Shincheonji · Political outreach

WARP Summit 2014: Shincheonji Behind the Peace Brand

The 2014 WARP Summit: What Guests Were Told, and What Members Were Taught

Short answer: The World Alliance of Religions’ Peace (WARP) Summit, held in Seoul on 16–19 September 2014, was hosted by HWPL, the group chaired by Shincheonji founder Lee Man-hee. Foreign guests were invited to a peace conference, while in Korean the event was called the “Conference of All Nations for the Grand Unification of Religions,” and the advertised co-host, the Institute for Cultural Diplomacy, withdrew the day before it opened.

In September 2014, a group called HWPL brought former presidents, religious leaders and youth delegates to Seoul for the World Alliance of Religions’ Peace (WARP) Summit. This page sets out what the summit said it was, what Shincheonji members were taught it meant, and what reporting at the time said about efforts to keep the church’s role out of view.

By Chris Vishoot12 min readSource notes

Quick facts

  • Name: World Alliance of Religions’ Peace (WARP) Summit
  • Dates: 16–19 September 2014
  • Places: Sheraton Walkerhill (welcome dinner), Jamsil Olympic Stadium (opening), 63 Convention Center (signing), Peace Gate, Olympic Park (peace walk)
  • Host: HWPL (Heavenly Culture, World Peace, Restoration of Light), chaired by Lee Man-hee, founder of the Shincheonji Church of Jesus
  • Co-hosts: IWPG (women’s group, chaired by Kim Nam-hee) and IPYG (youth group). The Institute for Cultural Diplomacy (ICD) was listed as a co-host but withdrew the day before the opening.
  • Timing: Lee Man-hee’s birthday is 15 September. The press conference introducing the summit was held on that day.

What the summit said it was

To foreign guests, WARP was a peace conference. HWPL said it would create “a platform for dialogue between community leaders on national, cultural, spiritual, and ethnic levels” and push for an international law to end war. Invitations described the chairman as a “renowned Korean peace activist.”

Former heads of state and government spoke, including Emil Constantinescu (Romania), Stjepan Mesić (Croatia) and Bertie Ahern (Ireland), as did Nobel Peace laureate Tawakkol Karman and leaders from several faiths.

What members were taught it meant

In Korean, the event had a different name: 종교대통합 만국회의, the “Conference of All Nations for the Grand Unification of Religions.”

English version

World Alliance of Religions’ Peace Summit

Korean version

종교대통합 만국회의 (“Conference of All Nations for the Grand Unification of Religions”)

English version

Chaired by a “renowned Korean peace activist”

Korean version

Chaired by Lee Man-hee, whom Shincheonji teaches is the “promised pastor” of Revelation

Critical Korean outlets report that Shincheonji’s motto for 2014 was “지파 완성, 흰무리 창조, 종교대통합, 만국회의의 해” — “the year of completing the tribes, creating the white multitude, the grand unification of religions, and the Conference of All Nations.” The summit’s Korean name uses two of those four phrases.

Shincheonji teaches that after the 144,000 are sealed, a “great multitude in white” from every nation will come to it (Revelation 7:9). Former members say foreign guests at the summit were presented to members as the visible fulfilment of that prophecy. That is why the event mattered so much inside the church, even though no foreign leader is known to have joined.

The pledge delegates were asked to sign also read more like a religious commitment than a policy statement. An attendee, Samuel Shropshire, quoted it:

Published in English

We pledge in the sight of God, all people of the world, and the Peace Advocate to become one under God through the unity of religion … as a united religion.

Secondary · via Samuel ShropshireWARP Summit pledge, as quoted by attendee Samuel Shropshire (opens in new tab), 9 Oct 2014LinkSource: published in English

Kim Nam-hee introduced Lee to the hall as “the Peace Advocate, heaven-sent for all humanity.”

How the Shincheonji connection was kept out of view

The Korea Observer reported, two days before the opening:

Published in English

At this year’s WARP Summit, once again taking place in the same week as Lee Man-hee’s birthday, internal memos went out instructing SCJ participants not to mention SCJ or Mannam.

Secondary · The Korea ObserverJon Twitch, The Korea Observer (opens in new tab), 16 Sep 2014 (reprint)LinkSource: published in English

The same report said Shincheonji had “blocked out its own websites for HWPL, IPYG, and IWPG in Korea to limit the information available, only lifting the block at the commencement of the summit,” and that volunteers it spoke to denied any connection to Shincheonji.

Church & Faith (republished by Christian Today USA) reported that the event details had been “kept thoroughly secret from outsiders” until the press conference two days before the event.

