Part 5 · article 49 of 70
Who are the 144,000? Shincheonji’s twelve tribes, the 12,000 stadia, and the new covenant
Short answer
Shincheonji (SCJ) teaches that the 144,000 sealed in Revelation 7 are the priests of its twelve tribes, which it calls New Spiritual Israel. It reads the 12,000 stadia of Revelation 21:16 as 12,000 sealed people from each tribe, and it teaches that the new covenant is now fulfilled with them.
Revelation 21 measures a city, not a head count, and it puts Israel’s tribes on the gates and the apostles on the foundations. Hebrews says Jesus has already established the everlasting covenant. Read in context, the 144,000 do not point to a Korean organization.
On this page (9 sections)
- Short answer
- 1. Shincheonji’s perspective: the 144,000 and the twelve tribes
- 2. The twelve tribes of Revelation 7
- 3. The 12,000 stadia: SCJ’s map of the holy city onto the tribes
- 4. The transition of covenants
- Conclusion: the Lamb, not an organization, stands at the center
- Where to go next
- Frequently asked questions
- Sources
1. Shincheonji’s perspective: the 144,000 and the twelve tribes
SCJ’s teaching about the 144,000 sits inside its pattern of three eras, in which a person who overcomes creates twelve tribes. Lee Man-hee’s book says, “In every generation of Israel it is the one who overcomes who creates the twelve tribes. These overcomers are Jacob, Jesus, and the pastor promised by Jesus” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 515). Article 8, How Shincheonji interprets the Bible, sets out that framework in SCJ’s own terms. In the third era, SCJ says, the twelve tribes are the 144,000 of Revelation 7: “Then, the 144,000 people (12,000 from each tribe) are chosen as firstfruits, and they become the priests of God’s kingdom of New Spiritual Israel” (p. 515).
Sealed
SCJ defines the seal as God’s word. Lee’s book says, “People are sealed by God and Jesus when they hear and acknowledge that the word of revelation, which comes from God and Jesus, is true” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 196). The parables book says, “To seal or to mark is to testify to the word. To be sealed or to be marked is to accept the word they received and write it in their heart” (The Explanation of Parables, p. 74), and, “At the Second Coming, an angel seals the 144,000 of the Twelve Tribes through the seal of God — the one who overcomes — on their foreheads and makes them become God’s possession (Rv 7, Rv 14)” (p. 75). Lee’s book adds that the 144,000 “have mastered the Bible because they are sealed with the new covenant and the words that testify about its physical fulfillment” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 515).
Priests and the great multitude
SCJ treats the sealed and the white-robed crowd of Revelation 7:9 as two groups chosen in order: “As the firstfruits, the 144,000 become the pastors (i.e., priests and kings) of New Spiritual Israel. The great multitude in white become its congregation members (i.e., its people). The order in which they are chosen by God is also different; the 144,000 are chosen first and the great multitude in white are chosen later” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, pp. 196–197). The book also describes what the 144,000 receive: “Jesus and his disciples, who died as martyrs, descend upon the 144,000 people of the twelve tribes that are created on earth today and resurrect using their bodies” (p. 517).
Who qualifies, according to SCJ’s books
- Harvested, sealed and registered. “To be a part of the twelve tribes of New Spiritual Israel, which are promised in the Bible, people must be harvested from the churches (in the north, south, east, and west), receive God’s seal, and have their names written in the book of life. People who fail to meet these conditions become gentiles instead of the people of heaven” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 516).
- Not easy, and tied to the covenant. “It is not easy to become one of the 144,000 priests from the twelve tribes of New Spiritual Israel. Only those who receive God’s seal in fulfillment of the new covenant can join the 144,000.” The same passage adds, “Only those who keep the new covenant established by Jesus become the true chosen people, the twelve tribes of New Spiritual Israel” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, pp. 156–157).
- Outside the tribes, no salvation. “At the time of Revelation’s fulfillment, anyone who does not belong to the twelve tribes of New Spiritual Israel, which are God’s only chosen people, is a gentile who cannot be saved” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 196). The Revelation commentary says, “Not knowing whether New Spiritual Israel has appeared according to the prophecies and not knowing whether you belong to one of the twelve tribes testifies that you are a gentile. There is no salvation, eternal life, or heaven for gentiles” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 157).
What SCJ’s class notes add
Class notes that an attendee wrote down during SCJ’s Bible study seminar show how students are taught to see themselves in the number. They are not SCJ’s printed curriculum, so the wording is the note-taker’s.
