Part 6 · article 55 of 70
If Jesus is God, why did he have human limits?
Short answer
If Jesus is God, why was he weary, unaware of the day, tempted and forsaken? Each argument is stated, then answered from the NET Bible.
Each passage below is in its own section. You can open one section at a time. The argument is stated as a potential argument from SCJ, labeled as not quoted from an SCJ book or lesson, and then a reply is given with the Bible text quoted from the NET.
Overview and every objection by verse: What does Shincheonji teach about Jesus and God?
On this page (8 sections)
- Short answer
- If Jesus is God, why was he tired, thirsty and made lower than the angels?
- If Jesus is God, why didn’t he know the day or the hour? Matthew 24:36
- If Jesus is God, how can he be tempted? James 1:13 and Matthew 26:39
- If Jesus is God, why was he forsaken? Matthew 27:46 and can God die?
- Where to go next
- Frequently asked questions
- Sources
Tired, thirsty and the day and the hour
If Jesus is God, why was he tired, thirsty and made lower than the angels?
Short answer
John 4:6 does not disprove Jesus’ deity because Scripture often uses human language about God without denying his divine nature, such as God “resting” on the seventh day in Genesis 2:2 or God being “afflicted” with his people in Isaiah 63:9. The Bible repeatedly affirms that the Son took on a real human nature in the incarnation, which means his humanity could experience physical weariness while his divine nature remained unchanged.
John 4:6
Here’s a potential argument from SCJ (not quoted from an SCJ book or lesson):
John 4:6 proves Jesus is not God because it explicitly says he became weary, and since an all-powerful, omnipotent God cannot grow tired or experience physical weakness, this verse shows Jesus was merely a human being, not deity.
Counter
John 4:6 does not disprove Jesus’ deity because Scripture often uses human language about God without denying his divine nature, such as God “resting” on the seventh day in Genesis 2:2 or God being “afflicted” with his people in Isaiah 63:9. The Bible repeatedly affirms that the Son took on a real human nature in the incarnation, which means his humanity could experience physical weariness while his divine nature remained unchanged. Jesus’ tiredness is a mark of true humanity, yet the same chapter shows him exercising divine knowledge of the Samaritan woman’s life and offering eternal life itself, which no mere man can do. The Gospels regularly present this pattern of genuine human weakness followed by divine authority in order to reveal that the Word who became flesh is both fully God and fully man, so his weariness is a sign of the incarnation, not a denial of his deity.
John 19:28
Here’s a potential argument from SCJ (not quoted from an SCJ book or lesson):
John 19:28 proves Jesus is not God because he expresses thirst on the cross, and a divine being who is omnipotent and self-sufficient would never experience such basic human weakness.
Counter
This objection collapses once the doctrine of the incarnation and the purpose of John 19:28 are understood, because Jesus’ thirst does not deny his deity but affirms that the eternal Word truly took on human flesh in order to suffer for our salvation. John explicitly tells us that Jesus said “I am thirsty” to fulfill Scripture, referring to Psalm 22:15 and Psalm 69:21 where the suffering figure speaks with language reserved for the righteous sufferer upheld by God. The New Testament repeatedly teaches that the Son took on a real human nature with real bodily limitations (John 1:14, Philippians 2:7–8, Hebrews 2:14–17), which means hunger, fatigue, pain, and thirst are not evidence of lacking deity but proof that the divine Son entered into the full experience of humanity. God appearing in human weakness is not foreign to the Old Testament; Yahweh appears in human form in Genesis 18 and eats with Abraham, and the Angel of the Lord speaks as God yet interacts physically with creation. Jesus’ thirst on the cross reveals not a denial of his divine nature but the depth of his incarnation, since the same Gospel that records “I am thirsty” also calls him the Creator through whom all things were made (John 1:3), the one who gives living water (John 4:14), and the one who declares himself “I AM” (John 8:58). The one who thirsts in his humanity is the same one who satisfies spiritual thirst as God.
A second angle is that Scripture shows God repeatedly experiences and expresses human-like emotions, sensations, and responses in order to reveal his character, without this ever denying his deity. The Old Testament openly describes Yahweh as “tired of carrying” Israel’s sins (Isaiah 1:14) and “highly offended” (Genesis 6:6), and portrays him using physical language such as stretching out his arm, smelling sacrifices, or walking in the garden (Genesis 3:8), none of which undermines his divine nature but communicates in ways humans can understand. John 19:28 specifically says Jesus expressed thirst “in order to fulfill the scripture” (NET) which means the statement is tied to his role as the righteous sufferer in Psalm 22 and Psalm 69, not to any limitation in his divine identity. The Old Testament repeatedly personifies God in ways that communicate suffering and passion, such as God saying “Ephraim has surrounded me with lies” (NET) in Hosea 11:12 or “you burdened me with your sins” (NET) in Isaiah 43:24. This biblical pattern shows that expressing human-like conditions does not contradict divine status; rather, it is a standard way Scripture reveals God’s involvement with his people. Jesus’ thirst fits this established scriptural pattern of God revealing himself through human-expressed language to accomplish his redemptive purpose.
