Shincheonji · Political outreach
HWPL Mindanao Peace Claim: What Shincheonji Says vs Record
The Mindanao Peace Claim: What HWPL Says, and What the Record Shows
Short answer: HWPL hosted a civilian signing in General Santos City on 24 January 2014, and Shincheonji media later credited Lee Man-hee with ending Mindanao’s conflict. Neither signer represented the government or the MILF, the two sides’ own talks had run since 1997, and we found no government or peace-panel record crediting HWPL; in September 2026 Shincheonji’s own paper said the sequence of events alone does not prove the link.
On 24 January 2014, HWPL, the peace organization chaired by Shincheonji founder Lee Man-hee, hosted a signing ceremony in General Santos City, Mindanao. HWPL and the Shincheonji-aligned newspaper Cheonji Ilbo have since credited Lee with ending Mindanao’s decades-long conflict. This page sets out what is claimed, how it is presented to members, and what the record of the Philippine peace process shows.
By Chris Vishoot12 min readSource notes
On this page
Quick facts
- HWPL event: 24 January 2014, General Santos City. A peace walk, then a signing at a hotel.
- Signers: Fernando Capalla, retired Archbishop of Davao, and Esmael Mangudadatu, then the sitting governor of Maguindanao.
- Parties to the armed conflict: the Government of the Philippines and the Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF). Neither was a party to the HWPL signing.
- Government–MILF final annex: signed 25 January 2014 in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, after talks that began in 1997.
What HWPL and Shincheonji claim
HWPL’s own page (opens in new tab) describes the event modestly, as an agreement “reached through the effort of the civil society for Mindanao’s peace,” signed by Capalla and Mangudadatu before about 300 people.
Other HWPL and Cheonji Ilbo material goes much further. Cheonji Ilbo is a newspaper aligned with Shincheonji.
- Cheonji Ilbo’s English edition (May 2014) (opens in new tab) called the HWPL signing “a decisive catalyst for signing the final annex to the Peace Treaty the next day.”
- Cheonji Ilbo (31 August 2014) credited Lee with the government–MILF agreement itself:
English translationIn January this year Chairman Lee astonished the world by bringing about the peace agreement between the Philippine government and the MILF.
원문 · Original이만희 대표는 올해 1월 필리핀 정부와 이슬람 반군세력 모로이슬람해방전선…과의 평화협정을 이끌어내 세계를 놀라게 했다.
- Cheonji Ilbo (21 December 2020) said the government and MILF agreed the final annex after hearing of HWPL’s signing, and that the war “effectively ended completely” when the Bangsamoro law was signed:
English translationHaving heard the news of the Mindanao civilian peace agreement, the government and the MILF finally agreed the last annex the very next day, 25 January.
With President Duterte finally signing this bill in August 2018, the Mindanao civil war effectively ended completely.
원문 · Original민다나오 민간 평화협정 소식을 접한 정부군과 모로이슬람해방전선(MILF) 측은 바로 다음날인 1월 25일 예비평화협정서의 마지막 부속문서에 최종 합의했다.
2018년 8월 두테르테 대통령이 이 법안에 최종 서명하면서 민다나오 내전은 사실상 완전히 종식됐다.
The law was signed on 26 July 2018 (opens in new tab), not in August.
- HWPL (2021) (opens in new tab) quoted Lee: “Today, Mindanao is no longer a place of conflict; rather, it has become a model of peace to which the world looks.”
How it is presented as fulfillment
Shincheonji’s official site says Lee is the messenger sent in Jesus’ name (Revelation 22:16), and that what he testifies to is Revelation being fulfilled:
English translationI, Shincheonji’s messenger of prophecy (the one who overcomes), did not come of my own accord but was sent to the churches in the name of Jesus (Rev 22:16).
원문 · Original나 신천지의 대언의 사자(이긴자)는 스스로 온 것이 아니요, 예수님의 이름으로 교회들에게 보냄을 받고 왔다(계22:16).
Cheonji Ilbo’s 2020 article says Lee went to Mindanao after receiving a “heavenly mandate” (천명), and ends:
English translationGod gifted ‘peace’ to Mindanao. This must be because the God who has the power to make peace was with Chairman Lee.
원문 · Original민다나오에 신(神)은 ‘평화’를 선물했다. 이는 평화를 이룰 힘을 가진 신이 이 대표에게 함께했기 때문일 것이다.