- Lesson 109: Revelation 7, part one: “This is not a figurative number but represents a true count.” Each tribe at Mount Zion “must ensure they have at least 12,000 members.” The notes say some tribes have 30,000 or 40,000 members and others about 11,000. The summary tells students to say, “I am part of the 12 tribes. I am striving to be among the 144,000. I am one who is striving to be sealed.”
- Lesson 47: figurative seal: the board summary reads, “God’s will for my life is be part of the 144,000.”
- Special lesson 111: where are we in Revelation?: the notes say, “God has already found the 144,000 who were sealed from the 12 tribes of Israel,” yet priests “are those who are 100% sealed,” and “We are still in the period where priests are being determined.” In the Q&A, “In 2019, God identified 144,000 people who were sealed,” but “the number of those considered sealed dropped below 144,000.”
- Lesson 120: Revelation 14 and the 144,000: “As long as the number isn’t confirmed, the possibility remains open.”
2. The twelve tribes of Revelation 7
Shincheonji’s interpretation of the three eras depends upon its claim that each overcomer establishes twelve tribes. Jacob’s twelve sons establish Physical Israel. Jesus’ twelve disciples establish Spiritual Israel. SCJ teaches that Lee Man-hee establishes the twelve tribes of New Spiritual Israel: “At the second coming, the promised pastor, the one who overcomes, chooses wheat-like believers from among Spiritual Israel, and through them, he creates the twelve tribes of New Spiritual Israel” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 516).
Shincheonji identifies its administrative structure as the physical fulfillment of Revelation 7, where John describes 144,000 individuals sealed from twelve tribes of Israel. Lee’s book closes its chapter on the three Israels, “I hope that all believers can become the people of the kingdom of heaven by joining the twelve tribes that have been created today” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 517). SCJ’s Newcomers Education course dates “The establishment of the 12 tribes in the Suwon Public Stadium” to March 14, 1995 (SCJ Newcomers Education course, Units 7–8, slide 83). See also Lesson 109: Revelation 7, part one.
However, several features of Revelation challenge this interpretation.
The names of the twelve tribes
Revelation 7:4–8 explicitly identifies the following tribes: Judah, Reuben, Gad, Asher, Naphtali, Manasseh, Simeon, Levi, Issachar, Zebulun, Joseph, and Benjamin.
Shincheonji’s twelve tribes, however, are named after apostolic figures rather than the tribes listed in Revelation 7. The same course slide names them: Seoul James, Simon, Matthew, Philip, Bartholomew, John, Matthias, Thaddeus, Thomas, Busan James, Peter and Andrew (SCJ Newcomers Education course, Units 7–8, slide 83). This creates an immediate interpretive problem. If Revelation 7 provides the organizational structure that Shincheonji claims to fulfill, why does Shincheonji not use the tribal names given in that passage?
SCJ points to Revelation 21:14, where the twelve foundations of the New Jerusalem bear the names of the twelve apostles, to support its apostolic tribal names. Lee’s book says, “Jesus’ twelve disciples became the city’s twelve foundations (Rv 21:14). This city descends to the earth on the members of the twelve tribes” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, pp. 103–104). Class notes from SCJ’s Bible study list Revelation 21:14 and Matthew 10:2–4 among the lesson’s verses and record that the new kingdom’s twelve tribes “will be named after the 12 disciples” (Lesson 77: signs of the Lord’s second coming and the end of the age).
However, Revelation 21 distinguishes between the twelve tribes of Israel and the twelve apostles. The names of Israel’s tribes appear on the twelve gates, while the names of the apostles appear on the twelve foundations: “the names of the twelve tribes of the nation of Israel are written on the gates. … The wall of the city has twelve foundations, and on them are the twelve names of the twelve apostles of the Lamb” (Revelation 21:12, 14, NET). The distinction demonstrates the unity of God’s redemptive work across the Old and New Testaments rather than identifying the apostles as the names of a future set of administrative tribes.
The symbolic nature of the tribal list
The tribal list in Revelation 7 differs from the traditional list of Jacob’s twelve sons and from the territorial arrangements found elsewhere in the Old Testament.
For example:
- Dan is omitted.
- Ephraim is not explicitly named.
- Levi is included.
- Joseph and Manasseh appear together.
SCJ explains the missing Dan as a replacement pattern: “In the time of the Old Testament, the tribe of Dan was replaced by the tribe of Manasseh (Gn 49:17). At the time of the first coming, Judas Iscariot was replaced by Matthias” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 158). These variations suggest instead that John is using Israel’s tribal imagery for a theological purpose rather than simply reproducing a genealogical or administrative census.
