Series · Part 9, article 3 of 5Lee Man-hee · How members treat Lee

Part 9 · article 68 of 70

How Shincheonji members treat Lee Man-hee: kneeling, hymns, welcomes and pilgrimage

10 min readHow we check sources

Short answer

Although Shincheonji officially maintains that Lee Man-hee is a human messenger rather than God, numerous investigations, internal publications, recordings, and former-member testimonies document practices in which Lee receives praise, devotion, and reverence ordinarily associated with divine figures.

The record includes a reporter who saw more than 3,000 people kneel when Lee entered a service (2012), a hymn line that says “let us praise and worship King Man-hee” (reported 2016), SCJ’s own report that it disciplined 16 people over hymn lyrics “praising a human being” (2017), and SCJ’s own newspaper comparing a welcome of Lee to the crowds that welcomed Jesus (2024). Much of it comes from news outlets and critics, and we label each item. SCJ’s own books on Lee’s titles and doctrine are in What Shincheonji’s books say about Lee Man-hee, God and Jesus.

Not every individual practice necessarily constitutes worship. Kneeling, ceremonial honors, and respectful titles can have cultural or nonreligious meanings.

On this page (11 sections)
  1. Short answer
  2. Kneeling at his entrance
  3. Hymns
  4. Welcomes and honors
  5. Birthdays and Teachers’ Day
  6. Pilgrimage to Cheongdo
  7. Testimony
  8. SCJ’s position
  9. Where to go next
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. Sources

Kneeling at his entrance

Source: news report, 2012

On September 12, 2012, the Catholic Times of Korea published a reporter’s account of a Sunday service under the headline “이만희 앞에 무릎 꿇고 경배… ‘신천지만 구원’ 설교” (“Kneeling and worshipping before Lee Man-hee… ‘Only Shincheonji is saved’ sermon”). The reporter writes that when Lee appeared, “3000명 이상의 사람들이 일제히 무릎을 꿇었다” (“more than 3,000 people knelt all at once”), then shouted “총회장님 사랑합니다” (“Chairman, we love you”), and that their posture held until Lee told them to “sit comfortably.” The article says people took that posture only when praying and when Lee appeared, and that they showed Lee “하느님에 대한 예와 동등한 예” (“the same courtesy as is shown to God”). “Worship” in the headline and the comparison with God are the reporter’s words. We found no SCJ reply to it.

Hymns

Source: news report; SCJ’s own acknowledgment as reported

In 2014, SCJ published a new hymnal with 351 songs (Hyundai Jonggyo, July 24, 2017). In April 2016, CBS broadcast a report on hymn 43 in which Pastor Jin Yong-sik, president of an association of heresy counselors, read the lyric from the hymnal: “온 천하 만민들아 시온산에 올라가서 오늘 나신 만희왕을 기쁨으로 맞이하자. 오늘 나신 만희왕께 찬양하며 경배하자” (“All peoples of the world, go up to Mount Zion and welcome with joy King Man-hee, born today. Let us praise and worship King Man-hee born today,” CBS, via Church and Faith). The same CBS report says other hymns praise the “Counselor” and “the Overcomer” (CBS, April 27, 2016). We have not seen the hymnal.

The Korean word 경배 refers to worship, adoration, or reverential homage and is frequently used in Christian contexts to describe worship directed toward God.

SCJ’s own newspaper, Cheonji Ilbo, reported on June 4, 2017, that SCJ disciplined 16 people (suspension or expulsion) for putting “lyrics praising a human being” in the new hymnal, and that it stopped using the hymnal. It said Lee learned of the lyrics only recently, and that praise and glory belong to God, not to “a person who will be saved or has been saved.” We know this report only as quoted by two critic outlets (Christian World, June 8, 2017; Hyundai Jonggyo, July 24, 2017). The Cheonji Ilbo original was not found. Hyundai Jonggyo says the hymnal’s preface credits Lee as editor and that he repeatedly told members to write hymns. Christian Portal News (June 7, 2017) reports that the hymnal was produced through SCJ’s publication department and music committees, and that its preface thanks God, Jesus and Lee Man-hee for permitting its compilation.