Internal Shincheonji material reported by CBS in 2020 described HWPL as an organization “made by the Chairman, the peace messenger, according to the will of heaven”:
English translationThe heavenly organization is an organization made by the Chairman, the peace messenger, according to the will of heaven.
원문 · Original하늘 단체는 평화의 사자이신 총회장님께서 하늘의 뜻을 따라 만든 조직
Within that teaching, Mindanao is presented as evidence that the “peace messenger” is doing heaven’s work. We have not found a Shincheonji sermon that ties Mindanao to one specific verse.
What actually happened
The conflict was a Moro separatist insurgency against the Philippine state over land, autonomy and the marginalization of the Muslim population (opens in new tab). It was not a war between the Catholic Church and Islam.
The government and the MILF negotiated for years, with Malaysia as facilitator. They were supported by an International Contact Group (opens in new tab) (Turkey, Saudi Arabia, the UK, Japan and several international NGOs) and a Third Party Monitoring Team. The government panel was chaired by Miriam Coronel-Ferrer and the MILF panel by Mohagher Iqbal.
On Saturday 25 January 2014, in Kuala Lumpur, the two panel chairs signed the Annex on Normalization (opens in new tab), the last annex to the 2012 Framework Agreement. It was the 43rd round of talks (opens in new tab). The Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro (opens in new tab) followed on 27 March 2014 in Manila.
The Philippine peace office’s 2018 release on the signing of the Bangsamoro Organic Law (opens in new tab), which reviews the history of the process, does not mention HWPL. We found no government, peace panel or Malaysian facilitator record that credits HWPL with the government–MILF agreements.
Who signed the HWPL agreement
- Fernando Capalla (opens in new tab) was Archbishop of Davao from 1996 to 2012, and so retired at the time. He was long active in Bishops–Ulama interfaith dialogue. He did not sit on either negotiating panel.
- Esmael Mangudadatu (opens in new tab) was governor of Maguindanao from 2010 to 2019, so he was in office in January 2014. He was a provincial official of the Philippine state, not an MILF official or negotiator.
A provincial information office report (opens in new tab) from that week described an “International Interfaith Peace Walk” organized by Mindanao State University’s College of Education with IPYG, a youth group affiliated with HWPL, ending in a “solidarity agreement.” It did not mention Lee or HWPL by name.
Violence after 2014
- 25 January 2015: the Mamasapano clash (opens in new tab) in Maguindanao killed 44 police commandos. The government’s peace office (opens in new tab) later said the first Bangsamoro bill failed because of low public support after it.
- 23 May – 23 October 2017: the siege of Marawi (opens in new tab) by ISIS-affiliated militants.
What official bodies in Mindanao have said
Some official bodies in Mindanao have honoured the HWPL event.
- In May 2015, Maguindanao province unveiled an HWPL-donated peace monument (opens in new tab) and agreed to mark 24 January as “HWPL day.”
- On 24 January 2016, a second HWPL monument was built (opens in new tab) at Camp Darapanan, and MILF leadership proclaimed 24 January “Peace Day” during its unveiling.
- In February 2024, the MILF-led Bangsamoro parliament adopted Resolution 439 (opens in new tab). It calls the 2014 event “a pioneering civilian-led peace agreement” and makes 24 January “Peace Day” in the region.
Resolution 439 does not say the HWPL event produced the government–MILF agreements. It says the government and MILF have supported HWPL’s campaign “since 2015.”
Criticism
In 2015 the Korean outlet Hyundae Jonggyo wrote:
English translationThe claim that a civilian event the day before influenced a government-level agreement in a third country is absurd.
원문 · Original제3국에서 열리는 정부 차원의 협정에 하루전날 열린 민간차원의 행사가 영향을 줬다는 주장은 터무니없다.
It also reported that the Philippine Embassy in Seoul was “전혀 인지하고 있지 않다” (“not aware at all”) of the HWPL agreement.
Shincheonji’s own paper now qualifies the claim
A Cheonji Ilbo feature from 11 September 2026 says:
English translationHowever, it is hard to conclude from the sequence of the two events alone that the HWPL civilian agreement directly produced the government–MILF agreement, because the official government–MILF negotiations had been going on for a long time before it.
