Shincheonji lesson 70: betrayal, destruction and salvation of the chosen people

Lesson 70 · Intermediate

Based on the full Closer Look lesson study

Main verses used

Links open the NET Bible.

What SCJ teaches

This section comes from class notes that an attendee wrote down during SCJ’s 9-month Bible study seminar, posted with the full Closer Look study. They are not SCJ’s printed curriculum, so the wording is the note-taker’s.

Reflection first

The class starts with an exercise. Students write three things that surprised them in the last lesson, plus any questions. “Please send the questions you have to your evangelist.” The surprises are for the next one-on-one. The hope is “To understand the fulfilment of Isaiah 1:1-2:4 at the first coming, and see how the logic of its fulfillment applies to the second coming.”

The notes give a rule: “Generally, the Old Testament points to the first coming, while the New Testament points to the second coming.” They also define destruction: “Destruction, in this context, means assimilation – making what is not his, his own.”

Isaiah 1: betrayal

Isaiah’s vision uses history to point ahead. “Guess what? Judah and Jerusalem are also parables.” Isaiah 1:2-4 is God’s complaint about children he raised. The notes read verse 4 as a clue: “Why did God use “Him” here instead of “me”? Because the “Him” he’s talking about is Jesus.” At the first coming, the betrayers were the shepherds and people of Jerusalem.

Isaiah 1: destruction and the remnant

Assyria is “the club of my wrath” (Isaiah 10:5). At the first coming, the spiritual Gentiles who destroyed the people were the “Pharisees, Sadducees, and teachers of the law”. Four groups are drawn: Jew or Gentile in body, Jew or Gentile in spirit (Romans 2:28-29). The survivors of Isaiah 1:9 were “Jesus and the twelve disciples.” At the second coming they are “New John and the twelve tribes of new spiritual Israel”.

Isaiah 1:15 shows God refusing prayers. Isaiah 1:17 tells the people to defend the widow and the fatherless. The notes recall the parable lesson: “Who was the spiritual widow? A pastor who betrayed.” Isaiah 1:18, “let us reason together,” becomes an invitation to class: “That’s why we say, “Come to one-on-ones. Come to small group.”” Silver and wine in verse 22 are the word, now “dross and diluted.” Revelation 9:21 is called the second-coming match: people who “refused to repent.” Oaks in verse 29 are false pastors, and gardens are “Gentile churches”.

Isaiah 2: salvation and peace

Isaiah 2:1 is said to speak of different people from 1:1, the recreated ones. Zion was Jesus at the first coming. “God will appoint a chief mountain as well, and all nations will stream to this place to come and learn.” Swords and spears become harvest tools. “So if there is a place that is welcoming and spurring on war, it is not Zion.” The summary asks, “What is that place of salvation at the second coming?” The answer: “Mount Zion.” It closes with two questions for each student: “Who am I according to the Bible? And have I been created according to the Bible?”

In SCJ’s own books

Each passage was checked against the scanned page image; page numbers are as printed.

Creation of Heaven and Earth, Lee Man-hee (Shincheonji Press), page 358, from the chapter “Betrayal • Destruction • Salvation”:

“Isaiah 1:1-2:4 summarizes the entire book of Isaiah and figuratively tells us about the spiritual events of betrayal and destruction, which occur at the time of the second coming.”

The same page: “Isaiah’s prophecies were partially fulfilled in a literal way during the time of Physical Israel, but today, they have all been spiritually fulfilled.”

Page 357:

“Believers can only learn the true identities of these groups by listening to the testimony of those who have directly witnessed the events of betrayal and destruction in the place they took place.”

How the lesson notes compare with the books

  • When Isaiah 1-2 is fulfilled. Difference in emphasis. The notes study the first coming and apply the “logic” to today. Creation reads the passage as events “at the time of the second coming” (p. 358). Both lines appear in the notes too, so this is not a clear contradiction.
  • Betrayal, destruction, salvation. Same direction. Both use 2 Thessalonians 2 and Isaiah 1-2.
  • Who explains it. Same direction. The notes point to the New John. Creation says believers “can only learn” from eyewitnesses (p. 357).