Hebrews 5:8 and learning obedience
Here’s a potential argument from SCJ (not quoted from an SCJ book or lesson):
Hebrews 5:8 proves Jesus is not God because it says he “learned obedience,” and a truly divine, omniscient being cannot learn anything or grow in moral submission, which shows Jesus must be a created, subordinate being.
Counter
And notice the context. Hebrews 5 is not demoting Jesus. It is exalting him as the perfect high priest who represents humanity precisely because he experienced real human life. This is the same book that begins by calling Jesus “the radiance of his glory” (NET) and “the representation of his essence” (Hebrews 1:3, NET) and that has the Father calling the Son “God” (Hebrews 1:8). If you want to pretend Hebrews 5:8 makes Jesus a creature, then you must explain how a creature can be the exact imprint of God’s very nature and how a creature can be addressed as God by the Father.
Now let us look at the philosophical side, since you asked. Classical theism has never taught that God “learns” because learning implies moving from ignorance to knowledge, which cannot apply to an all-knowing being. So the Son, according to his divine nature, does not learn. His human nature does. Philosophers distinguish between “essential properties” and “accidental properties.” Essential properties are those that belong to a being’s very nature, like omniscience for God. Accidental properties are those a being can take on without changing its essence. The Son taking on human limitations does not change his divine essence. It simply means that as man he participates in all the experiences proper to man, including growth and experiential learning.
Hebrews 5:8 is about Jesus learning obedience as the Last Adam who succeeds where the first Adam failed. His human nature learns obedience through suffering so that he can be the perfect, sinless representative of humanity. None of this touches his divine nature. None of this implies ignorance in God. It simply shows that the Son experienced the fullness of genuine humanity. And if Unitarians kept reading, they would discover that the entire book of Hebrews destroys their position by teaching Christ’s divine nature, eternal priesthood, cosmic creative power, and perfect equality with the Father. “Learning obedience” is about his humanity. His deity remains fully intact and eternally omniscient.
Hebrews 2:9 Jesus being made lower than the angels
Here’s a potential argument from SCJ (not quoted from an SCJ book or lesson):
Hebrews 2:9 proves Jesus cannot be God because it says he was “made lower than the angels” (NET), and no true deity can ever be lower in status, rank, or nature than created angelic beings, which means Jesus must be a subordinate creature rather than the eternal God.
Counter
Hebrews 2:9 does not deny Jesus’ deity because the verse explicitly says he was made lower than the angels “because he suffered death,” which is necessary for his mission in Hebrews 2:14–18, where he shares “flesh and blood” and becomes like his brothers “in every respect.” This temporary lowering refers to his human condition, not his divine nature, and it must be read together with Hebrews 1:2–3, 6, 8, and 10, where the same author already stated that Jesus created the world, sustains all things, receives worship from angels, and is called God by the Father. Hebrews 2:9 also cannot mean Jesus is a created being because Hebrews 1 has already established that the Son is superior to angels, receives their worship, and is identified as the Creator and as God himself in Hebrews 1:3, 1:6, 1:8, and 1:10. The author’s design is to place Hebrews 1, which presents the Son exalted above angels in his divine nature, beside Hebrews 2, which shows the Son made lower than angels in his human nature for suffering and death, in order to teach that the same divine Son truly became human. This deliberate literary contrast shows both natures of Christ united in one person, not a downgrade from deity to creature.
We can also see the God of the Old Testament entering creation –
- In Genesis 11:5, God “comes down” to see the tower, which shows him describing his own action in human terms as he steps into human space.
- In Exodus 3:7–8, God says he has “come down to deliver them” (NET) Israel, revealing his choice to enter history without diminishing his deity.
- In Genesis 32:24–30, God wrestles with Jacob as a man, demonstrating that he can adopt a human form without ceasing to be God.
- In Genesis 18:1–2, the Lord appears to Abraham as a man, showing that God can manifest himself in human likeness before the incarnation.
- In Exodus 33:20–23, God shields Moses from his full glory, illustrating that God can limit the visibility of his presence for human survival.
- In Exodus 32:14, God is described as “relenting,” which reflects divine accommodation to human understanding while he remains unchanging in his essence.
- In Deuteronomy 1:31, God depicts himself as carrying Israel like a father carries his son, revealing divine condescension expressed through human imagery.
Numbers 23:19 vs. Jesus becoming a man.
Here’s a potential argument from SCJ (not quoted from an SCJ book or lesson):
Numbers 23:19 teaches that God is “not a man” nor “a son of man,” which means God cannot become human, so the very idea that Jesus is God made flesh contradicts God’s own declaration that he is categorically not a man and therefore Jesus cannot be God.
Counter
This is where we need to read the context.
Numbers 23:19 (NET): God is not a man, that he should lie, nor a human being, that he should change his mind. Has he said, and will he not do it? Or has he spoken, and will he not make it happen?