원문 · Original다만 두 사건의 선후관계만으로 HWPL 민간 협정이 정부-MILF 합의를 직접 만들어냈다고 단정하기는 어렵다. 정부와 MILF의 공식 협상은 HWPL의 민간 협정 이전부터 장기간 진행돼왔기 때문이다.
The same feature still says the HWPL signing contributed to a peace mood in the region.
Sourcing noteWe have not yet asked Shincheonji for comment. Disclosure: Bible Vaccine Center and Closer Look Initiative are run by the same team.
Timeline, 1997 to 2026
1990s
- 1997Peace process
Government–MILF negotiations begin.
Source: Wikipedia, Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro (opens in new tab)
2010s
- 15 Oct 2012Peace process
Framework Agreement on the Bangsamoro signed.
Source: Wikipedia, Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro (opens in new tab)
- 24 Jan 2014HWPL event
HWPL signing in General Santos City (Capalla and Mangudadatu).
Sources: HWPL, Peace Agreement – Mindanao (opens in new tab) · Sarangani Information Office, 28 Jan 2014 (opens in new tab)
- 25 Jan 2014Peace process
Government and MILF panels sign the final annex in Kuala Lumpur.
Sources: Annex on Normalization (PA-X) (opens in new tab) · GMA News, 25 Jan 2014 (opens in new tab) · BBC News, 25 Jan 2014 (opens in new tab)
- 27 Mar 2014Peace process
Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro signed in Manila.
Source: Wikipedia, Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro (opens in new tab)
- 25 Jan 2015Violence
Mamasapano clash.
- 25 May 2015Recognition in Mindanao
Maguindanao unveils an HWPL peace monument and marks 24 January as “HWPL day.”
- 24 Jan 2016Recognition in Mindanao
Second HWPL peace monument built at Camp Darapanan; MILF leadership proclaims 24 January “Peace Day” during its unveiling.
Source: Bangsamoro Transition Authority, Resolution 439 (opens in new tab)
- 23 May – 23 Oct 2017Violence
Siege of Marawi.
- 26 Jul 2018Peace process
Bangsamoro Organic Law signed.
- 2019Peace process
Plebiscites; the Bangsamoro region is inaugurated on 29 March.
Source: Wikipedia, Bangsamoro peace process (opens in new tab)
2020s
- 26 Feb 2024Recognition in Mindanao
Bangsamoro parliament adopts Resolution 439.
Source: Bangsamoro Transition Authority, Resolution 439 (opens in new tab)
- 11 Sep 2026Shincheonji media
Cheonji Ilbo says the sequence of events alone does not show that the HWPL signing directly produced the government–MILF deal.
Source: Cheonji Ilbo (SCJ-aligned), 11 Sep 2026 (opens in new tab)
Summary of findings
- HWPL hosted a civilian signing in General Santos City on 24 January 2014. Neither signer represented the government or the MILF.
- The government and MILF signed their final annex in Kuala Lumpur on 25 January 2014, after talks that began in 1997.
- Cheonji Ilbo credited Lee with bringing about the government–MILF agreement.
- No Philippine government or peace-panel record we found credits HWPL with that agreement.
- Maguindanao (2015) and the Bangsamoro parliament (2024) have honoured the HWPL event as a civilian initiative.
- Major violence continued after 2014, including Mamasapano (2015) and Marawi (2017).
Frequently asked questions
What happened in General Santos City on 24 January 2014?
HWPL hosted a civilian signing in General Santos City on 24 January 2014. Neither signer represented the government or the MILF. HWPL’s own page describes the event modestly, as an agreement “reached through the effort of the civil society for Mindanao’s peace,” signed by Capalla and Mangudadatu before about 300 people.
Who signed the HWPL agreement?
Fernando Capalla was Archbishop of Davao from 1996 to 2012, and so retired at the time. He did not sit on either negotiating panel. Esmael Mangudadatu was governor of Maguindanao from 2010 to 2019, so he was in office in January 2014. He was a provincial official of the Philippine state, not an MILF official or negotiator.
Did the HWPL signing bring about the government–MILF agreement?
We found no government, peace panel or Malaysian facilitator record that credits HWPL with the government–MILF agreements. The Philippine peace office’s 2018 release on the signing of the Bangsamoro Organic Law, which reviews the history of the process, does not mention HWPL.
When did the government and the MILF sign the final annex?
