-7. Isaiah 29:9-13, however, says that because God’s vision is like words sealed in a book, none of the prophets or the seers (heads) can understand. This same concept also appears in Rv 5, where no one is able to open, much less see or read, the book sealed with seven seals that is in God’s right hand. The consequence of the inaccessibility of God’s word is that people can only learn and teach according to the rules and traditions of men. Believers who attempt to draw closer to the Lord do so only with their lips because their hearts are far from God (Is 29:13).” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 339)

Writing on tablets and running

The Lord responded: “Write down this message. Record it legibly on tablets so the one who announces it may read it easily. For the message is a witness to what is decreed; it gives reliable testimony about how matters will turn out. Even if the message is not fulfilled right away, wait patiently; for it will certainly come to pass—it will not arrive late.” (Habakkuk 2:2–3, NET)

Lee’s book quotes this passage from the NIV, so its wording differs from the NET above.

According to Lee Man-hee:

“In the same way, the sealed books that the prophet Isaiah and Apostle John saw in their visions are hidden revelations of future events. God said, ‘Write down the revelation and make it plain on tablets so that a herald may run with it. For the revelation awaits an appointed time’ (Hb 2:2-3, NIV). Since the book is sealed by God until an appointed time, no one is able to know the meaning of what is recorded.” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, pp. 8–9)

In essence, Shincheonji teaches that Habakkuk 2:2-3 points to their church as the site of the fulfillment of biblical prophecies, with Lee Man-hee as the key figure revealing the previously sealed truths of the Bible, particularly Revelation. They see their interpretation as the only correct and complete understanding of the Bible, leading to salvation for those who believe.

The scroll of Daniel 12

“But you, Daniel, close up these words and seal the book until the time of the end. Many will dash about, and knowledge will increase.” (Daniel 12:4, NET)

Shincheonji uses Daniel 12:4, 9 as a foundational proof-text for the concept of the Bible being sealed for thousands of years. According to SCJ, this passage demonstrates that God intentionally sealed His full plan of redemptive history, especially the vision of the end times, until the appointed time of fulfillment. The instruction to Daniel to “seal the book” is not seen as limited to his own writings but symbolic of the entire Bible being spiritually encrypted through figurative language, parables, and prophecy. SCJ argues that this sealing has caused confusion and doctrinal division within Christianity for 2,000 years, leaving traditional churches unable to perceive the true meaning of Scripture, especially the book of Revelation.

“God also told us that his book would remain sealed until the time of the end (Dn 12).” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 356)

How SCJ says the scroll was opened: Revelation 5 and 10

According to SCJ, the opening of this sealed book began when Jesus overcame and received the scroll sealed with seven seals from God’s right hand, as described in Revelation 5. The process of breaking the seals, detailed in Revelation 6–8, represents a sequence of events that must take place before the true meaning of Revelation can be revealed. Once the scroll is fully opened, it is handed to an angel, who then gives it to the figure symbolized as “John” in Revelation 10. SCJ interprets this as the moment the open scroll is given to the “Promised Pastor,” a figure they identify as Lee Man-hee, the founder of Shincheonji.

SCJ’s books describe the route the scroll takes:

“Jesus receives the scroll sealed with seven seals from God, and he reveals it by breaking its seals (Rv 5, 6, 8, 10). Jesus gives this revelation to an angel, who then delivers the open, revealed scroll to Apostle John. John obeys the voice from heaven and testifies to God’s servants what is written in the scroll and what he has seen (Rv 10:8-11).” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, pp. 6–7)

Lee’s book ties the opening to Jesus’ victory over Satan:

“Jesus is able to open the seven seals because he overcame Satan (Rv 5:5). If he had been unable to defeat Satan, he would be unable to open the sealed book. Satan would interfere and Jesus would be unable to fulfill the prophecies recorded in the sealed book.” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 431)

Then I saw in the right hand of the one who was seated on the throne a scroll written on the front and back and sealed with seven seals. And I saw a powerful angel proclaiming in a loud voice: “Who is worthy to open the scroll and to break its seals?” But no one in heaven or on earth or under the earth was able to open the scroll or look into it. So I began weeping bitterly because no one was found who was worthy to open the scroll or to look into it. Then one of the elders said to me, “Stop weeping! Look, the Lion of the tribe of Judah, the root of David, has conquered; thus he can open the scroll and its seven seals.” (Revelation 5:1–5, NET)

The Sealed Book in Revelation: Shincheonji identifies the “sealed book” explicitly with the scroll mentioned in Revelation 5:1-5, which depicts a scroll sealed with seven seals, only openable by Jesus the Lamb. They interpret the seven seals as symbolic of the hidden nature of Revelation’s prophecies, inaccessible to those without the proper spiritual understanding. By highlighting Jesus’s role in opening the scroll, Shincheonji reinforces the idea that understanding Revelation requires divine intervention and revelation.