Numbers 23:19 is not saying God cannot ever take on human flesh, but that God is not like man in the sense that he lies, changes his mind, or fails to keep his word. The context is about God’s unchanging truthfulness and faithfulness, not about his inability to enter creation or assume a human nature. The verse contrasts God’s perfect reliability with human frailty and inconsistency, so it does not forbid the incarnation but denies that God behaves like sinful, unstable human beings.
Source of the Greek, Hebrew, manuscript and historical claims in this article: the author’s own research.
If Jesus is God, why didn’t he know the day or the hour? Matthew 24:36
Short answer
In Matthew 24:36 Jesus says “no one knows [oiden]” the day or the hour. The verb oida in Greek often refers not to a lack of capacity to know, but to a lack of disclosure, a knowledge not revealed or not communicated for a purpose.
If Jesus is God, why didn’t he know the day or the hour? (Mark 13:32, Matthew 24:36) (how did Jesus “grow” in wisdom?)
Objection:
If Jesus is God, how can he be omniscient yet not know the day or the hour?
The common argument against Jesus’ deity follows this logic:
- God is omniscient.
- Jesus is not omniscient.
- Therefore, Jesus is not God.
However, this objection misunderstands the nature of Christ’s incarnation and the meaning of the Greek word “oida” (οἶδα) used in Mark 13:32 and Matthew 24:36.
1. The Greek word “oida” can mean “declare”
The word “oida” (οἶδα), translated as “know,” can also mean “declare” or “make known.”
Paul uses “oida” in 1 Corinthians 2:2:
“For I decided to be concerned about nothing among you except Jesus Christ, and him crucified” (NET). The Greek verb is oida, “know.”
Paul obviously knew more than Christ crucified, but he chose only to declare that message.
Thus, an alternative translation of Jesus’ words in Mark 13:32 and Matthew 24:36 could be:
“But concerning that day or that hour, no one declares it, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, but only the Father.” (author’s own rendering)
This aligns with the immediate context—the disciples were asking Jesus to reveal the day and hour. Jesus, in his role as a servant, made it known that it was the Father’s prerogative to declare it.
2. Jesus did exercise omniscience
The Bible overwhelmingly affirms that Jesus is omniscient, even in his humanity:
In the Gospels:
- John 16:30 – “Now we know that you know everything” (NET)
John 2:24-25 – “he knew all people … he knew what was in man” (NET)
Mark 2:8 – “immediately, when Jesus realized in his spirit that they were contemplating such thoughts” (NET)
- Luke 6:8 – “he knew their thoughts”
- Matthew 12:25 – “Jesus realized what they were thinking” (NET)
In the Epistles:
- Colossians 2:2-3 – “Christ, in whom are hidden all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge” (NET).
- 1 Corinthians 1:24 – “Christ is the power of God and the wisdom of God” (NET)
- Revelation 2:23 – “I am the one who searches minds and hearts” (NET)
If Jesus is omniscient in these passages, it is inconsistent to assume he literally did not know the day or the hour. Rather, he chose not to reveal it in accordance with his role.
3. The incarnation: Jesus voluntarily restricted certain divine privileges
Philippians 2:5-7 explains that in the incarnation, Jesus voluntarily humbled himself and did not fully exercise all divine attributes:
- Jesus remained fully God (Colossians 2:9),
- But he chose not to exercise all his divine privileges.
Just as Jesus grew in wisdom (Luke 2:52) in his humanity, he also chose to limit his knowledge at times.
4. Now why would Jesus do this and limit himself? And are there other examples in the Bible?
Jesus voluntarily limited himself during his incarnation to fulfill his role as the Messiah—the perfect mediator between God and humanity.
He did so to take on human weaknesses and to identify with us.
Hebrews 4:15 – “For we do not have a high priest incapable of sympathizing with our weaknesses, but one who has been tempted in every way just as we are, yet without sin” (NET).
We can also see God in the Old Testament limit himself in order to interact with his creation, as seen with Moses.
Exodus 33:20-23 – “You cannot see my face, for no one can see me and live … I will put you in a cleft in the rock and will cover you with my hand while I pass by” (NET)
- This parallels how Jesus, in his incarnation, veiled his full divine power so that humanity could interact with him without being overwhelmed.
Matthew 24:36, Mark 13:32: Jesus says “the Father alone” knows certain things (Matthew 24:36).
Here’s a potential argument from SCJ (not quoted from an SCJ book or lesson):
When Jesus says in Matthew 24:36 that only the Father knows the day and hour, it shows that Jesus lacks divine omniscience and therefore cannot be truly God, since a being who does not know everything cannot share the same nature as the all-knowing Father.
Counter
The Greek verb “oida” does not always refer to absolute ignorance
In Matthew 24:36 Jesus says “no one knows [oiden]” the day or the hour. The verb oida in Greek often refers not to a lack of capacity to know, but to a lack of disclosure, a knowledge not revealed or not communicated for a purpose. For example, in John 21:17 Peter says to Jesus, “You know [oidas] everything,” and the same verb describes Jesus’ divine omniscience. The verb is flexible. It can mean “to know,” “to understand,” “to be aware,” or “to make known.”