The government and MILF signed their final annex in Kuala Lumpur on 25 January 2014, after talks that began in 1997. It was the 43rd round of talks.
Have official bodies in Mindanao honoured the HWPL event?
Some official bodies in Mindanao have honoured the HWPL event. In February 2024, the MILF-led Bangsamoro parliament adopted Resolution 439. Resolution 439 does not say the HWPL event produced the government–MILF agreements.
What does Cheonji Ilbo say about the claim now?
A Cheonji Ilbo feature of 11 September 2026 says it is “hard to conclude from the sequence of the two events alone” that the HWPL signing directly produced the government–MILF agreement, because the official negotiations had been going on long before it. The same feature still says the HWPL signing contributed to a peace mood in the region.
Source notes
- HWPL, “Peace Agreement – Mindanao.” https://www.hwpl.kr/language/en/peaceagreement-mindanao/ (opens in new tab)
- HWPL, “7th Anniversary of the January 24 HWPL Peace Day,” 29 Jan 2021. https://www.hwpl.kr/language/en/7th-anniversary-of-the-january-24-hwpl-peace-day/ (opens in new tab)
- Cheonji Ilbo (English), “Lee, a Korean Peacemaker Bears Fruit of Peace in Mindanao,” 11 May 2014. https://www.newscj.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=239143 (opens in new tab)
- Cheonji Ilbo, “전쟁과 평화Ⅱ ⑤,” 31 Aug 2014. https://www.newscj.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=254941 (opens in new tab)
- Cheonji Ilbo, “[한국인 이만희 평화실화<2-1>] 민다나오 민간 평화협정 그후,” 21 Dec 2020. https://www.newscj.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=810941 (opens in new tab)
- Cheonji Ilbo, feature, 11 Sep 2026. https://www.newscj.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=3431570 (opens in new tab)
- Shincheonji official site, greeting page. https://www.shincheonji.org/ko/introduce/greeting (opens in new tab)
- CBS No Cut News, 18 Mar 2020. https://www.nocutnews.co.kr/news/5311104 (opens in new tab)
- Annex on Normalization, text (PA-X), 25 Jan 2014. https://www.peaceagreements.org/agreements/882/ (opens in new tab)
- GMA News, “GPH, MILF panels sign final annex to Bangsamoro framework agreement,” Jan 2014. https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/topstories/nation/345550/gph-milf-panels-sign-final-annex-to-bangsamoro-framework-agreement/story/ (opens in new tab)
- BBC News, Jan 2014. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-25896408 (opens in new tab)
- Office of the Presidential Adviser on the Peace Process, “PRRD signs Bangsamoro Organic Law,” Jul 2018. https://peace.gov.ph/2018/07/prrd-signs-bangsamoro-organic-law/ (opens in new tab)
- Sarangani Information Office, 28 Jan 2014. http://saranganitoday.blogspot.com/2014/02/progsarmea-participates-in-world-peace.html (opens in new tab)
- Wikipedia, “Esmael Mangudadatu.” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Esmael_Mangudadatu (opens in new tab)
- Wikipedia, “Fernando Capalla.” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fernando_Capalla (opens in new tab)
- Wikipedia, “Mamasapano clash.” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mamasapano_clash (opens in new tab)
- Wikipedia, “Siege of Marawi.” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siege_of_Marawi (opens in new tab)
- MindaNews via CMFR, “Maguindanao unveils peace monument courtesy of Korean peace advocates,” 26 May 2015. https://cmfr-phil.org/womensvoices/features/maguindanao-unveils-peace-monument-courtesy-of-korean-peace-advocates/ (opens in new tab)
- Bangsamoro Transition Authority, Resolution 439, 26 Feb 2024. https://parliament.bangsamoro.gov.ph/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/AR-439-January-24-as-Peace-Day.pdf (opens in new tab)
- Hyundae Jonggyo (현대종교), 30 Nov 2015. http://www.hdjongkyo.co.kr/m/content/view.html?category=1001&no=14672§ion=22 (opens in new tab)
- Wikipedia, “Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro.” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comprehensive_Agreement_on_the_Bangsamoro (opens in new tab)
- Wikipedia, “Bangsamoro peace process.” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bangsamoro_peace_process (opens in new tab)
Peer-led, non-clinical support; not a substitute for professional care. In a crisis in the US, call or text 988.