He held in his hand a little scroll that was open, and he put his right foot on the sea and his left on the land. … Then the voice I had heard from heaven began to speak to me again, “Go and take the open scroll in the hand of the angel who is standing on the sea and on the land.” So I went to the angel and asked him to give me the little scroll. He said to me, “Take the scroll and eat it. It will make your stomach bitter, but it will be as sweet as honey in your mouth.” So I took the little scroll from the angel’s hand and ate it, and it did taste as sweet as honey in my mouth, but when I had eaten it, my stomach became bitter. Then they told me: “You must prophesy again about many peoples, nations, languages, and kings.” (Revelation 10:2, 8–11, NET)

SCJ’s Revelation commentary says the little scroll of Revelation 10 is the same book as the sealed scroll of Revelation 5:

“The small, open book the angel brings (Rv 10:2) is the same book Jesus takes from God’s hand in Rv 5. It is the same book whose seven seals Jesus opens in Rv 6. It is a book of revelation. Jesus gives his opened revelation to the angel in Rv 10, and the angel tells new John to eat it.” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 215)

It says what “eating” the scroll means, and who “John” is when Revelation is fulfilled:

“What does it mean for John to eat the open book? It means he completely understands its content and writes it on his heart. When new John eats God’s book, he becomes a walking Bible.” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 220)

“As the prophecies are fulfilled, Apostle John does not rise from the dead to testify his prophecies and their fulfillment. Instead, a pastor like Apostle John (the new John) appears to testify about the physical revelation he has seen and heard.” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 22)

“In Rv 10, Apostle John (the new John at the time of the fulfillment) is the promised pastor who receives and eats the open book.” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 571)

“That is when the promised pastor, who comes in the position of Apostle John, sees and hears the words of the revealed scroll from the angel. He sees and hears the events of the physical fulfillment and delivers that message to us.” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 7)

“Jesus opened the seals of the closed book and gave it to the one who overcomes, the true promised pastor. Jesus commanded him to testify about the words recorded in the scroll to all nations, peoples, languages, and kings.” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 565)

Ezekiel and the open scroll

“As for you, son of man, listen to what I am saying to you: Do not rebel like that rebellious house! Open your mouth and eat what I am giving you.” Then I looked and realized a hand was stretched out to me, and in it was a written scroll. He unrolled it before me, and it had writing on the front and back; written on it were laments, mourning, and woe. He said to me, “Son of man, eat what you see in front of you—eat this scroll—and then go and speak to the house of Israel.” So I opened my mouth and he fed me the scroll. He said to me, “Son of man, feed your stomach and fill your belly with this scroll I am giving to you.” So I ate it, and it was sweet like honey in my mouth. (Ezekiel 2:8–3:3, NET)

Shincheonji strengthens their claims by drawing parallels between Lee Man-hee and the prophet Ezekiel, who, in Ezekiel chapters 1-3, receives a scroll from God and is commanded to eat it. They view both figures as receiving symbolic scrolls containing God’s message, linking Ezekiel’s prophetic role to Lee Man-hee and reinforcing their assertion that Lee Man-hee is a divinely chosen revealer of truth. While Ezekiel foreshadows Jesus eating the open scroll in the first coming, during the second coming, the Apostle John also ate the open scroll in Revelation 10, and thus, foreshadows another “Promised Pastor” in the future.

“One thing must be clarified. As Revelation is fulfilled, it is not the actual Apostle John from 2,000 years ago who testifies about the prophecies and physical fulfillment of Revelation. Someone similar to Apostle John—a new John—must appear. This is easier understood with an example from the book of Ezekiel. God called Ezekiel “Son of Man” and showed him many visions, but Ezekiel’s visions were prophecies fulfilled by Jesus roughly 600 years later.” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 26)

Why SCJ says only one man can read the scroll

Drawing from Revelation 5 and 10, Ezekiel 2–3, Daniel 12, and Amos 3:7, SCJ teaches that Lee is the only one who has received and understood the open scroll, enabling him to testify to the fulfillment of prophecy. He is seen as the “wise slave” of Matthew 24 who provides “food at the proper time,” and the “one who overcomes” in Revelation 2:17 who receives the “hidden manna,” symbolizing the revealed word of truth.

SCJ believes that only through this Promised Pastor—who they claim has seen and heard the fulfillment of Revelation—can the hidden truths of the Bible be fully understood. While they may acknowledge that earlier Christians, including the apostles, had a partial understanding, SCJ holds that full and correct interpretation of the Bible was not possible until the scroll was opened and revealed at the time of fulfillment.

“While Jesus was on this earth, he proclaimed what he had seen and heard in heaven. Even after he fulfilled the prophecies of the Old Testament and ascended to heaven, he taught his disciples many things through revelation (Gal 1:11-12). These revelations, however, were partial revelations.” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 495)

SCJ’s books make the “only one” claim in these words:

“Only a true witness—someone who saw and heard an event take place—can give a valid testimony regarding that event. Since John, according to the will of Jesus, directly sees and hears the explanation of everything recorded in Revelation, John’s testimony is the only testimony regarding Revelation that is true.” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 26)

“The new John is the only person who has seen and heard the fulfillment of the entire book of Revelation. Therefore, to be a person of Mount Zion who is saved, everyone must receive the testimony about the prophecies and their fulfillment from new John today at the time of Revelation’s fulfillment.” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 347)

“Therefore, the new John is the only one who can testify about the prophecies and physical fulfillment of Revelation. We must also know that anyone else who claims to have seen or heard the prophecies of Jesus is a liar.” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 551)

“The churches of this world cannot even begin to explain the words of Revelation or testify about their physical fulfillment. This is because Jesus is the only person who broke the seven seals of the sealed book (Rv 5:1-5, 6:1-8:1), and because John is the only person to whom Jesus gave and taught the words of the book that was once sealed. Through an angel, John witnessed the prophecies recorded in the book along with their physical fulfillment. Now, he is the one who proclaims the truth to all believers (Rv 10).” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 370)

“Today, because the promises in the New Testament, including the prophecies of Revelation, are being fulfilled, I am testifying about the fulfillment of the prophecies according to what I have seen and heard.” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 563)

For who SCJ says “the one who overcomes” is, see Article 14, Promised pastor: is Lee Man-hee “the one who overcomes” and the male child? For the “hidden manna,” see Article 15, The 12 promised blessings.