The number 144,000 is also formed by multiplying twelve by twelve and then by one thousand. Within Revelation’s highly symbolic imagery, this numerical structure can represent the completeness of God’s covenant people. SCJ rejects that reading: “The number 144,000 is not symbolic; it is an actual number” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 156).
Christians hold different interpretations concerning whether the 144,000 refers to ethnic Israel, a particular group of believers, or the entirety of God’s redeemed people. However, none of these possibilities establishes that Revelation is predicting a Korean religious organization led by Lee Man-hee.
John hears the number but sees a great multitude
One of the most significant interpretive patterns in Revelation concerns the relationship between what John hears and what he subsequently sees.
In Revelation 5:5, John hears that the Lion of Judah has overcome. However, when John looks, he sees a Lamb who has been slain. The Lion and the Lamb are not two separate individuals. They are two complementary images of Jesus Christ.
A similar pattern appears in Revelation 7. John hears the number of those who have been sealed: “Now I heard the number of those who were marked with the seal, 144,000” (Revelation 7:4, NET). However, when he looks, he sees a great multitude that no one can count, consisting of people from every nation, tribe, people, and language: “After these things I looked, and here was an enormous crowd that no one could count, made up of persons from every nation, tribe, people, and language” (Revelation 7:9, NET).
This provides a strong basis for understanding the 144,000 and the great multitude as two complementary images of God’s redeemed people. The first image emphasizes their covenantal identity and completeness through Israel’s tribal symbolism. The second emphasizes their international composition and redemption through Christ.
Although this interpretation is debated among Christians, it provides a coherent explanation based upon Revelation’s own literary patterns.
Shincheonji, by contrast, interprets the 144,000 as an elite priestly group within its organization and the great multitude as a subsequent group of believers who gather through their testimony. Its commentary says the 144,000 “are new pastors who act as priests for the newly created kingdom of Israel” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 156), and that “The countless multitudes dressed in white become the people of New Spiritual Israel led by the 144,000 priests who reign with Christ generation after generation” (p. 164).
Yet Revelation 7 does not identify either group through their relationship to a modern promised pastor. Instead, the multitude stands before God and the Lamb, and its members have washed their robes in the blood of the Lamb (Revelation 7:9–14). SCJ reads that blood as something else: “the blood of the Lamb refers instead to the words of Jesus (Jn 15:3) that wash away our sins and cleanse our hearts” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 163). See Lesson 110: Revelation 7, part two.
Priests: the 144,000 or all believers?
SCJ makes the 144,000 the priests and the great multitude the people they lead. Revelation does not divide believers that way. Jesus “has appointed us as a kingdom, as priests serving his God and Father” (Revelation 1:6, NET), written to first-century believers. Revelation 5:9–10 says the Lamb “purchased for God persons from every tribe, language, people, and nation” and that “You have appointed them as a kingdom and priests to serve our God” (NET). The same people are both. Peter tells his readers, “you are a chosen race, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, a people of his own” (1 Peter 2:9, NET).
SCJ’s own book reads those verses more widely than its 144,000 doctrine does. It says, “God has appointed us as his kingdom and priests (Rv 1:6, 5:10)” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 460), and, “Those who hear the word from him and believe in its physical fulfillment become the priests and people of God’s kingdom (Rv 5:9-10)” (p. 493). Those verses give the priesthood to everyone the Lamb purchased, not to a first tier counted ahead of the rest.
The twelve tribes and the New Testament church
The significance of twelve within the New Testament is already established through Jesus and his apostles. In Matthew 19:28, Jesus tells his disciples that they will sit on twelve thrones, judging the twelve tribes of Israel. James 1:1 addresses his readers as the twelve tribes scattered among the nations (“the 12 tribes dispersed abroad,” NET). Ephesians 2:19–22 describes God’s household as being built upon the foundation of the apostles and prophets, with Jesus Christ as the cornerstone.
The imagery of twelve tribes therefore already has a place within the New Testament’s understanding of God’s people. It does not require another individual to establish twelve additional tribes at the second coming.
Furthermore, the mere creation of an organization consisting of twelve divisions cannot establish divine authorization. An organization can deliberately adopt a biblical structure without fulfilling biblical prophecy.
The question is not whether Shincheonji has twelve tribes, but whether Scripture predicts Shincheonji as those tribes.