Paul uses “oida” to mean “not revealing” rather than literal ignorance
In 1 Corinthians 2:2 Paul says “I decided to be concerned about nothing among you except Jesus Christ, and him crucified” (NET). The Greek verb is oida, “know.” Paul obviously did not lose all other knowledge. He means he chose not to disclose or focus on anything else. This directly parallels how oida can operate in Matthew 24:36. Jesus is not saying, “I am incapable of knowing,” but rather that this knowledge is not being revealed within the scope of his incarnational mission.
The Old Testament frequently uses “not knowing” as a figure of speech for “not disclosing”
A. Genesis 22:12
God says to Abraham, “Now I know that you fear God” (NET), but God already knows all things (1 Samuel 16:7). This is experiential revelation, not new information.
B. Deuteronomy 8:2
God says he tested Israel so that he might “know” what was in their heart. Again, the omniscient God does not gain information. He reveals it through events.
C. Psalm 73:11
The wicked say, “How does God know?” which mocks the idea of God being unaware, clearly not literal.
Thus, “knowing” or “not knowing” is commonly used in Scripture as covenantal or revelatory language, not literal ignorance.
Unitarian logic collapses when confronted with Revelation 19:12
Revelation 19:12 says:
“He has a name written that no one knows except himself” (NET).
If Unitarians insist that “not knowing” implies creaturely ignorance, then they must conclude:
- Jesus has knowledge that no one else has, not even the Father.
- Jesus is omniscient in a way that excludes every other being.
This destroys their argument, because by their own standard:
- If Matthew 24:36 proves Jesus is not God, then Revelation 19:12 proves Jesus is greater than God.
Obviously both conclusions are absurd.
The only consistent interpretation is this:
- In Matthew 24:36 Jesus is not incapable of knowing.
- In Revelation 19:12 Jesus possesses knowledge that is withheld or not disclosed.
Both passages use “knowing” in the sense of revelation, not essence.
Luke 2:52
Here’s a potential argument from SCJ (not quoted from an SCJ book or lesson):
Luke 2:52 proves Jesus is not God because it says he grew in wisdom, which a true omniscient deity cannot do, showing that Jesus possessed only human limitations and therefore cannot be God.
Counter
Only someone who does not understand the incarnation would think Luke 2:52 disproves Jesus’ deity. Of course Jesus grew in wisdom because that is the whole point of God becoming man. In taking on flesh, he chose to enter into our human experience so completely that he shared our weaknesses, pains, and struggles. Scripture says God himself is “Through all that they suffered, he suffered too” (Isaiah 63:9, NET) and that he “he knows what we are made of” (NET) and “he realizes we are made of clay” (Psalm 103:13–14, NET). The incarnation is the fullest expression of this divine compassion, because the eternal Son truly became one of us so he could feel what we feel, suffer as we suffer, and redeem us from within our own nature. When he took on a real human mind, he accepted everything that belongs to genuine humanity, including growth and development. If Jesus did not grow in wisdom, he would not be truly human and Luke would be denying the incarnation. Yet the same Jesus who grew in wisdom is the one who amazed the teachers in the temple at age twelve (Luke 2:46–47), who knew people’s thoughts (Mark 2:8), who knew the future (John 13:19 and 16:30), and who claimed eternal preexistence when he said “before Abraham came into existence, I am” (John 8:58, NET). Jesus grows in wisdom according to his humanity, and he reveals divine wisdom according to his deity, which is exactly what the incarnation teaches and it completely answers the Unitarian misuse of Luke 2:52.
Source of the Greek, Hebrew, manuscript and historical claims in this article: the author’s own research.
Tempted and forsaken
If Jesus is God, how can he be tempted? James 1:13 and Matthew 26:39
Short answer
The Greek verb peirazō can mean “to tempt” or “to test” depending entirely on the context in which it appears. This means the New Testament uses the same word family for both morally neutral testing and morally evil tempting, so James 1:13 and Matthew 4:1 are not automatically describing the same kind of experience.
If Jesus is God, how can God be tempted?
A common objection (not quoted from an SCJ book or lesson): James 1:13 says that God cannot be tempted with evil. But if Jesus is God, why was he tempted in Matthew 4:1-11?
- James 1:13 vs. Jesus’ Temptation—No Contradiction
James 1:13 states:
“Let no one say when he is tempted, ‘I am tempted by God,’ for God cannot be tempted by evil, and he himself tempts no one” (NET).
But notice what James actually says:
- “God cannot be tempted by evil” (NET).
The verse does not say God cannot be tempted in any way. Instead, it clarifies that God has no internal sinful desires that could be tempted by evil.
Jesus had no sinful nature, so his temptation was external—Satan tempted him from the outside just like he tempted Adam and Eve.
- Did God “Experience” Temptation?
The word “tempted” (πειράζω – peirazō) in Matthew 4:1 can mean:
- To entice toward sin (which cannot happen to God),
- To test or prove (which is what happened to Jesus).