Sourcing noteThe internal memo itself has never been published. These points rest mainly on one outlet’s reporting.

Guests who said they didn’t know

Several people who came said afterward that they had not understood what they were attending.

  • A Muslim delegate, speaking to the Korea Observer at the airport: “We didn’t know the chairman of the peace summit is accused of being a cult leader who claims to be immortal.”
  • A foreign NGO participant, speaking to Daily Goodnews:
English translation

I came thinking it was a peace event, but it was too religious.

원문 · Original

평화행사로 알고 참여했는데 종교적 색채가 너무 났다.

Secondary · Daily GoodnewsA foreign NGO participant, speaking to Daily Goodnews (opens in new tab), 18 Sep 2014LinkOur translation; awaiting native-speaker review.
  • A secretary at the Seoul embassy of an unnamed country, whose former president was attending, told Church & Faith: “We understand he is attending a peace-related symposium, rather than a religious event organized by Shincheonji.” (translated)
  • Martin Bergsma, a Dutch youth leader whose airfare was about 80% paid, later wrote that his group had been photographed so Koreans would see Lee had supporters worldwide, and that he had been asked to make a hand sign he later learned was a Shincheonji symbol. CBS quoted his conclusion:
English translation

We were used as a propaganda tool of Shincheonji.

원문 · Original

신천지 선전도구 이용당했다

Secondary · CBS No Cut NewsCBS No Cut News (opens in new tab) headline, 9 Mar 2016Link

He withdrew his members and refused to sign the pledge.

The co-host that pulled out

The Berlin-based Institute for Cultural Diplomacy (ICD) had been promoted as a co-host. It withdrew on 16 September 2014, the day before the opening. CBS reported that ICD “indicated it would not participate after confirming the true nature (실체) of Shincheonji.” In 2023, ICD told VICE that when it “later learned of the controversies around Lee Man-hee,” it “immediately broke off relations.”

Sourcing noteICD never published its own statement of reasons. Both accounts above are second-hand.

The numbers

ClaimSource
About 200,000 at the openingHWPL press release (opens in new tab)
About 60,000 in the stadiumTwo attendees sympathetic to the event (Braybrooke (opens in new tab), Shropshire (opens in new tab))
“Some 30,000” on the closing walkRosita Šorytė (opens in new tab), an academic who defends HWPL

HWPL said about 200,000 people were inside and outside the stadium. Two attendees sympathetic to the event put the crowd in the stadium at about 60,000.

The opening featured a card section of 10,000–12,000 young members holding up coloured cards to form images, including one of Kim Nam-hee as “만민의 어머니” (“Mother of all people”). Critics compared similar Shincheonji stadium displays in 2012 and 2016 to North Korean mass games.

Protests outside the venues

Relatives of Shincheonji members protested outside the stadium and the 63 Building, saying their adult children had left home for the church and asking to see them. Police held protesters back at the 63 Building. Before the event, a national anti-Shincheonji coalition asked Seoul City to cancel it; the city said it had no power to do so.

Timeline, 2012 to 2022

2010s

  1. Sep 2012Before the summit

    Mannam, a Shincheonji-linked volunteer group, holds a “World Peace Festival” at Jamsil for foreigners. Mannam later admits a “failure to disclose the full details of our relationship with Shinchonji church.”

    Source: Yonhap, 28 Oct 2012 (opens in new tab)

  2. 15 Sep 2014Summit week

    Lee’s birthday. Press conference announcing the summit.

  3. 16 Sep 2014Summit week

    ICD withdraws. Korea Observer publishes its report. Welcome dinner.

    Sources: The Korea Observer, 16 Sep 2014 (opens in new tab) · Star Daily News (mirror), 18 Sep 2014 (opens in new tab)

  4. 17 Sep 2014Summit week

    Opening at Jamsil Olympic Stadium. Relatives of members protest outside.

  5. 18 Sep 2014Summit week

    Pledges signed at the 63 Convention Center.

  6. 19 Sep 2014Summit week

    Peace walk at Olympic Park.

  7. 14 Mar 2016Afterward

    HWPL proclaims its Declaration of Peace and Cessation of War (DPCW), which it presents as the summit’s legacy.

    Source: HWPL, DPCW 10th anniversary page (opens in new tab)

  8. 18 Sep 2016Afterward

    “2nd anniversary” event at Jamsil. Korean media report members were told to wear diapers so the card section would have no gaps.

    Source: CBS No Cut News, 19 Sep 2016 (opens in new tab)

2020s

  1. 13 Jan 2021Later court case (2015–2019 events)

    First-instance court convicts Lee of embezzlement; of the public-venue counts, only the Hwaseong stadium use is found guilty. That event was held on 18 Sep 2017 and booked under a volunteer group’s name.