Back to the top of §23. The 12,000 stadia: SCJ’s map of the holy city onto the tribes
What SCJ says
Revelation 21 describes the holy city and its measurements. The angel “measured the city with the measuring rod at 1,400 miles (its length and width and height are equal)” (Revelation 21:16, NET). The Greek gives that distance in stadia, and SCJ’s books quote it that way: “its length, width, and height are each 12,000 stadia. Its wall measures 144 cubits” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 265).
SCJ’s Revelation commentary then ties those numbers to the tribes:
“The holy city New Jerusalem is shaped like a cube; its length, width, and height are all equal. This has an important spiritual meaning. The twelve edges of the cube represent God’s twelve tribes. All twelve edges measure 12,000 stadia because each of the twelve tribes are made up of 12,000 people sealed with God’s word of truth. Thus, there are 144,000 sealed priests among the people of the twelve tribes.”
The commentary reads the wall the same way: “The city wall is 144 cubits thick because there are 144 representatives in charge of education: twelve educators in each of the twelve tribes” (pp. 526–527). It says “the golden measuring rod represents God’s word, which is used to measure spirits” (p. 525), and it calls the city “an organization built of the ‘wife-like’ spirits of the disciples who evangelized and trained other believers” (p. 524). It also says the new heaven and new earth “represent the kingdom of Shincheonji, the twelve tribes of New Spiritual Israel that are created as people are sealed with God’s seal (Rv 7)” (p. 509).
An earlier SCJ book makes the same link in plainer words. In The Reality of the Revelation (English translation, 1995), the author writes, “It says that the measurement of the city, the gates and the wall came to 12,000 furlongs, and that the length, the breadth and the height are equal. This implies each tribe is of 12,000, and that the twelve tribes reach 144,000” (p. 285). “Furlongs” is the King James word for stadia. The same book says, “the 144 cubits of the wall indicates the missionaries that wait on at the wall” (p. 286). Class notes from SCJ’s Bible study give a slightly different sum: the cube is read as “When you multiply 12,000 by 12, you get 144,000” (Lesson 129: Revelation 21).
Put together, SCJ’s map looks like this:
| Revelation 21 | SCJ’s reading | Source |
|---|---|---|
| The holy city | The organization of New Spiritual Israel, built of spirits | PFR pp. 509, 524 |
| Length, width and height, each 12,000 stadia | The twelve edges of a cube, one for each tribe of 12,000 sealed people | PFR p. 526; RoR p. 285 |
| Twelve tribes of 12,000 | 144,000 sealed priests | PFR p. 526 |
| The wall of 144 cubits | 144 education representatives, twelve in each tribe | PFR pp. 526–527 |
| The golden measuring rod | God’s word, measuring spirits | PFR p. 525 |
PFR: The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation (2015). RoR: The Reality of the Revelation (English translation, 1995).
What Revelation 21:15–17 measures
Here is the passage SCJ is reading:
“The angel who spoke to me had a golden measuring rod with which to measure the city and its foundation stones and wall. Now the city is laid out as a square, its length and width the same. He measured the city with the measuring rod at 1,400 miles (its length and width and height are equal). He also measured its wall, 144 cubits according to human measurement, which is also the angel’s” (Revelation 21:15–17, NET).
Tested against that text, SCJ’s map runs into several problems:
- The angel measures things, not people. The rod measures “the city and its foundation stones and wall,” and the results are distances. The passage counts no one, and the word “sealed” does not appear in it. Sealing is described in Revelation 7:3–8.
- One dimension, repeated. The city’s “length and width and height are equal,” so each side is the same distance. The text never speaks of edges, assigns a tribe to an edge, or multiplies the measurement by twelve. The “twelve edges” come from SCJ’s reading of a cube, not from the verse.
- The wall is 144 cubits, and nothing more. The NET gives it as “144 cubits according to human measurement, which is also the angel’s.” It does not say whether the figure is the wall’s height or its thickness, and it says nothing about educators or representatives.
- SCJ reads stadia as a distance elsewhere. In Revelation 14:20 the winepress blood flows for 1,600 stadia, which the NET renders as “almost 200 miles.” SCJ’s commentary takes that as a distance: “Two hundred miles is roughly the distance from Seoul to Busan” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 342). In Revelation 14:20, stadia measure a distance. In Revelation 21:16, SCJ turns the same unit into a head count.
- The same number does not mean the same thing. Revelation 7:5–8 says 12,000 were sealed from each tribe. Revelation 21:16 gives 12,000 stadia as the city’s dimension. Both numbers are built from twelve, and so is the rest of the passage: twelve gates, twelve angels, and twelve foundations (Revelation 21:12–14). A shared number is not a shared referent.