Critic outlet. Bible and Church quotes lines it says come from SCJ hymns posted on an online community board: “하늘 아래 구원자가 여럿이라지만 나에게는 오직 이긴 자이신 이만희님이라오” (“They say there are many saviors under heaven, but for me there is only the Overcomer, Mr. Lee Man-hee”), and, from the revised hymnal, “시온 산의 어린양 나의 주님 이긴 자 이만희 님” (“Lamb of Mount Zion, my Lord, the Overcomer, Mr. Lee Man-hee”) and “아버지 하나님과 예수님이 함께 하시는 나의 주님 이긴 자 이만희 님께” (“To my Lord the Overcomer, Mr. Lee Man-hee, with whom Father God and Jesus are”). We have not seen the hymnal or the board post.

Welcomes and honors

Source: SCJ’s own media, news report

SCJ’s own media. Cheonji Ilbo reported on September 7, 2024, on Lee’s visit to the Gangneung church. About 2,000 members lined the route. The report compares the welcome with the one Jesus received: “just as people held palm branches and shouted ‘Hosanna’ to welcome Jesus, the messenger of peace, at his first coming” (“초림 때 손에 종려나무 가지를 들고 호산나를 외치며 평화의 사자이신 예수님을 맞이했던 것처럼”). It adds that members receive him with “최고의 존경심과 예우” (“the highest respect and honor”), and that “the joy of seeing the messenger Jesus sent reaches its peak.” It shows Lee waving from his car window and does not mention any correction. On December 25, 2024, its photo report from Suwon says members waved “신천지 보좌기” (the caption’s term; “보좌” means “throne,” and we have not confirmed what the flags are) and cheered as he arrived.

News report. In 2018, Lee visited the Daegu church. The Wall Street Journal reported that he arrived in a Mercedes Maybach, that followers in traditional dress formed a line and bowed their heads, and quoted former member Hee-jin Koh: “It was like a king had arrived” (WSJ, March 6, 2020). That is one former member’s impression. In March 2024, CBS reported on the 40th anniversary event: an honor guard, cheering crowds, members shouting “보혜사” (“Counselor”), children performing, and an SCJ official saying, “약속의 목자 총회장님과 함께 완성의 그날까지 목숨 걸고 뛰고 또 뛰겠습니다” (“We will run and run with our lives at stake, together with the promised pastor, the Chairman, until the day of completion”) (CBS, March 14, 2024). CBS’s own word for the event was 신격화, “deification.” We report the scenes, not that word.

Critic outlets. Christian Portal News reports that on July 18, 2014, after Lee returned from an overseas trip, the master of ceremonies introduced him as “만왕의 왕 총회장님” (“Chairman, King of Kings”). Bible and Church describes a video in which members greeting Lee after his twelfth international peace tour shout “만왕의 왕, 평화의 왕이 오셨다” (“the King of Kings, the King of Peace has come”). We have not seen the video.

Birthdays and Teachers’ Day

Source: news report

In 2008, CBS obtained video of a Teachers’ Day celebration and a birthday party for Lee, hosted by a harmonica worship artist who sang SCJ praise songs. It says Lee sang along and thanked the audience (CBS, December 31, 2008). In 2016, CBS showed children from SCJ’s children’s arts group singing at a soccer tournament held on his birthday, ending with “총회장님, 원장님 사랑합니다” (“Chairman, Director, we love you”) (CBS, April 27, 2016). Hymn 43’s “born today” fits a birthday song, but we have not seen it sung at one.

Birthday celebrations alone do not constitute religious worship.