Jesus was not tempted internally (because he had no sin), but he was tested externally as part of his mission to defeat Satan as the second Adam (1 Corinthians 15:45).
We can also see God being “tempted” in the Old Testament also:
- Numbers 14:22 – “For all the people have seen my glory and my signs that I did in Egypt and in the wilderness, and yet have tempted me now these ten times, and have not obeyed me” (NET)
God says that the Israelites had tempted him 10 times by constantly doubting his faithfulness. They tested him by refusing to trust in his promises, despite seeing miracles.
- 1 Samuel 8:7-9 – “The Lord said to Samuel, ‘Do everything the people request of you. For it is not you that they have rejected, but it is me that they have rejected as their king … But you must warn them and make them aware of the policies of the king who will rule over them” (NET)
The Israelites “tested” God by rejecting his kingship and demanding a human king instead. They doubted his rule and put him on trial, just as Jesus was later put on trial before men.
- In Exodus 17:2 – “So the people contended with Moses, and they said, ‘Give us water to drink!’ Moses said to them, ‘Why do you contend with me? Why do you test the Lord?’” (NET)
Here, Israel tempted (tested) God by questioning his ability to provide for them.
This is the same Greek word (peirazō) used in Matthew 4:1, where Jesus was “tempted.”
The Israelites challenged God’s provision, just as Satan challenged Jesus’ provision in the wilderness by saying, “command these stones to become bread” (Matthew 4:3, NET).
- Psalm 95:8-9 – “Do not be stubborn like they were at Meribah, like they were that day at Massah in the wilderness, where your ancestors challenged my authority and tried my patience” (NET)
- Israel tested God at Massah and Meribah by demanding water instead of trusting him.
God was not tempted to sin, but he was tested and provoked by their doubt and complaints.
- Psalm 78:41 – “They again challenged God and offended the Holy One of Israel” (NET).
- The Israelites tested God’s patience and power through their repeated rebellion and lack of faith.
- This was not a temptation to sin, but rather a provocation and a demand for proof of his faithfulness.
And there are more examples throughout the Old Testament.
James 1:13 and Matthew 4:1 – God cannot be tempted
Here’s a potential argument from SCJ (not quoted from an SCJ book or lesson):
James 1:13 says God cannot be tempted, yet Matthew 4:1 says Jesus was tempted by the devil, so Jesus cannot be God because a being who is genuinely susceptible to temptation cannot be the same God who is immune to it.
Counter
“Tested” and “tempted” come from the same Greek word
The Greek verb peirazō can mean “to tempt” or “to test” depending entirely on the context in which it appears. This means the New Testament uses the same word family for both morally neutral testing and morally evil tempting, so James 1:13 and Matthew 4:1 are not automatically describing the same kind of experience.
The Old Testament says Israel “tempted” or “tested” God
Several passages say Israel “tested” or “tempted” God, such as Exodus 17:2, Psalm 78:18, and Psalm 95:9. These texts show that God can be the object of attempted temptation or testing without implying that he internally feels temptation toward evil.
The philosophical explanation for how Jesus can be tempted
Temptation has two aspects, an external presentation and an internal susceptibility, and only the second one implies moral weakness. Jesus experienced real external temptation in his human nature, but he had no internal inclination to sin because his divine nature and sinless human nature made him incapable of desiring evil.
If Jesus is God, then why did he have a different will from God? (Matthew 26:39)
There are a few key points to consider:
- Jesus prayed to the Father
To pray historically means “to ask” or communicate. When Jesus prays, he engages in communication with the Father. This is not a problem for trinitarians who believe the persons of the trinity can communicate with one another. Historic meaning of “Pray”
Notice the vast difference between our prayers and Jesus prayers, for us to pray to the Father we need to go through Jesus, we can’t communicate with the Father unless we communicate through the son (1 Timothy 2:5, John 16:23–24), Jesus however needs no mediator, he has direct unlimited communication to the Father because he’s from the Father(John 16:28) and has always existed with the Father (John 1:1, John 17:5).
- Jesus having a different will from the Father?
Jesus experienced fear; and yet despite his fear, he still submitted to the will of the Father.
In Matthew 26:39, we see Jesus expressing anguish before his crucifixion:
“My Father, if possible, let this cup pass from me! Yet not what I will, but what you will” (NET).
What does this show? That Jesus, in his humanity, experienced the natural fear of suffering and death.
- Luke 22:44 – “And in his anguish he prayed more earnestly, and his sweat was like drops of blood falling to the ground” (NET).
- This is a real human reaction to intense suffering.
Yet, what did Jesus do? He still submitted to the Father’s will.
- This objection contradicts Shincheonji’s own teachings about Jesus
John 10:30 – “The Father and I are one” (NET).
SCJ itself teaches that Jesus’ will was always in perfect alignment with the Father, so if they claim Jesus had a separate, opposing will, they contradict their own teaching.
Jesus’ will was always aligned with the Father’s, as seen in John 5:19:
“the Son can do nothing on his own initiative, but only what he sees the Father doing. For whatever the Father does, the Son does likewise” (NET)
Does this sound like Jesus has an opposing will? Absolutely not!