God revealing to his prophets: Amos 3:7

“Certainly the Sovereign Lord does nothing without first revealing his plan to his servants the prophets.” (Amos 3:7, NET)

Shincheonji (SCJ) places great emphasis on Amos 3:7 to justify the necessity of a single, divinely chosen messenger at every major turning point in redemptive history. They interpret this verse to mean that God never acts without first revealing His will through a prophet, and in the context of the end times, that prophet is none other than Lee Man-hee. SCJ teaches that God’s “plan” — the hidden meaning of the parables, prophecies, and the scroll sealed in Revelation — was not given to the traditional church or Christian leaders, but to the Promised Pastor. This is how they argue that Lee Man-hee, like Moses or the Apostle John, is the exclusive recipient of divine revelation in this era.

Furthermore, SCJ uses Amos 3:7 to delegitimize all other Christian interpretations of Scripture, especially regarding the book of Revelation. Since no major prophet had arisen to reveal the meaning of Revelation until Lee Man-hee, SCJ argues that all previous teachings were based on human understanding, tradition, or even demonic deception. Only the person to whom the “plan” has been revealed — in this case, Lee Man-hee — has the authority to speak on behalf of God at the time of the end. In this framework, Amos 3:7 becomes a divine protocol, and failure to recognize the Promised Pastor is seen as a rejection of God’s final revelation. As such, this verse is central to SCJ’s claim that salvation today hinges on hearing and believing the testimony of the one to whom the open scroll has been given.

“When God fulfills the secret promises, he always reveals them to his chosen pastor before fulfilling them (Am 3:7; Jn 5:19).” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 182)

Every mate has its pair: Isaiah 34:16

“Carefully read the scroll of the Lord! Not one of these creatures will be missing, none will lack a mate. For the Lord has issued the decree, and his own Spirit gathers them.” (Isaiah 34:16, NET)

Shincheonji interprets Isaiah 34:16 as a prophetic statement that underscores the importance of finding the correct pairings or fulfillments of the figurative and symbolic language in Scripture. The phrase “none will lack a mate” is taken to mean that every prophecy has a corresponding fulfillment, and it is the responsibility of the one sent by God to properly “mate” each prophecy with its correct event or figure in reality. According to SCJ, this verse justifies their methodology of matching parables and symbolic language with physical fulfillments — a core principle in their interpretation system. They claim that only the Promised Pastor, who has witnessed the fulfillment of Revelation, can accurately pair each symbolic prophecy with its real-world counterpart, thus revealing the true meaning of the “scroll of the Lord.”

The new song

“The new song represents the testimony regarding the fulfillment of the prophecies of Revelation; the singing of the new song represents the first time the true meaning of the prophecies of Revelation and their fulfillment are being explained.” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 346)

In this framework, Lee Man-hee is seen as the one who completes what was previously known only in part, receiving and proclaiming the revealed word of the open scroll. SCJ teaches that this revelation is necessary for salvation in the present age and that those who accept this testimony belong to the new spiritual Israel—symbolized by the 144,000 who learn the “new song” in Revelation 14.

For SCJ’s count of the 144,000, see Article 49, Who are the 144,000?

Back to the top of §1

2. What the Bible says about the scroll

Context of Isaiah 29:9–13 and spiritual stubbornness

Isaiah 29:9–13 emerges in a specific historical moment, shortly after the fall of Samaria, as Isaiah addresses the people of Jerusalem and the Southern Kingdom of Judah. The prophecy warns of impending judgment because of their persistent rebellion against God and hardened hearts toward His commands. The “sealed book” image is not describing an actual supernatural lock placed on Scripture for thousands of years but is a vivid metaphor for the people’s spiritual blindness — their refusal to hear and obey God’s word despite having access to it.

The scope of this “sealed” metaphor is limited to Isaiah’s immediate prophetic message. At most, it could refer to the scroll containing Isaiah’s own words, which the people could not truly “read” because they would not accept its meaning. There is no indication in the text that Isaiah’s metaphor is about the entire Bible or the visions of Revelation given centuries later. This is reinforced by the fact that, throughout the book of Isaiah, God repeatedly calls His people to repentance and obedience, offering to avert destruction if they return to Him (Isaiah 1:16–20).

This theme is also seen in Isaiah 6:9–11, where God commissions Isaiah to speak to a people who will “listen continually, but don’t understand,” as a form of judgment on their hard hearts. Yet this blindness is not a permanent state; God Himself can and does open the eyes of His people when they turn to Him. The “seal” in Isaiah is therefore a metaphor for willful spiritual resistance, not a prophecy of a future era in which no one can understand the Scriptures until a modern figure arrives to explain them.