The cube itself points somewhere else. Solomon’s inner sanctuary, the room for God’s presence, was also a cube: “30 feet long, 30 feet wide, and 30 feet high” (1 Kings 6:20, NET). Revelation 21 then says, “The residence of God is among human beings. He will live among them, and they will be his people” (Revelation 21:3, NET), and that the city has no temple “because the Lord God—the All-Powerful—and the Lamb are its temple” (Revelation 21:22, NET). A city shaped like the sanctuary fits a picture of God dwelling with his people, not a count of an organization’s members.
The tribes on the gates and the apostles on the foundations
SCJ’s books see both lists in the text. Then they merge them. The Revelation commentary says, “The twelve foundations and the twelve gates symbolize the twelve disciples who become the twelve tribes leaders (Mt 19:28) of New Spiritual Israel” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 524). The Reality of the Revelation reads the verses the same way: “So if the foundations of the city are the twelve apostles, this house should be the twelve tribes of the twelve apostles (Luke 22:30)” (p. 285).
Revelation 21:12–14 keeps the two lists apart: the tribes of Israel on the gates, the apostles of the Lamb on the foundations. Matthew 19:28, which SCJ cites, keeps them apart too: the apostles will sit “on 12 thrones, judging the 12 tribes of Israel” (NET). The apostles are the judges, and the tribes are the ones judged. One city carries both names, and the text does not turn them into a second set of tribes named after the apostles.
A literal head count, or a picture of completeness?
SCJ’s map needs 12,000 to be a literal count. Its commentary says, “The number 144,000 is not symbolic; it is an actual number” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 156). Yet the class notes in Lesson 109 report tribes of 30,000 or 40,000 members and others of about 11,000. If the number were a literal headcount, there would be exactly 12,000 from each tribe, not 30,000 in some and 11,000 in others. The notes in Lesson 120 say the total is still open: “As long as the number isn’t confirmed, the possibility remains open.” A number that changes with each tribe’s membership is not the fixed 12,000 per tribe that Revelation 7:5–8 gives.
God’s acceptance of a person does not depend on a quota either. Jesus says, “the one who comes to me I will never send away” (John 6:37, NET).
4. The transition of covenants
How SCJ moves the covenant from one era to the next
Shincheonji does not claim a third covenant. It teaches that Jesus initiated the new covenant but sends the Advocate to complete the new heaven and new earth, and that this new covenant is physically fulfilled through Lee Man-hee and the establishment of New Spiritual Israel. Lee’s book says, “Before he ascended to heaven Jesus promised that he would send the spirit of truth, the advocate,” and that “Jesus will give all of his power and authority to the one who fights and overcomes the Nicolaitans” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 78). It calls the prophecies of the four gospels and Revelation “the new covenant that will be fulfilled in the future” (p. 116) and says, “Today, we at Shincheonji are proclaiming all over the world that the new covenant, Revelation, has been fulfilled according to the prophecies” (p. 342). In SCJ’s terms, the same new covenant is then made with New Spiritual Israel: “After Jesus fulfills the covenant he made with Spiritual Israel, he makes a new covenant with New Spiritual Israel” (p. 169).
The three cards give the outline, and the quotations below them give SCJ’s own words.
-
Era 1
Old Testament
- People
- Physical Israel, Jacob’s twelve tribes
- Covenant, in SCJ’s terms
- The old, or first, covenant
- What SCJ says happens
- The people break it, and Physical Israel ends at Jesus’ first coming
-
Era 2
First coming
- People
- Spiritual Israel, Jesus’ twelve disciples and Christians
- Covenant, in SCJ’s terms
- Jesus’ new covenant, made in his blood
- What SCJ says happens
- It is prophesied that Spiritual Israel betrays and comes to an end
-
Era 3
Second coming
- People
- New Spiritual Israel, the sealed 144,000 and the great multitude
- Covenant, in SCJ’s terms
- The same new covenant, now fulfilled
- What SCJ says happens
- The 144,000 are sealed, and the twelve tribes of New Spiritual Israel are created
The old covenant with Physical Israel. “God reveals his plans to his chosen people, rears them, and makes a covenant with them. If they were to keep the covenant, they would become the tree of life that receives salvation” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 13). “Paul referred to the Old Testament law as the first covenant, and he said that Jesus established the new covenant because there was a problem with the first covenant (Heb 8:7-13)” (p. 457).