So when Jesus says “not my will, but yours be done” (NET), he is not saying he has a separate, conflicting will—He is saying that his mission is to fully submit to the Father’s will, which he has already declared to be one with.
If SCJ claims that Jesus’ will was always aligned with the Father (John 10:30), then they contradict their own interpretation when using Matthew 26:39 to argue that Jesus had a “different will.”
So, which one is it?
- If they affirm John 10:30 and John 5:19, then Matthew 26:39 cannot be used against Jesus’ deity.
- If they deny John 10:30, then they contradict their own doctrine.
Matthew 26:39: Jesus submits his will to the Father.
Here’s a potential argument from SCJ (not quoted from an SCJ book or lesson):
Matthew 26:39 proves Jesus is not God because he clearly expresses a will that differs from the Father’s and then submits to a higher divine will, which would be impossible if he were truly equal with the Father or shared the same divine nature.
Counter
Matthew 26:39 does not deny the deity of Christ because it simply shows that Jesus possesses a genuine human will that is perfectly aligned with the Father’s divine will, which is exactly what the incarnation requires. If Jesus were not perfectly aligned with the Father, that would directly contradict Shincheonji’s own interpretation of John 10:30 where they insist the Father and the Son are “one” in purpose, which means his submission actually supports, rather than contradicts, their own theological claims.
Jesus’ expression of fear in Gethsemane does not indicate inequality but reveals his true humanity, because a real human nature feels real dread in the face of suffering. This is why Luke records that Jesus was sweating blood, since he fully knew the torment and wrath he was about to endure for the salvation of the world. Instead of disproving his deity, Matthew 26:39 demonstrates the unity of the divine will and the human will within the one person of Christ, a unity that SCJ’s theology cannot properly account for.
Luke 22:42: “Not my will but yours be done” (NET).
Here’s a potential argument from SCJ (not quoted from an SCJ book or lesson):
When Jesus says, “Not My will but Yours be done” (NET), it shows his will is different from the Father’s will, proving he cannot be God but is a subordinate being whose nature and desires are inferior to the Father.
Counter
This objection collapses when Luke 22 is read carefully, because Jesus is not revealing a fallen or inferior will but a genuine human will submitted perfectly to the divine will as part of the incarnation. The entire point of the passage is that the eternal Son has taken on a real human nature with real human desires, including a natural human aversion to suffering and death, yet he brings that human will into perfect obedience to the Father, demonstrating sinless submission rather than ontological inferiority. The New Testament repeatedly affirms that Jesus possesses a divine will in unity with the Father, as Jesus says in John 10:30 that he and the Father are one, in John 5:19 that he only does what the Father does, and in John 4:34 that his food is to do the Father’s will, all of which show perfect will alignment, not conflict. The prayer in Gethsemane displays the mystery of the incarnation described in Philippians 2:6–8, where Jesus, who is in the form of God, humbles himself and becomes obedient as a man. Far from disproving deity, Luke 22:42 affirms the orthodox truth that the one divine Son operates through two natures with two wills, a human will and a divine will, and that his perfect obedience secures our salvation (Hebrews 5:8–9). The unity of will is seen even within the prayer itself, because Jesus freely submits, proving that his will is morally and essentially one with the Father’s and fully consistent with the confession that he is God in the flesh.
Also, this contradicts Shincheonji’s theology if Jesus isn’t perfectly aligned with the Father.
Source of the Greek, Hebrew, manuscript and historical claims in this article: the author’s own research.
If Jesus is God, why was he forsaken? Matthew 27:46 and can God die?
Short answer
In Matthew 27:46, Jesus addresses the Father as “God,” but this does not mean he is denying his own divinity. The psalm ends in triumph, declaring that God did NOT actually forsake his servant.
If Jesus is God, why did Jesus ask God why God forsook him and then right after that gave up his own spirit (Mt 27:46, 50)
A common objection (not quoted from an SCJ book or lesson): If Jesus is truly God, why did he cry out to God, asking why he was forsaken? Doesn’t this prove that Jesus is separate from God and not divine?
This misunderstands both:
- What Jesus was actually saying (quoting Psalm 22)
- The meaning of the word “God” in the New Testament when referring to different persons of the Godhead.
1. The meaning of “God” in the New Testament
The title “God” in the New Testament can refer to:
- The Father (John 17:3).
- The Son (Hebrews 1:8, John 1:1).
- The Holy Spirit (Acts 5:3-4).
In Matthew 27:46, Jesus addresses the Father as “God,” but this does not mean he is denying his own divinity.
Jesus is often called “God” in Scripture (John 1:1, John 20:28, Titus 2:13, Hebrews 1:8), so distinguishing the Father as “God” does not mean Jesus isn’t God.
2. Jesus was quoting a messianic prophecy (Psalm 22)
When Jesus cried out “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?” (NET), he was quoting Psalm 22:1—a prophetic psalm about the suffering of the Messiah.