Jesus’ use of Isaiah 29 in the first coming

When Jesus quotes Isaiah 29:13 in Matthew 15:8–9 and Mark 7:6–7, He applies the prophet’s words to the religious leaders of His own day. By doing so, He exposes their hypocrisy and spiritual stubbornness, showing that they honor God with their lips while their hearts are far from Him. In this context, Isaiah’s “sealed” message is not a prediction about the Bible’s inaccessibility but a timeless indictment of people who outwardly claim devotion to God while rejecting His truth in practice.

Far from postponing the meaning of Isaiah’s words for a distant generation, Jesus immediately reveals the truth to those willing to listen. In Mark 4:11, He tells His disciples, “The secret of the kingdom of God has been given to you,” and in John 18:37, He declares that He came into the world “to testify to the truth.” These statements show that Christ Himself breaks the “seal” by explaining the kingdom openly to His followers during His ministry.

This makes it clear that the “seal” in Isaiah is not a prophetic timetable awaiting the arrival of a modern “promised pastor.” Instead, it represents a spiritual condition — one that is removed whenever God speaks and His people respond in repentance and faith. In Jesus’ ministry, the unsealing happens in real time, not after centuries of darkness, proving that God’s word is accessible to those with open hearts.

The scroll in Revelation 5

In Revelation 5:5–7, John sees that only the Lamb, Jesus Christ, is worthy to take the scroll from the right hand of the One seated on the throne and open its seals. This scene makes it unmistakably clear that the authority to unseal the scroll belongs to Christ alone, not to any human messenger or leader. The focus of the vision is on the Lamb’s unique worthiness, rooted in His sacrificial death and victory, as the basis for revealing God’s plans.

Revelation 5 presents one of the most exalted scenes in all of Scripture. In the heavenly throne room, John weeps because no one in heaven, on earth, or under the earth is found worthy to open the scroll or even look inside it. The tension breaks when the Lion of the tribe of Judah — the Lamb who was slain — appears, and the heavenly host erupts in worship, declaring Him worthy “because you were killed, and at the cost of your own blood you have purchased for God persons from every tribe, language, people, and nation” (Revelation 5:9, NET). The scene drives home a single truth: only the Lamb, Jesus Christ, has the authority to open the seals and bring God’s plan to completion. This authority flows from His unique identity and redemptive work, which no angel, apostle, or human leader can replicate.

This approach also replaces Christ’s role in Revelation with that of a modern leader. In Revelation 5–6, the Lamb alone is worthy to take and open the scroll, and He does so within the vision itself. By claiming that their leader must reveal what Jesus has already unsealed, SCJ diminishes the direct authority and work of Christ in Scripture, shifting that authority onto a human figure. This is a theological downgrade from the biblical text, which centers the unsealing on the victorious, risen Lamb.

To transfer this divine prerogative to a modern, fallible human being — as Shincheonji does with Lee Man-hee — is to strip Revelation 5 of its meaning and diminish the centrality of Christ. The Bible affirms the sufficiency of Scripture for equipping believers (2 Timothy 3:16–17) and teaches that the faith has been “once for all entrusted to the saints” (Jude 3, NET). By asserting that Revelation’s contents can only be rightly understood through the interpretation of one present-day “promised pastor,” SCJ places a human intermediary in a role that the text reserves exclusively for Christ.

The biblical pattern confirms this problem. God has indeed used prophets and apostles throughout history to proclaim His word, but even they never shared in Christ’s exclusive heavenly authority to execute God’s final plan of judgment and redemption. The prophets pointed forward to Christ, the apostles bore witness to His completed work, and the Church continues to proclaim the gospel under the guidance of the Holy Spirit. At no point does Scripture suggest that a single future leader would share in the Lamb’s throne-room authority or act as a co-revealer of the sealed scroll.

Revelation 5 and Revelation 10 describe different scrolls

In Revelation 5, John sees a large scroll (biblion) in the hand of the One on the throne. It is sealed with seven seals, and only the Lamb, Jesus Christ, is worthy to open it. Its contents concern God’s sovereign plan of judgment and redemption, revealed as the seals are broken. By contrast, Revelation 10 shows John receiving a small scroll (biblaridion) that is already open in the angel’s hand. This scroll is not sealed, not taken from God’s throne, and not connected to the seven seals. Instead, it is given directly to John as a prophetic commission to proclaim God’s word. The differences in size (biblion vs. biblaridion), condition (sealed vs. already open), and purpose (God’s hidden plan vs. John’s prophetic task) make clear these are not the same scroll. SCJ’s teaching that Revelation 10 continues the scroll of Revelation 5 is therefore baseless.

The purposes of the scrolls are equally distinct. The large scroll in Revelation 5 represents the fullness of God’s sovereign plan for history, encompassing both judgment on the wicked and redemption for the righteous. Its opening marks the execution of this plan on a cosmic scale. The little scroll in Revelation 10, on the other hand, contains a specific prophetic message for John to internalize and proclaim. John is told to “eat” the scroll, which tastes sweet in his mouth but turns bitter in his stomach — a symbol of the joy and privilege of receiving God’s word, mixed with the sorrow and hardship of declaring judgment.

Finally, the audiences differ significantly. Revelation 5 unfolds in the heavenly throne room, with the twenty-four elders, four living creatures, and multitudes of angels responding in worship to the Lamb’s worthiness. The focus is entirely on Christ’s heavenly authority and the praise He receives for redeeming people by His blood. Revelation 10, by contrast, shifts to a personal commissioning scene in which John is directly instructed to prophesy “about many peoples, nations, languages, and kings.” The audience is no longer the heavenly court but the prophet himself, preparing him for his role in delivering God’s message to the world.