The pattern of betrayal. SCJ gives the order in which it says God’s work is fulfilled, from “(c) establishment of a covenant with the chosen people, (d) betrayal of the covenant by the chosen people, (e) destruction of the chosen people by the gentiles, (f) selection of a new pastor” to “(i) creation of a new kingdom, (j) establishment of a new covenant and entering the sabbath rest” (p. 53). It defines the sin: “Betrayal is breaking the covenant you have made with God” (p. 14). And it applies the pattern to both earlier peoples: “From the time of Adam to the time of Revelation, God has always made a covenant with his chosen people. His chosen people, however, have always betrayed their covenant with God. Thus, even at the time of the second coming, Spiritual Israel is prophesied to betray God just like the people of Physical Israel did (Rv 11:8)” (p. 133).
Jesus’ new covenant with Spiritual Israel. “Jesus, who was born of the holy spirit, sowed God’s seed … and made the new covenant (Jer 31:31-33; Lk 22:20)” (p. 162). “At the time of the Lord’s second coming, which is when Spiritual Israel comes to an end, people will be divided between judgment and salvation depending on whether or not they keep the words of the new covenant” (p. 168).
The same covenant, fulfilled. SCJ defines the new covenant as the promises of the New Testament, and one of those promises is the 144,000: “The new covenant that Jesus established refers to the promised words of the New Testament.” The list that follows includes, “He promised to create God’s kingdom by placing God’s seal on the 144,000 people of the twelve tribes and by gathering the great multitude dressed in white” (p. 457). The covenant with New Spiritual Israel is made of those same promises: “Out of all the promises Jesus made in the New Testament, the prophecies of Rv 2-3 represent the covenant made with the pastor and congregation members living at the time those prophecies are fulfilled” (p. 169). Class notes say it more bluntly: “Therefore, the new covenant equals Revelation – they are one and the same,” and it “cannot be fully kept until Revelation is fulfilled” (Lesson 79: Jesus’ new covenant established in blood).
How the twelve tribes and the 144,000 carry the transition
In SCJ’s scheme, the twelve tribes are the vehicle that carries the covenant from one stage to the next, and the 144,000 are the stage’s priests.
- Twelve tribes at every stage. “Jacob’s twelve sons became the twelve tribes of Physical Israel, and Jesus chose twelve disciples to create the twelve tribes during the first coming. At the second coming, the promised pastor, the one who overcomes, chooses wheat-like believers from among Spiritual Israel, and through them, he creates the twelve tribes of New Spiritual Israel” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 516).
- The Advocate and the new heaven and new earth. SCJ says the new heaven and new earth are the tribes themselves: “The new heaven and new earth represent the city of the millennium, the twelve tribes of New Spiritual Israel, which are being created today through the harvest of grain-like believers” (p. 266).
- The sealed keep the covenant. The 144,000 “are sealed with the new covenant and the words that testify about its physical fulfillment” (p. 515). “Only those who keep the new covenant established by Jesus become the true chosen people, the twelve tribes of New Spiritual Israel” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 157).
- The earlier community ends. SCJ places the second coming at the point “when Spiritual Israel comes to an end” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 168), and its new covenant is then fulfilled with the new people.
Nevertheless, its framework requires the previous community of believers to lose its covenantal position and a new religious organization to become the exclusive location of salvation. The Revelation commentary says believers “must be harvested and taken to Mount Zion (i.e., the barn of heaven) because all other churches, pastors, and people come to an end” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 11).
This raises an important question: does the New Testament anticipate such a replacement?
Jesus already established the new covenant
At the Last Supper, Jesus identifies the cup as the new covenant in his blood: “This cup that is poured out for you is the new covenant in my blood” (Luke 22:20, NET). Paul repeats this teaching in 1 Corinthians 11:25. Hebrews 9:15 explains that Jesus is the mediator of the new covenant because his death provides redemption.
The new covenant is therefore established through the sacrificial death of Jesus Christ. Although Christians await its ultimate consummation, the New Testament presents believers as already participating in this covenant.
Hebrews 8 describes one change of covenants, not three. Jesus “has obtained a superior ministry, since the covenant that he mediates is also better” (Hebrews 8:6, NET), and “When he speaks of a new covenant, he makes the first obsolete” (Hebrews 8:13, NET). The new covenant also belongs to the whole people of God: “I will put my laws in their minds, and I will inscribe them on their hearts. … they will all know me, from the least to the greatest” (Hebrews 8:10–11, NET). SCJ’s book uses the same passage to explain the seal: “God promised that in setting up the new covenant he would write his laws in believers’ hearts and minds (Heb 8:10)” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 196). In Hebrews, that writing on the heart marks every member of the covenant, “from the least to the greatest,” not a first tier of 144,000 priests.