What the Bible says

  • Isaiah is the son of Amoz. The notes once say Amos. Here is the message about Judah and Jerusalem that was revealed to Isaiah son of Amoz during the time when Uzziah, Jotham, Ahaz, and Hezekiah reigned over Judah. (Isaiah 1:1, NET)
  • Paul applies Isaiah 1:9 to Jews and Gentiles who believe. Just as Isaiah predicted, “If the Lord of Heaven’s Armies had not left us descendants, we would have become like Sodom, and we would have resembled Gomorrah.” (Romans 9:29, NET)
  • Ten tribes went north, not eleven. I will take the kingdom from the hand of his son and give 10 tribes to you. (1 Kings 11:35, NET)
  • The vineyard is Isaiah 5:1-7. The notes once cite Isaiah 5:28-31. I will sing to my love— a song to my lover about his vineyard. My love had a vineyard on a fertile hill. He built a hedge around it, removed its stones, and planted a vine. He built a tower in the middle of it and constructed a winepress. He waited for it to produce edible grapes, but it produced sour ones instead. (Isaiah 5:1-2, NET)
  • Isaiah 1:15 is about a people whose hands are covered with blood. When you spread out your hands in prayer, I look the other way; when you offer your many prayers, I do not listen because your hands are covered with blood. (Isaiah 1:15, NET)
  • Isaiah 10:5 calls Assyria the club of God’s anger. “Beware, Assyria, the club I use to vent my anger, a cudgel with which I angrily punish. (Isaiah 10:5, NET)
  • In Isaiah, the Holy One of Israel is the Lord himself. For I am the Lord your God, the Holy One of Israel, your deliverer. I have handed over Egypt as a ransom price, Ethiopia and Seba in place of you. (Isaiah 43:3, NET)
  • Revelation 9:20-21 is about people who survived plagues. The rest of humanity, who had not been killed by these plagues, did not repent of the works of their hands so that they did not stop worshiping demons and idols made of gold, silver, bronze, stone, and wood—idols that cannot see or hear or walk about. Furthermore, they did not repent of their murders, of their magic spells, of their sexual immorality, or of their stealing. (Revelation 9:20-21, NET)
  • Jesus said worship would not be tied to a mountain. Jesus said to her, “Believe me, woman, a time is coming when you will worship the Father neither on this mountain nor in Jerusalem. (John 4:21, NET)
  • The messenger of peace announces that God reigns. How delightful it is to see approaching over the mountains the feet of a messenger who announces peace, a messenger who brings good news, who announces deliverance, who says to Zion, “Your God reigns!” (Isaiah 52:7, NET)

Where SCJ’s reading conflicts with the Bible

This lesson reads Isaiah 1 and 2 as a code for betrayal, destruction and salvation. It sets a rule: “Generally, the Old Testament points to the first coming, while the New Testament points to the second coming.” It says, “Judah and Jerusalem are also parables,” that “Him” in Isaiah 1:4 is Jesus, and that the survivors of Isaiah 1:9 were “Jesus and the twelve disciples” and today are “New John and the twelve tribes of new spiritual Israel.” It calls the widow “A pastor who betrayed,” and turns “let us reason together” into “Come to one-on-ones. Come to small group.” SCJ’s The Creation of Heaven and Earth (p. 358) says Isaiah 1:1 to 2:4 “figuratively tells us about the spiritual events of betrayal and destruction, which occur at the time of the second coming,” and (p. 357) that believers “can only learn the true identities of these groups by listening to the testimony of those who have directly witnessed the events of betrayal and destruction.” Isaiah explains much of this chapter in its own words.

  1. 1. The New Testament records the first coming

    The notes give a rule: “Generally, the Old Testament points to the first coming, while the New Testament points to the second coming.”

    • Most of the New Testament is about the first coming. Four Gospels record Jesus’ life, death and resurrection, and Acts and the letters explain what it accomplished.
    • Jesus’ work fulfilled the promises: “every one of God’s promises are ‘Yes’ in him” (2 Corinthians 1:20).
    • The New Testament does look forward to Jesus’ return. But this rule treats nearly the whole New Testament as unfulfilled prophecy waiting for a new interpreter. That’s the course’s framework, not a rule Scripture states.
  2. 2. Isaiah 1 is about the real Judah of Isaiah’s day

    The notes say, “Judah and Jerusalem are also parables.”