Ezekiel, the open scroll, and Jesus Christ

Ezekiel’s scroll in Ezekiel 2–3 contains messages of lamentation, mourning, and woe — a prophetic indictment against the rebellious house of Israel during the Babylonian exile. It is a covenant lawsuit, confronting Israel with their sin and calling them to repentance. In contrast, the scroll in Revelation 5 is sealed with seven seals and represents the fullness of God’s redemptive plan for history, which only the Lamb — Jesus Christ — is worthy to open. Revelation 10 introduces yet another scroll, this time described as “little” and already “open,” given to John to eat as part of his prophetic commission to speak further words of both sweetness and bitterness. These are separate visions, given in different contexts, with different content and purposes. There is no textual or thematic evidence in Scripture that these scrolls are meant to be viewed as the same object passed along through time.

Shincheonji collapses these distinct scrolls into a single prophetic object, creating a false continuity that moves from Ezekiel to Jesus to their leader, Lee Man-hee. This artificially constructed chain is necessary for their theology because it allows them to claim that Lee has received the “final” scroll in a supposed line of prophetic succession. However, the biblical text never presents the scrolls as connected in this way. Revelation 5 makes it clear that the sealed scroll is opened only by Christ, and there is no indication that its authority or contents are handed to another figure after Him. By merging these scrolls into one narrative, Shincheonji distorts the biblical storyline, undermines the uniqueness of Christ’s role, and imposes an interpretive framework foreign to the text itself.

In Scripture, the imagery of “eating” a scroll appears in places like Ezekiel 3 and Revelation 10, and in each case it signifies a prophet personally internalizing God’s message so they can faithfully proclaim it to their audience. In Ezekiel’s case, the scroll contained words of judgment for the exiled nation of Israel; in John’s vision, the small open scroll brought a bittersweet commission to continue prophesying to many peoples and nations. In both examples, the act is tied to an individual prophet’s specific mission and context — it is a personal commissioning, not a symbolic passing of authority from one figure to another. The imagery focuses on the prophet’s reception and embodiment of the message, not on creating a prophetic “relay race” across generations.

Shincheonji departs from this biblical pattern by turning the “eating” motif into a man-made doctrine of prophetic succession, a chain in which Ezekiel ate the scroll, Jesus embodied it and Lee now eats it. This interpretation forces unrelated biblical events into a continuous chain, implying that God’s revelation progresses through a line of specially appointed human mediators. Yet Scripture never uses this symbol to indicate an unbroken transfer of authority from one prophet to another. On the contrary, the Bible affirms that Jesus, as the eternal Word, is both the source and fulfillment of God’s message (Heb. 1:1–3), leaving no theological need for a third figure to “complete” what He has already accomplished.

Hebrews 1:1–3 clearly teaches that while God communicated through the prophets in various ways in the past, He has now spoken definitively and fully through His Son, Jesus Christ. This means that Christ is not just another prophet in a long sequence but the ultimate and complete revelation of God, perfectly revealing the Father’s will and accomplishing salvation through His life, death, and resurrection. His person and work stand as the climax of God’s redemptive plan, leaving no gap for further mediators to complete or improve upon His message.

“After God spoke long ago in various portions and in various ways to our ancestors through the prophets, in these last days he has spoken to us in a son, whom he appointed heir of all things, and through whom he created the world.” (Hebrews 1:1–2, NET)

The “new song” is about Christ’s redemption, not a modern pastor

The “new song” of Revelation 5:9–10 is a hymn of praise sung by the twenty-four elders and the four living creatures before the throne of God. The lyrics clearly focus on the Lamb’s sacrificial death, the redemption purchased by His blood, and the transformation of believers into “a kingdom and priests to serve our God.” This is a direct celebration of Christ’s completed work at the cross and its ongoing effect in gathering people from every tribe, language, people, and nation. Importantly, this worship scene takes place before the scroll is opened, showing that the song commemorates a past act of salvation, not a new event or message in the modern day.

Throughout Scripture, “new songs” consistently serve as responses to God’s saving acts, not as endorsements of new human messengers. In the Psalms, “new song” appears as an invitation to praise God for His deliverance and mighty works (Psalm 33:3; 40:3; 96:1; 98:1; 144:9; 149:1). In Isaiah 42:10, the command to sing a new song is linked to God’s coming judgment and salvation for the nations. Each instance celebrates divine intervention and redemption, never the proclamation of an individual’s personal testimony as an authoritative message for all believers.

Shincheonji’s claim that the “new song” of Revelation 5 represents the testimony of Lee Man-hee as the “promised pastor” is entirely unsupported by this biblical pattern. To redefine the “new song” as a modern human proclamation is to strip it from its scriptural context and shift the focus away from the Lamb, who alone is worthy of worship. The Bible’s witness is clear: songs of praise are always directed toward God’s redemptive acts through Christ, not toward the testimony of a man.

Revelation 1:1–3 does not teach a “new John”

Revelation 1:1–3 opens the book by describing how “the revelation of Jesus Christ, which God gave him to show his servants what must happen very soon,” was made known through an angel to “his servant John.” The “John” here is the apostle John, who faithfully recorded the visions he saw while exiled on the island of Patmos. Nothing in the text suggests that John is serving as a symbolic “template” for a future individual who would repeat his role in the last days. The verse is simply identifying the historical recipient of the vision and the divine source of its message.