The new covenant is everlasting
Hebrews 13:20 describes the blood of Jesus as the blood of the eternal covenant. Hebrews 7:24–25 explains that Jesus possesses a permanent priesthood because he lives forever. Consequently, he is able to save completely those who approach God through him: “he holds his priesthood permanently since he lives forever. So he is able to save completely those who come to God through him because he always lives to intercede for them” (Hebrews 7:24–25, NET).
Unlike the former priesthood, which required successive priests because of human mortality, Jesus’ priesthood does not require another individual to succeed him. Hebrews 10:14 also teaches that through a single sacrifice Jesus has perfected those who are being made holy.
The new covenant does not require another mediator because its mediator remains alive and his sacrifice remains sufficient.
The church belongs to Christ
Shincheonji teaches that Spiritual Israel eventually betrays God and must be replaced by New Spiritual Israel: “In his second coming, Jesus judges Spiritual Israel and brings it to an end because of its corruption (Rv 6). He then creates New Spiritual Israel (Rv 7, 14)” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 163).
The New Testament certainly warns about apostasy, false teachers, corruption, and unfaithfulness within Christian communities. However, the existence of apostasy does not establish that the entire body of Christ must be replaced by another organization.
Jesus promises in Matthew 16:18 that the gates of Hades will not overpower his church. Ephesians 3:21 gives glory to God in the church and in Christ Jesus throughout all generations. Matthew 28:20 promises Christ’s continuing presence with his disciples until the end of the age: “I am with you always, to the end of the age” (Matthew 28:20, NET).
These passages support the continuing relationship between Christ and his people. They do not predict that salvation will eventually depend upon transferring membership from Christianity to another religious kingdom established by a new pastor.
Mount Zion and the new covenant
SCJ’s book names Shincheonji as the place believers must come to: “Therefore, all believers must come to Mt. Zion (Shincheonji) where God’s spiritual kingdom descends” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 460). Hebrews says believers have already arrived: “you have come to Mount Zion, the city of the living God, the heavenly Jerusalem … and to Jesus, the mediator of a new covenant” (Hebrews 12:22–24, NET). The tribes of Israel and the apostles of the Lamb stand together in one city (Revelation 21:12–14), and the covenant passes once, from the first to the new, in the blood of the Lamb. SCJ’s scheme needs the covenant’s people to change again, through a new set of twelve tribes.
Back to the top of §4Conclusion: the Lamb, not an organization, stands at the center
Shincheonji answers “Who are the 144,000?” with a chain of links. The 144,000 are the priests of its twelve tribes. The 12,000 stadia of the holy city measure those tribes. And the new covenant passes through them to New Spiritual Israel.
Each link weakens when it is tested against the text.
Revelation 7 lists the tribes of Israel, not the apostles. John hears a number and sees a great multitude.
Revelation 21 measures a city with a rod and counts no one. It puts the tribes on the gates and the apostles on the foundations, and SCJ itself reads stadia as a distance in Revelation 14:20.
Hebrews says Jesus has already established the new covenant, that it is eternal, and that its priest needs no successor.
Christians hold different views about who the 144,000 are. Nothing in Revelation 7 or 14 says that anyone must join an organization to be counted among them.
Revelation keeps directing attention to the Lamb.
The 144,000 are with “the Lamb standing on Mount Zion” (Revelation 14:1, NET).
The crowd no one could count “washed their robes and made them white in the blood of the Lamb” (Revelation 7:14, NET).
And the covenant is “the new covenant in my blood” (Luke 22:20, NET).
Where to go next
- Glossary: twelve tribes, 144,000
- Lessons: 60, figurative 3 types of Israel; 47, figurative seal; 109, Revelation 7, part one; 110, Revelation 7, part two; 111, where are we in Revelation?; 120, Revelation 14 and the 144,000; 129, Revelation 21; 79, Jesus’ new covenant established in blood
- Shincheonji FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Who are the 144,000, according to Shincheonji?
SCJ says the 144,000 are the priests of its twelve tribes, chosen first, with the great multitude in white gathered after them. Lee’s book says, “As the firstfruits, the 144,000 become the pastors (i.e., priests and kings) of New Spiritual Israel. The great multitude in white become its congregation members (i.e., its people)” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, pp. 196–197). The Revelation commentary says, “The number 144,000 is not symbolic; it is an actual number” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 156). In Revelation 7, John hears the number 144,000 and then sees “an enormous crowd that no one could count” from every nation (Revelation 7:4, 9, NET).