Psalm 22:1-2 – “My God, my God, why have you abandoned me? I groan in prayer, but help seems far away” (NET).
- This does not mean the psalmist was actually abandoned by God.
- Instead, it expresses deep suffering—which later results in vindication (Psalm 22:24).
When Jews heard Jesus quote Psalm 22:1, they would instantly recognize he was invoking the entire psalm, not just making a statement of despair.
3. Psalm 22 perfectly describes Jesus’ crucifixion
Psalm 22 prophetically describes the crucifixion hundreds of years before it happened:
Psalm 22:16-18
“Yes, wild dogs surround me— a gang of evil men crowd around me; like a lion they pin my hands and feet. I can count all my bones; my enemies are gloating over me in triumph. They are dividing up my clothes among themselves; they are rolling dice for my garment” (NET)
- “like a lion they pin my hands and feet” (NET) – Jesus was crucified.
- “my enemies are gloating over me in triumph” (NET) – The crowd mocked him.
- “They are dividing up my clothes among themselves; they are rolling dice for my garments” (NET). – Roman soldiers did exactly this (John 19:23-24).
4. The triumph of Psalm 22: Jesus was not truly forsaken
Those who argue that Jesus was actually abandoned by God ignore the ending of Psalm 22:
Psalm 22:24 – “For he did not despise or detest the suffering of the oppressed. He did not ignore him; when he cried out to him, he responded” (NET).
The psalm ends in triumph, declaring that God did NOT actually forsake his servant.
So, when Jesus quoted this, he was:
- Fulfilling prophecy.
- Declaring his suffering.
- Pointing to his coming victory.
5. If Jesus was truly forsaken, his will would be different from the Father’s
SCJ insists that Jesus and the Father have perfect unity in will, purpose, and action.
John 5:19 – “the Son can do nothing on his own initiative, but only what he sees the Father doing. For whatever the Father does, the Son does likewise” (NET)
John 6:38 – “For I have come down from heaven not to do my own will but the will of the one who sent me” (NET).
If Jesus was actually forsaken, this means that at some point, the Father and the Son had a different will—the Father rejecting Jesus, and Jesus seeking the Father.
This contradicts SCJ’s own doctrine that Jesus was in perfect unity with the Father at all times.
Would SCJ claim that Jesus ceased to be one with the Father when he cried, “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?” (NET)?
If so, then SCJ would be admitting that Jesus and the Father were divided—which contradicts John 10:30, John 5:19, and John 6:38.
6. If Jesus was truly forsaken, he would have been cut off from God’s Spirit
SCJ teaches that:
- Only those who remain in God’s Word and will receive the Spirit.
- Those who depart from God’s truth are cut off from him.
John 14:10 – “The words that I say to you, I do not speak on my own initiative, but the Father residing in me performs his miraculous deeds” (NET).
If Jesus was truly forsaken, that means the Father left him, and his Spirit departed from Jesus.
- This would mean that Jesus was no longer the Messiah during that moment.
- This would mean Jesus lost his authority.
- This would mean Jesus was no longer God’s instrument.
This is one of many examples of SCJ shooting themselves in the foot theologically in an attempt to disprove the Deity of Christ.
If Jesus is God, how can God die?
A common objection (not quoted from an SCJ book or lesson):
If Jesus is truly God, how can God die? Doesn’t the Bible say that God is immortal (1 Timothy 6:16)?
This objection completely misunderstands both:
- What death actually means in the Bible
- What it means for Jesus to be both God and man
Now let me break it down step by step so there’s no confusion.
1. Death in the Bible means separation, not annihilation
When people ask how God can die, they assume death means ceasing to exist. That is NOT what death means in the Bible.
James 2:26 – “For just as the body without the spirit is dead, so also faith without works is dead” (NET).
Death is the separation of the spirit from the body, NOT the end of existence.
Let me ask you this: When you die, do you cease to exist? Of course not! Your body dies, but your soul continues to live.
So when Jesus “died,” his divine nature didn’t die—only his human body experienced death.
2. God took on flesh so he could experience death
Hebrews 2:14 – “since the children share in flesh and blood, he likewise shared in their humanity, so that through death he could destroy the one who holds the power of death (that is, the devil)” (NET)
God cannot die in his divine nature because he is eternal (1 Timothy 6:16). But God CAN take on human nature, which can die. This is why Jesus became flesh—so that he could experience death on our behalf. If Jesus were ONLY God and NOT also a man, then he could NOT die for our sins.
3. Jesus’ death and resurrection prove he is God!
If someone argues that God can’t die, so Jesus isn’t God, ask them this:
Then how did Jesus raise himself from the dead?
John 10:17-18 – “I lay down my life, so that I may take it back again” (NET)
Jesus chose to lay down his life. Jesus chose to take it up again. If Jesus were just a man, how could he have the authority to raise himself from the dead?
Only God has power over life and death—and Jesus has that power!
4. The Bible says “God” died
Acts 20:28 – “to shepherd the church of God that he obtained with the blood of his own Son” (NET)
Who purchased the church? God. With whose blood? God’s blood.