    • Isaiah 1:1 dates the vision. It is “the message about Judah and Jerusalem that was revealed to Isaiah son of Amoz during the time when Uzziah, Jotham, Ahaz, and Hezekiah reigned over Judah” (Isaiah 1:1).
    • Isaiah describes what was happening: “Your land is devastated, your cities burned with fire … Daughter Zion is left isolated, like a hut in a vineyard” (1:7-8). This fits the foreign invasions Judah suffered in those reigns.
    • The passage teaches every generation: “everything that was written in former times was written for our instruction” (Romans 15:4). But Judah and Jerusalem are real places and people, not parables.
  3. 3. “Him” in Isaiah 1:4 is the Lord

    The notes ask, “Why did God use ‘Him’ here instead of ‘me’?” and answer, “The Holy One of Israel is Jesus.”

    • Isaiah 1:4: “They have abandoned the Lord, and rejected the Holy One of Israel. They are alienated from him” (Isaiah 1:4). Prophets often speak of God in the third person.
    • “The Holy One of Israel” is Isaiah’s favorite name for God himself, used 25 times in the book: “For I am the Lord your God, the Holy One of Israel, your deliverer” (Isaiah 43:3).
    • Christians believe Jesus is God the Son. But this verse is about Judah abandoning the Lord in Isaiah’s day. It doesn’t prove a first-coming code.
  4. 4. Assyria is Assyria

    The lesson says the spiritual Gentiles who destroyed God’s people at the first coming were the “Pharisees, Sadducees, and teachers of the law,” and says, “Destruction, in this context, means assimilation – making what is not his, his own.”

    • Isaiah 10:5: “Beware, Assyria, the club I use to vent my anger” (Isaiah 10:5). Assyria was the empire God used to judge Israel, and Isaiah then announces that “he will punish the king of Assyria” (10:12).
    • Defining destruction as assimilation fits SCJ’s history. It isn’t taken from Isaiah.
  5. 5. The remnant: Everyone who believes in Christ

    The notes say the survivors of Isaiah 1:9 were “Jesus and the twelve disciples,” and today “New John and the twelve tribes of new spiritual Israel.”

    • Paul quotes Isaiah 1:9 in Romans 9:29, right after describing God calling believers “not only from the Jews but also from the Gentiles” (Romans 9:24-29).
    • “So in the same way at the present time there is a remnant chosen by grace” (Romans 11:5). The remnant is everyone who believes in Christ by grace, Jew or Gentile.
  6. 6. Widows and orphans are real people to defend

    The notes say, “Who was the spiritual widow? A pastor who betrayed. And the fatherless are the congregation of the pastor who betrayed.”

    • Isaiah 1:17: “Learn to do what is right. Promote justice. Give the oppressed reason to celebrate. Take up the cause of the orphan. Defend the rights of the widow” (Isaiah 1:17).
    • Isaiah 1:23 says what was wrong: Judah’s officials “do not take up the cause of the orphan or defend the rights of the widow” (1:23). It’s a rebuke of real injustice toward vulnerable people.
    • “Pure and undefiled religion before God the Father is this: to care for orphans and widows in their adversity” (James 1:27). (See Lesson 54.)

    Turning the widow into a betraying pastor removes the chapter’s call to justice.

  7. 7. Isaiah 1:18 is God’s offer of forgiveness

    The notes say reasoning together is “what we’re actually doing here,” and tell students, “Come to one-on-ones. Come to small group.”

    • Isaiah 1:18: “‘Come, let’s consider your options,’ says the Lord. ‘Though your sins have stained you like the color red, you can become white like snow’” (Isaiah 1:18).
    • It’s the Lord’s invitation to a sinful nation to repent and be cleansed. In the New Testament, that cleansing comes through Christ: “the blood of Jesus his Son cleanses us from all sin” (1 John 1:7).
    • It isn’t an invitation to a class meeting.
  8. 8. Isaiah explains the silver and the watered-down drink

    The lesson says the silver and wine of Isaiah 1:22 are the word, now “dross and diluted.”

    • The NET reads, “Your silver has become scum, your beer is diluted with water” (1:22). The next verse explains: “Your officials are rebels, they associate with thieves. All of them love bribery, and look for payoffs” (1:23).
    • The corrupted silver and watered drink picture Jerusalem’s corrupt leadership. Isaiah tells us so.
  9. 9. The sacred trees and orchards were places of idol worship

    The notes say the oaks of Isaiah 1:29 are false pastors and the gardens are “Gentile churches.”

    • The NET reads, “they will be ashamed of the sacred trees you find so desirable; you will be embarrassed because of the sacred orchards where you choose to worship” (Isaiah 1:29).
    • Elsewhere in Isaiah, these were sites of pagan worship: people who “sacrifice in their sacred orchards and burn incense on brick altars” (65:3; see 66:17).
    • Isaiah 1:29 rebukes Judah for idolatry. It doesn’t describe churches.
  10. 10. Revelation 9:21 is about the rest of humanity

    The lesson calls Revelation 9:21 the second-coming match: people who “refused to repent.”