The blessing in Revelation 1:3 is inclusive, not exclusive. It states, “Blessed is the one who reads the words of this prophecy aloud, and blessed are those who hear and obey the things written in it, because the time is near!” (Revelation 1:3, NET) This blessing applies to all believers in every generation who engage with and obey the message of the book, whether in the first century or today. It does not limit understanding or authority to a single, specially appointed “promised pastor” who must arise at the end of time.

Shincheonji’s teaching of a “New John” is not drawn from the biblical text itself but from their own “revealed truth” as presented by Lee Man-hee. This makes it a circular interpretation: the doctrine of the “New John” is used to validate Lee Man-hee’s authority, while Lee Man-hee’s authority is defended on the basis that he is the “New John.” Without independent biblical support, this claim collapses under its own weight.

If SCJ’s logic were applied consistently, it would imply that every prophet or apostle in Scripture requires a “new” counterpart in later generations to fulfill the same role. That would mean a “new Moses,” “new Isaiah,” or “new Paul” would need to appear for believers to understand God’s word in each era — something Scripture never teaches. The Bible instead affirms the sufficiency of the prophetic and apostolic witness already given (2 Timothy 3:16–17; Jude 3) and the continuing work of the Holy Spirit in guiding believers into all truth (John 16:13) without the necessity of a singular, modern-day prophetic figure.

The original context of Revelation rules out SCJ’s claim of a 2,000-year seal

Revelation was originally written to seven actual churches in the Roman province of Asia — Ephesus, Smyrna, Pergamum, Thyatira, Sardis, Philadelphia, and Laodicea (Revelation 1:4, 11). These communities were facing severe trials, including persecution from Roman authorities, pressure to participate in emperor worship, and internal threats from false teaching. The book’s immediate purpose was to encourage these first-century believers to remain faithful to Christ in the face of suffering, assuring them that God’s plan was unfolding according to His sovereign will. The letters to the seven churches in chapters 2 and 3 address their specific spiritual conditions, showing that the content of Revelation was both timely and understandable to its original audience.

In Revelation 1:3, John declares a blessing on those who read aloud the prophecy, hear it, and take it to heart “because the time is near.” This statement is significant — it affirms that the prophecy carried an urgent and relevant message for those living in John’s day. While the book contains visions that point toward the future, its central themes of God’s sovereignty, Christ’s ultimate victory over evil, and the call for perseverance in faith were meant to strengthen and guide believers in the present, not merely in a distant age.

Throughout history, Christians have drawn hope and encouragement from Revelation’s message without needing a new human mediator to unlock its meaning. The imagery and symbolism have been studied, preached, and applied by the Church for centuries, leading to a variety of interpretations but always centering on the victory of Christ and the assurance of God’s justice. This reality directly contradicts Shincheonji’s assertion that Revelation remained a completely sealed mystery for 2,000 years until the arrival of Lee Man-hee.

By claiming that only their leader has the authority and ability to interpret Revelation, SCJ effectively denies the text’s historical accessibility and the sufficiency of the Holy Spirit in guiding the Church into truth (John 16:13). The biblical and historical evidence shows that Revelation was not hidden from believers throughout the ages but has been an open source of comfort, exhortation, and hope for every generation of the faithful.

Habakkuk 2: an explicit, “unsealed” message

Habakkuk 2:2–3 was a clear, unsealed prophecy given to the prophet Habakkuk about God’s imminent judgment on Babylon, fulfilled in 539 BC. The command to “Record it legibly” shows it was meant to be understood in its own time, not hidden for thousands of years. The prophecy’s historical context, audience, and genre have no direct link to the apocalyptic visions of Revelation. The New Testament affirms that God’s plan has already been revealed in Christ, leaving no biblical basis for a “new John” or exclusive last-days messenger. Shincheonji’s interpretation follows their broader pattern of reassigning Old Testament prophecies to Lee Man-hee, adding meaning foreign to the text and ignoring its original fulfillment.

In Habakkuk 2:2, God commands the prophet, “Write down this message. Record it legibly on tablets so the one who announces it may read it easily.” The Hebrew verb used here, ba’er, means “to make clear, explain, or clarify.” This is the opposite of concealing a message — it is an explicit instruction to communicate the vision in a way that is understandable to others. The image is one of public accessibility, where even a messenger running could grasp the meaning and carry it onward. Far from being hidden, the vision was intended to be widely known and easily understood by the prophet’s contemporaries.

This stands in sharp contrast to the sealed scroll imagery in Revelation 5, which no one could open except the Lamb. A sealed scroll in apocalyptic literature signifies a message that is intentionally withheld until the appointed one has the authority to reveal it. Habakkuk’s message shares none of those qualities — it was not locked away, not waiting for a mysterious future interpreter, and not couched in language designed to obscure its meaning from its original audience. It was already revealed and explained in the prophet’s lifetime.

By ignoring these differences, Shincheonji collapses all “scroll” references in the Bible into one symbolic category, treating every scroll — sealed or unsealed — as if it refers to the same end-times revelation. This interpretive shortcut strips away the original historical and literary context of each passage. It allows them to artificially connect Habakkuk 2 to Revelation 5 or Revelation 10, even though the contexts, purposes, and audiences are completely different. Recognizing that Habakkuk’s vision was intentionally made plain dismantles the claim that this prophecy was a hidden message waiting thousands of years for Lee Man-hee to disclose.