Does the 12,000 stadia of Revelation 21 mean 12,000 people sealed from each tribe?
No. Revelation 21:16 gives the city’s dimensions, and the passage counts no one. SCJ teaches, “All twelve edges measure 12,000 stadia because each of the twelve tribes are made up of 12,000 people sealed with God’s word of truth” (The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, 2015, p. 526). The NET reads, “He measured the city with the measuring rod at 1,400 miles (its length and width and height are equal)” (Revelation 21:16). SCJ treats stadia as a distance in Revelation 14:20: “Two hundred miles is roughly the distance from Seoul to Busan” (p. 342).
Why are Shincheonji’s twelve tribes named after apostles instead of the tribes in Revelation 7?
SCJ names its tribes after the apostles and points to Revelation 21:14, where the apostles’ names are on the city’s foundations. Its course lists the tribes as Seoul James, Simon, Matthew, Philip, Bartholomew, John, Matthias, Thaddeus, Thomas, Busan James, Peter and Andrew (Newcomers Education course, Units 7–8, slide 83). An earlier SCJ book says, “So if the foundations of the city are the twelve apostles, this house should be the twelve tribes of the twelve apostles (Luke 22:30)” (The Reality of the Revelation, p. 285). Revelation 7:4–8 names Judah, Reuben, Gad and the other tribes of Israel, and Revelation 21:12–14 puts Israel’s tribes on the gates and the apostles on the foundations.
Does Shincheonji teach a third covenant?
No. SCJ teaches that Jesus initiated the new covenant and that the same new covenant is then fulfilled with New Spiritual Israel. Lee’s book says, “After Jesus fulfills the covenant he made with Spiritual Israel, he makes a new covenant with New Spiritual Israel” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 169), and it defines that covenant as Jesus’ own promises: “The new covenant that Jesus established refers to the promised words of the New Testament” (p. 457). The 144,000 “are sealed with the new covenant and the words that testify about its physical fulfillment” (p. 515). Hebrews describes one change of covenants: “When he speaks of a new covenant, he makes the first obsolete” (Hebrews 8:13, NET). Hebrews 13:20 calls the blood of Jesus the blood of the eternal covenant.
Are the 144,000 and the great multitude two different groups?
SCJ says they are two groups, but John hears a number and sees a crowd, which gives a strong basis for reading them as two images of the same redeemed people. Christians debate that reading. SCJ teaches that “the 144,000 are chosen first and the great multitude in white are chosen later” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 197). In Revelation 7, John hears “the number of those who were marked with the seal, 144,000” and then sees “an enormous crowd that no one could count” (Revelation 7:4, 9, NET). Those in the crowd “washed their robes and made them white in the blood of the Lamb” (Revelation 7:14, NET).
Sources
SCJ’s own books (primary).
Printed page numbers.
- Lee Man-hee, The Creation of Heaven and Earth, English 2nd ed. (2014): pp. 13, 14, 53, 78, 103–104, 116, 133, 162, 163, 168, 169, 196–197, 265, 266, 342, 457, 460, 493, 515–517.
- Lee Man-hee, The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, English 1st ed. (2015): pp. 11, 156–158, 163, 164, 342, 509, 524–527.
- Lee Man-hee, The Explanation of Parables (English): pp. 74, 75.
- Lee Man-hee, The Reality of the Revelation, English translation (Shincheonji Publishing, translated 1995; first printed 1993): pp. 285–286.
SCJ course.
Newcomers Education course, Units 7–8, slide 83 (“The establishment of the 12 tribes in the Suwon Public Stadium,” March 14, 1995, with the twelve tribe names).
BVC lesson and glossary pages used.
Lesson 47: figurative seal (class notes); Lesson 77: signs of the Lord’s second coming and the end of the age (class notes); Lesson 79: Jesus’ new covenant established in blood (class notes); Lesson 109: Revelation 7, part one (class notes); Lesson 110: Revelation 7, part two; Special lesson 111: where are we in Revelation? (class notes); Lesson 120: Revelation 14 and the 144,000 (class notes); Lesson 129: Revelation 21 (class notes); twelve tribes; 144,000.
Scripture quotations are from the NET Bible®, https://netbible.com, copyright ©1996, 2019 by Biblical Studies Press, L.L.C. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
