Part 1 · article 6 of 70
How Shincheonji treats critics and ex-members
Short answer
SCJ’s books describe people who leave and then oppose the church as “antichrists that have united with the spirit of Satan.” They say anyone who “interferes” with someone seeking the promised pastor “belong[s] to the devil.” SCJ also describes itself as a persecuted minority. Former members and one government report rules that cut members off from outside voices.
On this page (10 sections)
Why this matters
How a group talks about its critics tells you what happens when a member has doubts. If every objection is “persecution” and everyone who leaves is an enemy, a member can’t weigh a question on its merits. This article sets out what SCJ’s own books say, how SCJ presents itself, and what a government investigation and named former members have reported. Article 62 goes deeper: How Shincheonji Responds to Criticism and Persecution coming soon.
What SCJ’s books say about those who leave
“Antichrists”
The clearest statement is in The Creation of Heaven and Earth:
In SCJ’s own words
“Those who have left their positions and homes within the twelve tribes of Shincheonji to deceive, cause division, create their own sects, and oppose God are antichrists that have united with the spirit of Satan. Anyone who receives this kind of person becomes a part of their group.”
Note the second sentence. Taking in someone who has left is treated as joining them. For a member, that turns contact with a former friend into a spiritual risk. (See twelve tribes.)
“Seven more evil spirits”
A few pages earlier, the book applies Jesus’ saying about the returning unclean spirit to members who stop believing:
In SCJ’s own words
“Today, people within Shincheonji who have been cleansed by the word only to fall into unbelief will receive seven more evil spirits regardless of whether they realize it (Mt 12:43-45; Lk 11:24-26). This is why the Bible says that it is impossible for a person who has tasted the powers of the coming age to be brought back to repentance if they fall away (Heb 6:4-6).”
To be precise, this passage is about people “within Shincheonji” who “fall into unbelief,” not about every outside critic. But it applies directly to anyone who leaves because they no longer believe the teaching. The book says such a person can’t be brought back to repentance.
People who “interfere”
The book also applies a test to anyone who gets in the way:
In SCJ’s own words
“Now is the time, since the prophecies are being fulfilled, when everyone must find the promised pastor and the place he appears. Anyone, who dallies in accomplishing this task or who interferes with someone else, proves that they belong to the devil (Mt 5:10-12, 23:13).”
By this standard, a parent who warns a child, or a pastor who warns a congregation, “belong[s] to the devil.” See promised pastor.
Pastors who warn their churches
SCJ’s books treat warnings from other churches as a repeat of the Pharisees’ opposition to Jesus:
In SCJ’s own words
“The children of Satan (the weeds) will be left behind in their churches. At the time of Jesus’ first coming, the Pharisees and Sadducees prevented people from going to Jesus, who was testifying the gospel of heaven (the physical fulfillment of the Old Testament). Even today, at the time of the second coming, pastors are preventing people from moving toward the one testifying the physical fulfillment of the New Testament. These pastors accomplish their goals by calling the promised pastor a cult leader.”
In this framework, a warning becomes evidence for SCJ’s claim: if pastors oppose Lee, that fits the pattern of the Pharisees. A framework in which criticism only confirms the claim can’t be tested by criticism. Glossary: bad report, Satan’s tactics.
How SCJ presents itself: a persecuted minority
SCJ’s public statements describe the church as a victim. In a March 2020 open letter, issued during the COVID-19 outbreak in Daegu, it said:
“Shincheonji Church of Jesus did not create COVID-19. We are citizens who have followed the instructions of the authorities, and we are victims of the virus and religious persecution.”
The same letter asks, “Is not belonging to mainstream churches in Korea a reason to die?” It refers to members taken to “so-called ‘Cult Counseling Offices’” and says two female members were killed by family members, one by her husband and one by her father.
Some of these claims describe real harm. Coercion and violence against anyone are wrong, and Christians should say so plainly. But real persecution and honest criticism are different things. Asking a group to name itself, comparing its teaching with Scripture, or a former member telling their story is not persecution. SCJ’s books, quoted above, don’t make that distinction.
What a government investigation and former members report
A government investigation
Singapore’s Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) investigated SCJ’s local chapter in 2020 and reported:
“A controlling influence is then exerted over these young members, requiring them to comply with strict instructions to conceal the local existence of SCJ and their involvement with it. Members are not allowed to contact one another, verify teachings with other churches, or inform their families of their involvement.”
A rule against checking teachings with other churches matches the books’ view of other pastors (CHE p. 302).
Former members, and SCJ’s reply
Named former members describe being steered away from outside information. A UK student told The Independent, “I was told not to use the internet to research things.”
SCJ’s representatives did not deny this. Responding to The Independent, they said: “It is certainly true that Shincheonji does recommend to members not to read anti-Shincheonji literature, including articles found on the internet” (The Independent, Aug 9, 2022). That is SCJ’s own statement, reported in the paper.
Leaving is costly. Laurie, a former head instructor in Namibia who now helps people leave, told the same paper that people who join young “don’t know how to live a normal life” when they leave. For practical next steps, see Rebuilding your life after leaving.
