Part 3 · article 18 of 70
Is Lee Man-hee the Advocate or Counselor in John 14–16?
Back to Promised pastorShort answer
Shincheonji (SCJ) teaches that the Advocate Jesus promised in John 14–16 is a spirit who speaks through one promised pastor, and that the person who receives that spirit also becomes the advocate. Lee’s book says, “the person who receives the spirit of the advocate also becomes the advocate who speaks on behalf of Jesus” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 441).
But the term “Advocate” (Greek: Parakletos) is never used in connection with angels, let alone a symbolic figure in Revelation. Every time the Bible refers to the Parakletos, it affirms that this Advocate is a divine person, either the Holy Spirit or Jesus, not an angel, and certainly not a man through whom an angel supposedly speaks.
Bible quotations are from the NET Bible. The NET translates the Greek word Parakletos as “Advocate.” SCJ’s books use “advocate” and “counselor.”
On this page (6 sections)
1. Shincheonji’s perspective: the Advocate and the promised pastor
Two advocates
Shincheonji claims that Lee Man-hee is the fulfillment of the Advocate in flesh. God, Jesus, and the angels are working first through Lee Man-hee in order to proclaim the “open” and true understanding of the word.
Lee’s book says there are two advocates:
In SCJ’s own words
“The first advocate is Jesus (1 Jn 2:1), and because Jesus said he would send another advocate (Jn 14:16-17, 26), the other advocate must not be Jesus”
It describes the second as a spirit:
In SCJ’s own words
“the advocate is also referred to as the spirit of truth, it refers to a spirit and not a physical being”
The spirit works through a man
SCJ’s book says that spirit chooses a pastor:
In SCJ’s own words
“The spirit of the advocate that Jesus sends to this earth chooses a pastor through whom to work. This person is the promised pastor of the New Testament and works in the physical world as the physical advocate because the spirit of the advocate is with him”
Shincheonji would claim that the mighty angel of Revelation 10, who delivers the open scroll to the New John, Lee Man-hee, is the true fulfillment of the Advocate that Jesus promised in John chapters 14–16. The book says so directly:
In SCJ’s own words
“The angel who brings the book is the spirit of the advocate and John, who receives the book, is the promised pastor through whom the spirit of the advocate speaks”
The book then draws the conclusion for believers:
In SCJ’s own words
“Today, which is the time of the second coming, nothing is more important for Christians than finding the pastor who acts as the advocate because he speaks on behalf of the spirit of truth”
Both of Lee’s books also list the author on the title page as “Advocate—Manhee Lee.”
Class notes taken by an attendee of SCJ’s Bible study (not SCJ’s printed curriculum) add that “All spirits of God are holy spirits” and that any of them “can be sent to do the work of a holy spirit” (Lesson 84: the Spirit of Truth, the Counselor). Hebrews 1:14 is among the verses that lesson lists.
Shincheonji identifies this pastor as Lee Man-hee. See Who is Lee Man-hee? for the roles SCJ gives him.
2. The Advocate in Scripture
Let’s see if this is biblical.
The word “Advocate” (Parakletos) is never used for the angel in Revelation
One of the most fundamental issues with Shincheonji’s claim that the mighty angel in Revelation 10 is the “Advocate” promised by Jesus in John 14–16 is the misuse of the term “Advocate” (Greek: Parakletos). In the original Greek, Parakletos is a specific term used only five times in the entire New Testament—four times in the Gospel of John (14:16, 14:26, 15:26, 16:7) and once in 1 John 2:1. In each of these instances, it refers either to the Holy Spirit or to Jesus Christ himself, who intercedes on our behalf before the Father. The term is never used in connection with angels, let alone a symbolic figure in Revelation.
“Then I will ask the Father, and he will give you another Advocate to be with you forever— the Spirit of truth, whom the world cannot accept, because it does not see him or know him. But you know him, because he resides with you and will be in you.”
“But the Advocate, the Holy Spirit, whom the Father will send in my name, will teach you everything and will cause you to remember everything I said to you.”
“But if anyone does sin, we have an advocate with the Father, Jesus Christ the Righteous One.”
Revelation 10 describes a “mighty angel” holding a little scroll, but the text never uses the word Parakletos to describe this angel. If the biblical authors intended readers to understand this figure as the fulfillment of Jesus’ promise in John 14–16, we would expect some kind of linguistic or contextual signal tying them together. But there is none. Instead, every time the Bible refers to the Parakletos, it affirms that this Advocate is a divine person—either the Holy Spirit or Jesus—not an angel, and certainly not a man through whom an angel supposedly speaks. This absence of textual and linguistic connection seriously undermines SCJ’s interpretation.
The Advocate is omnipresent, unlike an angel or a man
A key distinction between the biblical Advocate and Shincheonji’s interpretation lies in the nature of the Advocate’s presence. In John 14:17, Jesus tells his disciples that the Spirit of truth “resides with you and will be in you.” This indicates an internal and personal presence of the Holy Spirit within each believer. Later, in John 14:26 and 16:13, Jesus explains that the Spirit will teach, remind, and guide his followers into all truth. These functions require ongoing interaction with multiple individuals across time and geography. The implication is clear: the Advocate must be omnipresent to dwell in and guide all believers at once—something neither an angel nor a single human being, like Lee Man-hee, can do.