Pilgrimage to Cheongdo

Source: news report, critic outlet, SCJ-linked coverage

News report. Newsis reported in February 2020 that SCJ counts Cheongdo, Lee’s hometown, as one of its three holy sites, with Gwacheon and Gyeryongsan’s Guksabong, that members worship in groups near his birthplace, and that Lee says he met a descending light three times there (Newsis, Feb 21, 2020). Critic outlet. A Presbyterian newspaper lists seven stops on a pilgrimage route, including a birthplace house, graves of Lee’s family, and a stream where Lee says angels caught fish for him, and uses the phrase “빛의 성지 청도” (“Cheongdo, Holy Land of Light”). The paper says SCJ is buying land there (Korean Christian Press). SCJ-linked coverage. A local paper’s October 28, 2018, report on a graduation ceremony at Cheongdo’s stadium is headlined “The light that began in Cheongdo, the village of life, shines on the whole world” (Semyeong Ilbo). JoongAng Ilbo quotes an SCJ official on the two sites in Cheongdo associated with Lee’s birthplace and with the light he says came down: “신천지 교인들은 그 빛을 ‘하나님’으로 해석한다” (“Shincheonji members interpret that light as ‘God’”). The Semyeong Ilbo piece says Jesus’s gospel reached “동방의 나라 대한민국 청도” (“Cheongdo, in the land of the East, South Korea”).

News report. CBS Nocut News reported in 2015 that Lee took members on a tour of his hometown in 2004, pointing out where he says he received revelation, and that a “Meeting Shelter” (만남쉼터) was built there in 2009 for visiting members. A former member told CBS that members with strong recruiting results were chosen for the tours (CBS Nocut News, March 17, 2015).

Critic outlet. The Korean Christian Press reader’s letter also names Biseulsan mountain, where Lee is said to have seen stars pour down while he gathered wood; Hyeolli Bridge; the Meeting Shelter; and Hoboksan mountain, where he is said to have met the spirit person (靈人). At the Gakbuk Stream, the letter says, a woman and children appeared and caught fish for Lee when the water was too high, and SCJ members call them angels. We did not find these stories in SCJ’s own publications.

Press report. CTS News reported on April 24, 2024, that wall paintings at the edge of the hometown village were read by church critics as showing Lee meeting the great star in childhood and SCJ recruiting, and that residents had covered an SCJ volunteer-corps mark on the wall. CTS adds that SCJ’s Thaddeus Tribe calls Cheongdo the “Holy Land of Light” (빛의 성지). We have not seen SCJ’s own description of the paintings (CTS News, April 24, 2024).

The Semyeong Ilbo piece also says Cheongdo is called the “Israel of the East” (동양의 이스라엘), and ties the name to a story that the apostle Thomas preached there in A.D. 42.

Testimony

Court witness. On November 16, 2020, a former secretary-general of HWPL, SCJ’s peace organization, who had been an SCJ member from 2003 to 2017, testified at Lee’s trial. Shown a prosecutors’ chart ranking “God, Jesus, Lee,” he said, “신천지 내에서 이만희의 말은 하나님의 말과 같다” (“Within Shincheonji, Lee Man-hee’s words are the same as God’s words”) (Yonhap, Nov 16, 2020).

However, it should be accurately identified as witness testimony rather than a judicial determination that Shincheonji worships Lee as God.

Former member. Kim Eun-kang, who joined in 2014 and left after a year, told ABC (Australia): “Lee Man-hee said he possessed the spirit of Jesus. When he was shown in TV or in public, I would just start to cry. I felt some aura around him” (ABC, May 2, 2021). In CBS’s 2016 report, a former member says that over time members come to believe Lee will never die (CBS, April 27, 2016).

SCJ’s position

SCJ’s answer is on the record: Lee is a messenger, and the head of the Shincheonji kingdom is Jesus Christ (Shincheonji website, chairman’s greeting). SCJ’s own newspaper also reported in 2017 that 16 people were disciplined over hymn lyrics “praising a human being.” The other items above come from reporters, critics and former members, and each is labeled by its source type.

Where to go next

  1. 62What Shincheonji’s books say about Lee Man-hee, God and Jesus
  2. 3Who is Lee Man-hee? What SCJ teaches about him
  3. Lee Man-hee’s eternal life claims in SCJ books

Frequently asked questions

Do Shincheonji members kneel before Lee Man-hee?

A Catholic Times reporter said so in 2012. He saw more than 3,000 people kneel when Lee entered and shout “Chairman, we love you.” That is one news report, and we found no SCJ reply (Catholic Times, Sept 12, 2012).

Did Shincheonji ban a hymnal for praising Lee Man-hee?

SCJ’s own newspaper reported in 2017 that it disciplined 16 people over lyrics “praising a human being” and stopped using the hymnal. We know the report only as quoted by two critic outlets. CBS reported in 2016 that hymn 43 reads, “Let us praise and worship King Man-hee.”