    • Revelation 9:20-21: “The rest of humanity, who had not been killed by these plagues, did not repent of the works of their hands so that they did not stop worshiping demons and idols made of gold, silver, bronze, stone, and wood” (Revelation 9:20-21). It’s the unrepentant world, not betrayers in a church.
  11. 11. Isaiah 2: The last days began at Pentecost

    The lesson says, “God will appoint a chief mountain as well, and all nations will stream to this place to come and learn,” and that place is Mount Zion today.

    • Isaiah 2:2 looks ahead to “future days” (Isaiah 2:2), which many translations render “the last days.” Peter says the last days began at Pentecost (Acts 2:16-17), and Hebrews says “in these last days he has spoken to us in a son” (Hebrews 1:2).
    • “For Zion will be the center for moral instruction; the Lord’s message will issue from Jerusalem” (Isaiah 2:3). It did: repentance and forgiveness were proclaimed “to all nations, beginning from Jerusalem” (Luke 24:47; Acts 1:8). (See Lessons 44 and 63.)
    • The lesson’s own test is right that a place spurring on war isn’t Zion. “They will beat their swords into plowshares” (2:4) will be fully realized when Christ reigns.
  12. 12. Isaiah 52:7: Good news that God reigns

    • Paul applies Isaiah 52:7 to everyone who preaches the gospel of Christ: “How timely is the arrival of those who proclaim the good news” (Romans 10:15). The message is “Your God reigns!” (Isaiah 52:7).
  13. 13. Questions go to your evangelist

    The lesson asks students to write down what surprised them and says, “Please send the questions you have to your evangelist.” The surprises are saved for the next one-on-one.

    • This keeps every question inside the course’s own channel. The Bereans brought their questions to Scripture, “examining the scriptures carefully every day to see if these things were so” (Acts 17:11). It’s healthy to bring questions to people outside the course too: “with abundant advisers they are established” (Proverbs 15:22).
    • SCJ’s book says believers “can only learn” these identities from eyewitnesses of SCJ’s events (The Creation of Heaven and Earth, p. 357). Isaiah itself names the betrayers (Judah’s officials, 1:23), the destroyer (Assyria, 10:5) and the remnant (believers chosen by grace, Romans 9:29; 11:5). (See Lesson 10.)

What the lesson is really for

This lesson turns Isaiah 1 and 2 into a map of SCJ’s history:

  • The Old Testament is the first coming, and the New Testament is the second.
  • Judah, Jerusalem, Assyria, widows and gardens are figures for churches and pastors.
  • The remnant is the New John and the twelve tribes.
  • Reasoning together means coming to one-on-ones.
  • SCJ’s book says only eyewitnesses of its events can explain the passage.

The biblical answer: Isaiah 1 rebukes Judah’s real leaders for injustice and idolatry (1:17, 23, 29) and offers forgiveness. Sins stained red can become white like snow (1:18). Assyria was God’s club against Israel (10:5). The remnant is everyone chosen by grace through faith in Christ (Romans 9:29; 11:5). And the Lord’s message went out from Jerusalem to all nations through the gospel of Jesus (Isaiah 2:3; Luke 24:47).

What’s happening behind the lesson

These notes are our reading of the lesson text, using Steven Hassan’s BITE model (behavior, information, thought and emotional control). They describe what the text does, not the teacher’s intent. Hassan notes that not every group uses every item. Source: Steven Hassan, BITE Model, Freedom of Mind.

  • Behavior: can route questions through the evangelist. “Please send the questions you have to your evangelist.” Surprises are saved for the next one-on-one.
  • Behavior: can tie Scripture to attendance. “When you don’t come to small group, you’re missing a key part of the class.”
  • Information: can limit trust in other teaching (our reading). Gardens in Isaiah 1:29 are “Gentile churches”. In our reading, this places other churches with the destroyers.
  • Thought: can make one place the answer. “What is that place of salvation at the second coming?” The answer given is “Mount Zion.”

The prophecy of swords beaten into plowshares in Isaiah 2:4 is not a control technique in itself.

Go deeper

Scripture quotations are from the NET Bible. Bible Vaccine Center and Closer Look Initiative are run by the same team.