Unlike the Holy Spirit, both angels and humans are spatially limited. An angel may be powerful, but cannot indwell believers across the globe. Likewise, a man claiming to be the Advocate “in the flesh” cannot simultaneously guide, teach, and remind the global body of Christ. The Holy Spirit’s ability to work within every believer, in every place, at all times, is an essential attribute of the true Advocate. By redefining the Advocate as an angel working through Lee Man-hee, Shincheonji introduces a theological contradiction: they assign divine, omnipresent functions to finite beings. This distorts the biblical picture of the Holy Spirit and ultimately diminishes the role of God himself in the life of the believer.
Is the Advocate many ministering spirits?
Shincheonji will often cite Hebrews 1:14 to argue that the Counselor of John 14–16 could be understood as many spirits or as one who uses many spirits to help:
“Are they not all ministering spirits, sent out to serve those who will inherit salvation?”
But this interpretation breaks down when compared to Jesus’ actual promise. In John 14:16, Jesus speaks of “another Advocate” (Parakletos) in the singular, not a group of spirits. This Advocate is consistently identified as the Holy Spirit in the surrounding context (John 14:26; 15:26; 16:7), not as a collection of angelic beings.
Furthermore, the Advocate has the divine attribute of omnipresence—“to be with you forever” (John 14:16) and to reside “with you and… in you” (John 14:17). No angel or group of angels shares this quality. Angels are created beings with limited presence and power, whereas the promised Advocate is God’s Spirit himself, able to indwell all believers everywhere at all times. This makes equating the Advocate with “many ministering spirits” a complete mismatch with both the language and the theology of the text.
Is the Spirit just the word?
Shincheonji may try to sidestep the issue of the Advocate’s omnipresence by claiming that it is merely the words of the Counselor that remain with us, rather than the presence of the Spirit himself—reducing the promise to the delivery of doctrine. But John 16:13 says, “But when he, the Spirit of truth, comes, he will guide you into all truth.” The Greek verb for “guide” (hodēgēsei) is ongoing and relational, describing an active, continuing work rather than a one-time information drop.
The Spirit’s role is not that of a courier who delivers teaching and then departs, but of a personal guide who walks alongside believers, illuminating truth in real time, applying Christ’s words to our lives, and transforming us from within. This relational dynamic is reinforced by Jesus’ promise that the Spirit “resides with you and will be in you” (John 14:17), something no impersonal transmission of words—or any angel—can replicate.
SCJ’s view replaces the Spirit with a man
One of the most theologically troubling aspects of Shincheonji’s doctrine is that it effectively replaces the role of the Holy Spirit with a man, Lee Man-hee. SCJ teaches that the “Spirit of the Advocate” works through the angel in Revelation 10, and that this angel in turn works through Lee, making him the “Advocate in flesh.” But this framework contradicts what Jesus clearly taught in John 14–16. The Advocate Jesus promised was not merely a messenger delivering information but the divine presence of God himself—the Holy Spirit—dwelling within all believers. Reducing this to a single man who claims exclusive authority to interpret Revelation strips the Spirit of his relational, omnipresent, and ongoing ministry to the global Church.
This doctrine elevates a human to a position that Scripture reserves only for God. It implies that believers cannot understand God’s Word or receive salvation apart from Lee Man-hee, positioning him as the exclusive mediator between God and man—a role Scripture says belongs to Jesus Christ alone (1 Timothy 2:5). Furthermore, this view denies the sufficiency of the Holy Spirit’s guidance throughout church history and introduces a new hierarchy where divine truth flows not from the Spirit to all believers, but from one man to everyone else. In doing so, SCJ diminishes the person and work of the Holy Spirit and redefines Christianity around a human figure, not around Christ.
“For there is one God and one intermediary between God and humanity, Christ Jesus, himself human.”
Where to go next
Frequently asked questions
Does Shincheonji teach that Lee Man-hee is the Advocate?
SCJ teaches that the Advocate is a spirit who speaks through one promised pastor, and that the person who receives the spirit also becomes the advocate.
Lee’s book says, “the person who receives the spirit of the advocate also becomes the advocate who speaks on behalf of Jesus” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 441). Both of Lee’s books list the author on the title page as “Advocate—Manhee Lee.”
Is the word “Advocate” ever used for the angel in Revelation 10?
No, the word Parakletos is never used in connection with angels.
In the original Greek, Parakletos is a specific term used only five times in the entire New Testament—four times in the Gospel of John (14:16, 14:26, 15:26, 16:7) and once in 1 John 2:1. In each of these instances, it refers either to the Holy Spirit or to Jesus Christ himself, who intercedes on our behalf before the Father.
Can an angel or a man be the Advocate Jesus promised?
The promised Advocate is God’s Spirit himself, able to indwell all believers everywhere at all times.
Angels are created beings with limited presence and power. Jesus tells his disciples that the Spirit of truth “resides with you and will be in you” (John 14:17, NET), and no angel or group of angels shares this quality.
Sources
SCJ’s own books (primary).
Printed page numbers.
- Lee Man-hee, The Creation of Heaven and Earth, English 2nd ed. (2014): title page; pp. 78, 436, 437–438, 440, 441, 442.
SCJ class notes (not SCJ’s printed curriculum).
Attendee notes from SCJ’s Bible study seminar, as summarized on BVC’s Lesson 84 page.
BVC lesson pages used.
Lesson 84 and Lesson 116; glossary entries counselor and new John.
Closer Look Initiative.
“Promised Pastor,” closerlookinitiative.com/archives/6253. Sections used: “Who is the Advocate?” and the Advocate sections under “A Christian Response.” Bible Vaccine Center and Closer Look Initiative are run by the same team.
Scripture.
NET Bible, quoted as (NET).
Scripture quotations are from the NET Bible®, https://netbible.com, copyright ©1996, 2019 by Biblical Studies Press, L.L.C. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