Habakkuk’s prophecy of judgment on Babylon found its fulfillment in 539 BC, when the Persian Empire under Cyrus the Great conquered Babylon. This occurred within decades of Habakkuk’s ministry, which is generally dated to the late 7th century BC. The Babylonians, whom God had raised up to discipline Judah, themselves became the object of divine judgment for their arrogance, violence, and idolatry. This swift historical turnaround — from being God’s instrument of discipline to becoming the target of His wrath — fits precisely with God’s assurance in Habakkuk 2:3 that “it will certainly come to pass—it will not arrive late.”

Understanding this timeline makes it clear that the phrase “Even if the message is not fulfilled right away, wait patiently” in Habakkuk 2:3 referred to a fulfillment within the lifespan of those who first heard the prophecy. The call to wait was measured in years or decades, not millennia. Shincheonji’s claim that this verse points to events in the 20th and 21st centuries stretches the prophecy far beyond its original context, effectively disregarding the fact that it already came to pass in the fall of Babylon. This re-interpretation not only disconnects the verse from its historical anchor but also undermines the very nature of biblical prophecy, which is often tied to concrete, verifiable events in the lives of its original audience.

Isaiah 34:16

In its actual context, Isaiah 34 is a prophecy of judgment against Edom and the nations opposing God. The chapter describes total desolation, where the land will be left to wild animals. The command to “Carefully read the scroll of the Lord” simply points to Isaiah’s own written prophecy as a trustworthy witness of what will happen. The phrase “none will lack a mate” refers to the animals listed in the preceding verses (Isaiah 34:11–15), emphasizing that each creature will have its counterpart in the devastated land. This is poetic imagery about the certainty and completeness of God’s judgment, not about pairing symbols across different prophecies.

SCJ’s interpretation fails because the “scroll” is not a hidden codebook but Isaiah’s prophecy itself, and the “mates” are literal animals in the context. The point is that everything God has decreed will come to pass exactly as written. Using this verse to justify a sealed, symbolic Bible ignores its plain meaning and the historical setting of Isaiah’s message to his audience.

Back to the top of §2

3. A scroll that only one man can read

Put SCJ’s statements side by side:

  1. The way to know God runs through one man. “Clearly, it is only by listening to the one who has received revelation from Jesus that believers can know God, Jesus, and the pastor sent by Jesus. This is the only path to eternal life.” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 496).
  2. Finding him is required. “All believers must find this pastor.” and “Since this church and pastor are the only ones who are truly orthodox, it is through them that people can attain salvation.” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 371).
  3. The first step is to obey by finding him. “Thus, the first step toward receiving the blessings of God in the end times is to obey the word of the Lord by finding the new John who speaks on behalf of Jesus.” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 551).

While it is true that many prophecies in Scripture contain symbolic or poetic elements, SCJ’s method becomes circular and self-validating: the Bible is sealed in symbols, only their leader can interpret those symbols, and their interpretations are valid because they claim to fulfill the symbols. This approach bypasses any objective test of truth and makes disagreement equivalent to spiritual blindness or rebellion. Worse, it opens the door for arbitrary meaning-making, where any passage can be twisted to support any claim, so long as it’s metaphorically framed.

Ultimately, SCJ’s teaching redirects the believer’s focus from the sufficiency of Christ to the supposed necessity of Lee Man-hee. This not only undermines the glory of the Lamb but also distorts the gospel itself by making salvation and understanding contingent on allegiance to a human leader. In contrast, the New Testament presents Christ as the one and only mediator between God and humanity (1 Timothy 2:5), whose authority is complete and whose word is final.

“For there is one God and one intermediary between God and humanity, Christ Jesus, himself human” (1 Timothy 2:5, NET)

4. Conclusion: the Lamb opens the scroll

Shincheonji (SCJ) claims that the Bible’s prophecies, especially those in Revelation, are sealed in parables and can only be understood through their appointed leader, Lee Man-hee. They argue that Hosea 12:10 and other verses support the idea that biblical truths are hidden until the fulfillment of God’s timing, which SCJ interprets as the revelation of these truths through Lee Man-hee. However, this claim is contradicted by the broader biblical context, which shows that while some prophecies are symbolic, many were understood by their original audiences without the need for a future, exclusive interpreter. The early church, under the guidance of the Holy Spirit, received clear understanding of the Gospel and the prophecies, affirming that the Bible’s message is accessible to all believers.

The claim that Lee Man-hee is the necessary interpreter of Revelation is a distortion of Scripture. Parables, while sometimes needing explanation, were not always hidden or sealed from the public; many were understood in context. In addition, the Bible emphasizes the sufficiency of Christ as the final and complete revelation of God’s plan (Hebrews 1:1-3), leaving no need for a future “promised pastor.” SCJ’s claim that Revelation remained sealed for 2,000 years until Lee Man-hee arrived contradicts the Bible’s testimony of Christ’s ongoing work in the Church, undermining the unique role of Jesus as the sole mediator of salvation.

“Stop weeping! Look, the Lion of the tribe of Judah, the root of David, has conquered; thus he can open the scroll and its seven seals.” (Revelation 5:5, NET)

The next article in the series asks why Jesus spoke in parables.