    Sources: CBS No Cut News, 13 Jan 2021 (opens in new tab) · Suwon District Court judgment (LBOX) (opens in new tab)

  2. 30 Nov 2021Later court case (2015–2019 events)

    Suwon High Court also finds the Suwon World Cup Stadium use guilty (3 years suspended for 5). Upheld by the Supreme Court on 12 Aug 2022.

    Sources: CBS No Cut News, 30 Nov 2021 (opens in new tab) · JoongAng Ilbo (opens in new tab) · Cheonji Ilbo (SCJ-aligned) (opens in new tab) · JoongAng Ilbo, 12 Aug 2022 (opens in new tab)

How HWPL describes it today

HWPL now calls the event the “September 18th HWPL World Peace Summit” and presents it as the start of the DPCW. Its anniversary pages do not mention Shincheonji, the ICD withdrawal or the protests, and the 2014 language of a “unity of religions” has been replaced by language about international law. The DPCW has not been adopted by the United Nations.

HWPL and some academics, notably at CESNUR, argue that HWPL is a genuine peace organization and that the guests were never recruitment targets. On the second point the record agrees: no foreign leader is known to have joined Shincheonji. The concern is not that presidents were converted. It is that guests, the Korean public and members were each told a different story about the same event.

Sourcing noteWe have not yet asked Shincheonji for comment. Disclosure: Bible Vaccine Center and Closer Look Initiative are run by the same team.

Summary of findings

  • HWPL, chaired by Shincheonji founder Lee Man-hee, hosted the summit on 16–19 September 2014. The press conference announcing it was held on his birthday.
  • Invitations described the chair as a “renowned Korean peace activist.” The Korean name, 종교대통합 만국회의, uses two phrases from the church’s 2014 motto.
  • The Korea Observer reported that participants from the church were told not to mention Shincheonji or Mannam. The memo itself has never been published.
  • The Institute for Cultural Diplomacy, listed as a co-host, withdrew the day before the opening.
  • HWPL reported about 200,000 people “both inside and outside of the stadium.” Two attendees sympathetic to the event put the crowd in the stadium at about 60,000.
  • No foreign leader is known to have joined Shincheonji.

Later-context note: a court case about events from 2015 to 2019

At first instance (13 Jan 2021) the only public-venue count found guilty was the Hwaseong stadium use. That event was held on 18 Sep 2017 and booked under a volunteer group’s name. On appeal (30 Nov 2021, Suwon High Court) the Suwon World Cup Stadium use was also found guilty; the Supreme Court upheld the ruling on 12 Aug 2022. These concern events from 2015 to 2019, not the 2014 summit.

The appeal sentence was three years in prison, suspended for five years, plus 80 hours of law-abiding classes. The appeal court upheld the acquittal on the COVID-19 charges.

Sourcing noteFirst-instance ruling: CBS No Cut News, 13 Jan 2021 (opens in new tab); Suwon District Court judgment (LBOX) (opens in new tab). Appeal ruling: CBS No Cut News, 30 Nov 2021 (opens in new tab); JoongAng Ilbo (opens in new tab); Cheonji Ilbo (SCJ-aligned) (opens in new tab). Supreme Court ruling: JoongAng Ilbo, 12 Aug 2022 (opens in new tab).

Separately, in 2026 Lee was arrested and put on trial under South Korea’s Political Parties Act over alleged mass enrollment of members in the People Power Party. That case is not about the 2014 summit; see where the 2026 trial stands.

Frequently asked questions

Who hosted the 2014 WARP Summit?

HWPL, chaired by Shincheonji founder Lee Man-hee, hosted the summit on 16–19 September 2014. The press conference announcing it was held on his birthday.

Did guests know the summit was connected to Shincheonji?

Several people who came said afterward that they had not understood what they were attending. A Muslim delegate, speaking to the Korea Observer at the airport: “We didn’t know the chairman of the peace summit is accused of being a cult leader who claims to be immortal.”

Why did the Institute for Cultural Diplomacy pull out?

CBS reported that ICD “indicated it would not participate after confirming the true nature (실체) of Shincheonji.” In 2023, ICD told VICE that when it “later learned of the controversies around Lee Man-hee,” it “immediately broke off relations.” ICD never published its own statement of reasons. Both accounts above are second-hand.

How many people attended the opening?

HWPL reported about 200,000 people “both inside and outside of the stadium.” Two attendees sympathetic to the event put the crowd in the stadium at about 60,000.

Did any foreign leader join Shincheonji?