What does Shincheonji say about worshipping Lee Man-hee?

SCJ says Lee is a messenger and that the head of its kingdom is Jesus Christ. The record in this article, mostly from news reports, covers kneeling, hymn lyrics, royal-style welcomes and pilgrimages. Not every practice has a religious meaning, and the article labels each item by its source type.

Sources

SCJ’s own media.

  1. “[천지일보 영상뉴스] 이만희 총회장 강릉 방문에 일대는 ‘대대적 환대’…,” Cheonji Ilbo, Sept 7, 2024. https://www.newscj.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=3177174
  2. “[포토 종합] ‘신천지 성탄절 기념예배’…,” Cheonji Ilbo, Dec 25, 2024. https://www.newscj.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=3215288
  3. Shincheonji website, chairman’s greeting. https://www.shincheonji.org/ko/introduce/greeting

News reports.

  1. “이만희 앞에 무릎 꿇고 경배…,” Catholic Times of Korea, Sept 12, 2012. https://www.catholictimes.org/article/201209120006968
  2. “여기가 북한? 신천지 이만희 노골적 우상화 작업,” CBS Nocut News, April 27, 2016. https://m.news.nate.com/view/20160427n03145
  3. “‘신천지 OUT’ … 찬송가 ‘만희왕께 찬양하며 경배하자’,” Church and Faith (quoting CBS, April 1, 2016 broadcast). https://www.penews.co.kr/news/articleView.html?idxno=1895
  4. CBS Nocut News, Dec 31, 2008. https://mch.nocutnews.co.kr/news/534198
  5. “신천지 40주년 신격화·내부 결집 총력,” CBS Nocut News, March 14, 2024. https://m.nocutnews.co.kr/news/amp/6111765
  6. Dasl Yoon, “A Man of Two Faces,” The Wall Street Journal, March 6, 2020 (read in a PDF reproduction). https://2021.sopawards.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/5/2021/05/Dasl-Yoon.pdf
  7. “신천지 탈퇴자 ‘신도들 사이서 이만희는 하나님과 같아’,” Yonhap, Nov 16, 2020. https://www.yna.co.kr/view/AKR20201116152700061
  8. Carrington Clarke et al., ABC News (Australia), May 2, 2021. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-05-02/south-koreas-secretive-religious-sect/100101810
  9. “신천지 이만희 총회장 형 장례식 왜 청도서 열렸을까?,” Newsis, Feb 21, 2020. https://mobile.newsis.com/view_amp.html?ar_id=NISX20200221_0000927237

Critic outlets and local papers (labeled in the text).

  1. Christian Portal News, June 7, 2017. https://www.antiscj.or.kr/technote7/board.php?board=aboard6&command=body&no=548 (page no longer available)
  2. “이만희 교주, ‘자신을 우상화한 새 찬송가 금지’,” Christian World, June 8, 2017. http://www.christianworld.or.kr/news/articleView.html?idxno=2282
  3. “이만희 신격화한 신천지 새찬송가,” Hyundai Jonggyo, July 24, 2017. http://www.hdjk.co.kr/news/view.html?category=1001&no=15372&section=22
  4. “신천지는 어떤 종교단체인가?,” Bible and Church. https://bibleandchurch.kr/archives/1347
  5. “청도 성지화 저지를 위한 대구동노회의 호소,” Korean Christian Press, July 7, 2024. https://m.pckworld.com/article.php?aid=10293723334
  6. “생명의 고을 ‘청도’서 시작된 ‘빛’…온 세계 비추다,” Semyeong Ilbo, Oct 28, 2018. https://m.smnews.co.kr/view.php?idx=49355
  7. “신천지 이만희 교주 고향서 은밀한 신격화 작업,” CBS Nocut News, March 17, 2015 (repost of the CBS report). https://v.daum.net/v/20150317142706414
  8. “신천지 ‘청도 성지’ 가속화 ➀ 이만희 출생지·가묘 위치…신격화 작업 의혹,” CTS News, April 24, 2024 (video, Korean auto-captions). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yW3Q8Feg0dQ