Where to go next

  1. 8How Shincheonji interprets the BibleSCJ’s three eras, its sealed and opened words, and its reading of the Bible as a whole.
  2. 14Promised pastor: is Lee Man-hee “the one who overcomes” and the male child?who SCJ says receives the open scroll, and what the Bible says about the overcomer and the male child of Revelation 12:5.
  3. 15The 12 promised blessingsthe “hidden manna” and the other promises of Revelation 2–3, and who receives them.
  4. 49Who are the 144,000? Shincheonji’s twelve tribes, the 12,000 stadia, and the new covenantthe people SCJ says learn the “new song.”

Frequently asked questions

What is the sealed book in Shincheonji’s teaching?

SCJ teaches that the sealed book is the book of Revelation, and that its meaning stayed hidden in parables until its fulfillment. SCJ teaches that the Bible—especially prophetic texts like Revelation—was written in parables and symbolic language, making it spiritually sealed and inaccessible to complete understanding for the past 2,000 years. SCJ’s Revelation commentary says, “This sealed book is the book of Revelation, the meaning of which is hidden in parables until it is fulfilled” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 111). Lee’s book says the prophecies of Revelation “have been sealed with seven seals for approximately 2,000 years since Apostle John received and recorded his vision” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 565).

Who opened the scroll, and who received it, according to Shincheonji?

SCJ says Jesus opened the scroll and gave it to the one who overcomes, whom SCJ calls the promised pastor and identifies as Lee Man-hee. Lee’s book says, “Jesus opened the seals of the closed book and gave it to the one who overcomes, the true promised pastor” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 565). The commentary says, “In Rv 10, Apostle John (the new John at the time of the fulfillment) is the promised pastor who receives and eats the open book” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 571). SCJ interprets this as the moment the open scroll is given to the “Promised Pastor,” a figure they identify as Lee Man-hee, the founder of Shincheonji.

Are the scrolls of Revelation 5 and Revelation 10 the same scroll?

SCJ says they are one book, but Revelation describes a sealed scroll in chapter 5 and a little scroll that is already open in chapter 10. The commentary says, “The small, open book the angel brings (Rv 10:2) is the same book Jesus takes from God’s hand in Rv 5” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 215). In contrast, the scroll in Revelation 5 is sealed with seven seals and represents the fullness of God’s redemptive plan for history, which only the Lamb — Jesus Christ — is worthy to open. Revelation 10 introduces yet another scroll, this time described as “little” and already “open,” given to John to eat as part of his prophetic commission to speak further words of both sweetness and bitterness. These are separate visions, given in different contexts, with different content and purposes.

Did the Bible stay sealed for 2,000 years until Lee Man-hee?

No. The Bible gives the opening of the scroll to the Lamb, and Revelation was written to seven real churches. Lee’s book says, “Today, this world has been in constant darkness for the past 2,000 years” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 535). Revelation was originally written to seven actual churches in the Roman province of Asia — Ephesus, Smyrna, Pergamum, Thyatira, Sardis, Philadelphia, and Laodicea (Revelation 1:4, 11). The letters to the seven churches in chapters 2 and 3 address their specific spiritual conditions, showing that the content of Revelation was both timely and understandable to its original audience. The biblical and historical evidence shows that Revelation was not hidden from believers throughout the ages but has been an open source of comfort, exhortation, and hope for every generation of the faithful.

Do Isaiah 29 and Habakkuk 2 point to Lee Man-hee opening the scroll?

No. In Isaiah 29 the sealed book pictures spiritual blindness, and Habakkuk 2 describes a message that was meant to be understood in its own time. The “sealed book” image is not describing an actual supernatural lock placed on Scripture for thousands of years but is a vivid metaphor for the people’s spiritual blindness — their refusal to hear and obey God’s word despite having access to it. Habakkuk 2:2–3 was a clear, unsealed prophecy given to the prophet Habakkuk about God’s imminent judgment on Babylon, fulfilled in 539 BC. The command to “Record it legibly” shows it was meant to be understood in its own time, not hidden for thousands of years. Lee’s book applies both passages to the sealed book, and quotes Habakkuk 2:2–3 from the NIV (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, pp. 8–9).

Sources

SCJ’s own books (primary).

Printed page numbers.

  1. Lee Man-hee, The Creation of Heaven and Earth, English 2nd ed. (2014): pp. 5–9, 182, 339, 370–371, 431, 495–496, 535, 563, 565.
  2. Lee Man-hee, The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, English 1st ed. (2015): pp. 22, 26, 111, 215, 220, 346–347, 356, 551, 571.

BVC lesson pages used (class notes).

Lesson 13: sealed vs. opened word; Lesson 71: the sealed book and revelation; Lesson 106: Revelation 5 and the seven seals; Lesson 116: Revelation 10 and the open book.

BVC articles.

How Shincheonji interprets the Bible; Promised pastor: is Lee Man-hee “the one who overcomes” and the male child?; The 12 promised blessings; Who are the 144,000? Shincheonji’s twelve tribes, the 12,000 stadia, and the new covenant.

Closer Look Initiative.

“Open Scroll Issues,” closerlookinitiative.com/archives/6250. Bible Vaccine Center and Closer Look Initiative are run by the same team.

Scripture quotations are from the NET Bible®, https://netbible.com, copyright ©1996, 2019 by Biblical Studies Press, L.L.C. Used by permission. All rights reserved.