No foreign leader is known to have joined Shincheonji. The concern is not that presidents were converted. It is that guests, the Korean public and members were each told a different story about the same event.

Is the DPCW a United Nations document?

HWPL now calls the event the “September 18th HWPL World Peace Summit” and presents it as the start of the DPCW. The DPCW has not been adopted by the United Nations.

Source notes
  1. The Korea Times, “Controversial religious group holds int’l peace event in Seoul,” 18 Sep 2014. https://www.koreatimes.co.kr/lifestyle/others/20140918/controversial-religious-group-holds-intl-peace-event-in-seoul (opens in new tab)
  2. Jon Twitch, The Korea Observer, “Alleged cult leader Lee Man-hee hosts world peace summit in Seoul,” 16 Sep 2014 (reprint). https://www.wwrn.org/articles/43421/ (opens in new tab)
  3. Christian Today USA / 교회와신앙, “이만희 ‘종교대통합‘ 문선명 따라하기,” 22 Sep 2014. http://www.christiantoday.us/22100 (opens in new tab)
  4. Daily Goodnews, “언론 및 누리꾼들 논란 ‘신천지가 종교 통합? 황당해‘,” 18 Sep 2014. https://www.goodnews1.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=59363 (opens in new tab)
  5. CBS No Cut News, “종교대통합 만국회의 해외 참가자.. ‘신천지 선전도구 이용당했다‘ 폭로,” 9 Mar 2016. https://www.nocutnews.co.kr/news/4559719 (opens in new tab)
  6. Star Daily News (mirror), on ICD withdrawal, 18 Sep 2014. https://totalog.net/1632 (opens in new tab)
  7. VICE (German), on ICD, 27 Oct 2023. https://www.vice.com/de/article/wie-ein-berliner-institut-praktikanten-ausnutzt/ (opens in new tab)
  8. Samuel Shropshire, attendee account, 9 Oct 2014. https://samslifeinjeddah.wordpress.com/2014/10/09/world-peace-summit-held-in-seoul/ (opens in new tab)
  9. Marcus Braybrooke, The Interfaith Observer, 15 Oct 2014. http://www.theinterfaithobserver.org/journal-articles/2014/10/15/gatherings-large-and-small-call-for-peace.html (opens in new tab)
  10. Kportal News, “만국회의서, 김남희 ‘만민의 어머니‘,” 19 Sep 2014. http://www.kportalnews.co.kr/news/articleView.html?idxno=13072 (opens in new tab)
  11. Amennews, Shincheonji annual mottos list. https://www.amennews.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=30231 (opens in new tab)
  12. Yonhap, “Mannam Volunteer Association faces criticism from foreign residents,” 28 Oct 2012. https://en.yna.co.kr/view/AEN20121028000200315 (opens in new tab)
  13. CBS No Cut News, 2016 anniversary event report, 19 Sep 2016. https://mch.nocutnews.co.kr/news/4655872 (opens in new tab)
  14. HWPL press release via Newswire, 19 Oct 2014. https://www.newswire.com/news/world-alliance-of-religions-peace-summit-marks-the-beginning-of (opens in new tab)
  15. Rosita Šorytė, The Journal of CESNUR 4(3), 2020. https://cesnur.net/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/tjoc_4_3_2_soryte.pdf (opens in new tab)
  16. HWPL, DPCW 10th anniversary page. https://www.hwpl.kr/language/en/what-path-should-humanity-take-10th-anniversary-of-the-declaration-of-peace-and-cessation-of-war-dpcw/ (opens in new tab)
  17. CBS No Cut News, appeal ruling, 30 Nov 2021. https://www.nocutnews.co.kr/news/5665968 (opens in new tab)
  18. JoongAng Ilbo, appeal ruling. https://www.joongang.co.kr/article/25028173 (opens in new tab)
  19. JoongAng Ilbo, Supreme Court ruling, 12 Aug 2022. https://www.joongang.co.kr/article/25093895 (opens in new tab)
  20. Cheonji Ilbo (SCJ-aligned), appeal ruling. https://www.newscj.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=926842 (opens in new tab)
  21. CBS No Cut News, first-instance ruling, 13 Jan 2021. https://www.nocutnews.co.kr/news/5481175 (opens in new tab)
  22. Suwon District Court, first-instance judgment, 13 Jan 2021 (full text on LBOX). https://lbox.kr/case/%EC%88%98%EC%9B%90%EC%A7%80%EB%B0%A9%EB%B2%95%EC%9B%90/2020%EA%B3%A0%ED%95%A9496 (opens in new tab)

Peer-led, non-clinical support; not a substitute for professional care. In a crisis in the US, call or text 988.