Per ex-member testimony, even long-serving leaders can be expelled suddenly and then shunned. That fits the warning on CHE p. 355 about receiving those who leave. We haven’t cited a specific case here because we don’t yet have one we can source publicly.
What the Bible says
Testing is commended, not condemned
Luke praises the Bereans for checking Paul’s teaching against Scripture:
“These Jews were more open-minded than those in Thessalonica, for they eagerly received the message, examining the scriptures carefully every day to see if these things were so.”
John tells believers to do the same with anyone who claims to speak for God: “Dear friends, do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits to determine if they are from God, because many false prophets have gone out into the world” (1 John 4:1, NET). A teacher who is telling the truth gains nothing by forbidding the test. See discernment.
The way home stays open
In Jesus’ parable, the father doesn’t wait for the son to prove himself:
“So he got up and went to his father. But while he was still a long way from home his father saw him, and his heart went out to him; he ran and hugged his son and kissed him.”
Contrast this with CHE p. 355, which warns that anyone who receives a former member “becomes a part of their group.” The gospel runs the other way: the Father runs toward the one who comes home.
If you have left, or are thinking about it
You aren’t alone, and leaving doesn’t make you an enemy of God. Many former members have walked this road. These pages can help:
- How to leave Shincheonji
- Rebuilding your life after leaving
- For churches: welcoming former members
- Family Packet, for parents, spouses and friends
- Contact us to talk with someone who has been there
Where to go next
Frequently asked questions
What does Shincheonji call people who leave the church?
SCJ’s books describe people who leave and then oppose the church as “antichrists that have united with the spirit of Satan” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 355).
The same passage says, “Anyone who receives this kind of person becomes a part of their group.” That teaching is taken up further in How Shincheonji Responds to Criticism and Persecution; see also twelve tribes.
Does Shincheonji tell members not to read criticism?
Yes. Responding to The Independent, SCJ’s representatives said, “It is certainly true that Shincheonji does recommend to members not to read anti-Shincheonji literature, including articles found on the internet.”
A UK student told the same paper, “I was told not to use the internet to research things” (The Independent, Aug 9, 2022). If you are checking the teaching, start with How to leave Shincheonji.
What does Shincheonji say about parents or pastors who warn someone against it?
SCJ’s books say that anyone who “interferes” with someone seeking the promised pastor “prove[s] that they belong to the devil” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, pp. 188–189).
The same book treats warnings from other churches as a repeat of the Pharisees’ opposition to Jesus (p. 302). See promised pastor, bad report, and Satan’s tactics.
Does Shincheonji teach that a person who leaves cannot repent?
SCJ’s book applies Hebrews 6:4–6 to people “within Shincheonji” who “fall into unbelief,” and it says they “will receive seven more evil spirits” and “it is impossible for [them] to be brought back to repentance” (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, 2014, p. 352).
The New Testament, by contrast, shows the father running toward the son who comes home (Luke 15:20, NET). If you have left, or are thinking about it, see How to leave Shincheonji and Rebuilding your life after leaving.
How does Shincheonji describe public criticism of the church?
SCJ’s public statements describe the church as a persecuted minority.
In a March 2020 open letter it said, “we are victims of the virus and religious persecution” (SCJ, “Letter of Appeal from Shincheonji Church of Jesus in Regards to COVID-19,” March 2, 2020). This article distinguishes real harm from honest criticism, such as asking a group to name itself or comparing its teaching with Scripture; How Shincheonji Responds to Criticism and Persecution goes deeper.
Sources
SCJ’s own books and statements (primary).
Printed page numbers.
- Lee Man-hee, The Creation of Heaven and Earth, English 2nd ed. (2014), pp. 188–189, 302, 352, 355.
- Shincheonji Church of Jesus, “Letter of Appeal from Shincheonji Church of Jesus in Regards to COVID-19,” EIN Presswire, March 2, 2020. https://www.einpresswire.com/article/510959113/letter-of-appeal-from-shincheonji-church-of-jesus-in-regards-to-covid-19
Government (kept: named official findings).
- Ministry of Home Affairs, Singapore, “Investigations into Shincheonji Church of Jesus the Temple of the Tabernacle of the Testimony in Singapore,” Feb 28, 2020. https://www.mha.gov.sg/media-room/newsroom/investigations-into-shincheonji-church-of-jesus-the-temple-of-the-tabernacle-of-the-testimony-in-singapore/
Named ex-member and press (kept for SCJ’s own reply and named testimony; no primary or BVC page has these quotes).
- Holly Bancroft, The Independent, Aug 9, 2022 (UK student; SCJ’s reply on internet use; Laurie, former head instructor in Namibia). https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/new-heaven-new-earth-lee-man-hee-cult-sect-b2119061.html
Bible Vaccine Center.
How to leave · Rebuilding your life after leaving · Welcoming former members.
Ex-member testimony.
Expulsion and shunning of long-serving leaders, per former members’ accounts to BVC (no public case cited).
Scripture quotations are from the NET Bible®, https://netbible.com, copyright ©1996, 2019 by Biblical Studies Press, L.L.C. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