Wait… but doesn’t God not have blood?
God took on flesh in Jesus Christ—so through Jesus, God shed his own blood for us.
1 Corinthians 2:8 – “None of the rulers of this age understood it. If they had known it, they would not have crucified the Lord of glory” (NET)
Who was crucified? The Lord of Glory—a title used for Yahweh in the Old Testament!
So according to the Bible, God did die—through the human nature of Jesus.
5. If Jesus was just a man, his death would be useless
Psalm 49:7-8 – “Certainly a man cannot rescue his brother; he cannot pay God an adequate ransom price” (NET)
If Jesus was just a man, his death would only pay for himself. But because Jesus is God, his death has infinite value—paying for the sins of the world!
If you say God can’t die, then you are left with an even bigger problem: Only a perfect sacrifice can atone for sin—so if Jesus wasn’t God, how could his death save anyone?
6. The Old Testament proves that God can die in human form
Some might still object that nowhere in the Old Testament does it say God will die:
Zechariah 12:10 – “they will look to me, the one they have pierced. They will lament for him as one laments for an only son” (NET)
Who is speaking? Yahweh. Who was pierced? Jesus.
God himself is saying HE will be pierced! This is a prophecy of Jesus’ crucifixion, proving that God can die in human flesh.
Isaiah 53: Jesus is God’s suffering servant, not God himself.
Here’s a potential argument from SCJ (not quoted from an SCJ book or lesson):
Isaiah 53 portrays the Messiah as God’s suffering servant who is wounded, rejected, pierced, and killed, which proves he is not God but a human servant submitted to God’s will.
Counter
This objection collapses once Isaiah 53 is read in the context of Isaiah’s entire Servant theology, because the Servant is not depicted as a mere human but as the unique Redeemer who accomplishes Yahweh’s own salvation and bears divine titles and functions. Isaiah 53:10 says it is Yahweh’s will to crush the Servant, yet Isaiah 53:11–12 says the Servant justifies many, bears their iniquities, intercedes for transgressors, and divides the spoil with the strong, all of which are divine prerogatives (Isaiah 45:24–25; Exodus 34:6–7). Earlier Servant Songs identify this Servant as the one who brings justice to the nations (Isaiah 42:1–4), restores Israel (Isaiah 49:5–6), and becomes a light to the Gentiles so that God’s salvation reaches the ends of the earth (Isaiah 49:6), which are tasks assigned to Yahweh alone in Isaiah 40–55. The same Servant is called “My salvation” in Isaiah 49:6 and is the Redeemer who accomplishes the new and everlasting covenant of Isaiah 55:3. The suffering in Isaiah 53 does not deny deity but reveals the incarnation, because the divine Messiah must take on flesh to bear sins on behalf of humanity. The New Testament confirms this interpretation: Jesus says Isaiah saw his glory in John 12:41, applying Isaiah’s vision of Yahweh directly to himself, and the apostles universally apply Isaiah 53 to Christ as the divine Redeemer who gives his life as a ransom for many. Isaiah 53 presents the divine Servant who becomes human to suffer and save, not a creature separate from God.
Source of the Greek, Hebrew, manuscript and historical claims in this article: the author’s own research.
Where to go next
Frequently asked questions
Does Jesus being tired in John 4:6 mean he is not God?
The Bible repeatedly affirms that the Son took on a real human nature in the incarnation, which means his humanity could experience physical weariness while his divine nature remained unchanged. Jesus’ tiredness is a mark of true humanity, yet the same chapter shows him exercising divine knowledge of the Samaritan woman’s life and offering eternal life itself, which no mere man can do.
Does Matthew 24:36 mean Jesus is not God?
Jesus voluntarily limited himself during his incarnation to fulfill his role as the Messiah—the perfect mediator between God and humanity.
What does the Greek verb oida mean in Matthew 24:36?
The word “oida” (οἶδα), translated as “know,” can also mean “declare” or “make known.”
Does the Greek verb peirazō always mean “tempt”?
The Greek verb peirazō can mean “to tempt” or “to test” depending entirely on the context in which it appears.
Why did Jesus say “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?”
When Jesus cried out “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?” (NET), he was quoting Psalm 22:1—a prophetic psalm about the suffering of the Messiah.
If Jesus is God, how can God die?
Death is the separation of the spirit from the body, NOT the end of existence. So when Jesus “died,” his divine nature didn’t die—only his human body experienced death.
Sources
Closer Look Initiative.
“More Objections to the Deity of Christ” (closerlookinitiative.com/archives/14555) and “The Common Objections to the Deity of Jesus” (closerlookinitiative.com/archives/9426). Bible Vaccine Center and Closer Look Initiative are run by the same team.
The author’s own research.
The Greek, Hebrew, manuscript and historical claims, and the statements about what SCJ teaches that carry this label in the text, are from the author’s own research.
Scripture.
NET Bible, quoted as (NET).
Scripture quotations are from the NET Bible®, https://netbible.com, copyright ©1996, 2019 by Biblical Studies Press, L.L.C. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
